3 ms·
>Given the absence of "higher-level" constructs, the resulting OS will never be as complex as something like an NT kernel i wonder whether you've worked with F
by trhway 9y ago
>Given the absence of "higher-level" constructs, the resulting OS will never be as complex as something like an NT kernel
i wonder whether you've worked with Forth - in my view of Forth (spent 1987-89 mostly in Forth running on 8088 clone based terminal of USSR clone of IBM 360, so Forth is my second language after mandatory Pascal and the first true "computer" love really) what you said is a huge advantage and natural characteristic of Forth, not a deficiency. Everything in the Forth world is like Salvador Dali's clock face plates - flexible/pliable/flowing and you build whatever "higher-level" constructs and complexity levels you need right now and leave them behind the moment you don't need them anymore, create and destroy worlds as you go... In comparison to that the static monstrosity like NT kernel is just dead dusty world of an ancient complex tech civilization who died off under the weight of its own complex tech.
To Cyph0n below: man, as an enterprise programmer for 25 years i completely understand and agree with you. As that Forth programmer enjoying it 3 decades ago i can only say to you - you just don't get it :)
- Cyph0n 9y agoThat was an analogy attempting to explain what OKAD does. The kernel represents the circuit being designed, while the assembler represents the OKAD toolchain. The goal of the analogy was to demonstrate that OKAD is not suitable for designing large circuits, just like using assembly to write a modern kernel is not practical.
- evincarofautumn 9y agoWell, presumably it’s not meant to be suitable for designing large/complex circuits, but rather to solve just the specific problems that Moore had when he wanted to make a chip. That’s an essential part of Forth philosophy: write only and exactly what you need. Forth itself is designed this way, to be the minimal useful tool you can bootstrap in a few dozen instructions on a chip with almost no resources.