3 ms·
>51% of Democrats support a law that requires Americans use transgender people’s preferred gender pronouns. This one blows my mind. A law that punishes people
by irrational 9y ago
>51% of Democrats support a law that requires Americans use transgender people’s preferred gender pronouns.
This one blows my mind. A law that punishes people if they don't use certain words? I just... I can't even... Wow.
- tree_of_item 9y agoNot just certain words, but words that defy basic observations about reality. It's really incredible.
- matt_wulfeck 9y agoI’ve started calling it the war on words.
- maxxxxx 9y agoWe are starting to apply the techniques of Newspeak from 1984. By eliminating certain words from the language you can't even think incorrect thoughts anymore.
- 2K17 9y agoThey banned ad banners with attractive people having nice toned bodies in London Tube, too bad you cannot outlaw being attractive in real life :).
- civilian 9y agoYou'd enjoy "Harrison Bergeron", a short story by Kurt Vonnegut http://www.tnellen.com/cybereng/harrison.html http://www.tnellen.com/cybereng/harrison.html
- mywittyname 9y agoThis has been the case for a while. For better or worse, we no longer use "archaic" terms, instead they've been replaced with more culturally appropriate terms that appear to have identical meanings. Mentally retarded -> mentally challenged/disabled has always kind of baffled me as either can be used as an insult. Oriental -> East Asian always baffled me too, but not being Asian myself. But I guess it's because we don't call the West the Occidental.
- sievebrain 9y agoWell let's try to understand it. This view must be rooted in the idea that such people have chosen their gender, and therefore chosen their gender pronoun. To not use it then would be like refusing to call someone by their preferred name. I don't know of widespread cases where people refuse to call others by their name after a name change, but I can imagine that if I changed my name and people refused to use my new name I would find that annoying. That said some trans people seem to want to introduce entirely new pronouns that didn't previously exist. That feels like overreach to me. Changing such a basic part of the language by force is not something to take lightly. Edit: to clarify, I would not support such a law myself!
- bsbechtel 9y agoI think the issue is using the law to punish people for not agreeing to do this.
- hrefjedd 9y agoThis is really interesting because for example my mother tongue (hungarian) doesn't have grammatical genders. Like it's non existent (unlike in english, german, or any other germanic language).
- whiddershins 9y agoAnnoying should not equal illegal.
- irrational 9y agoWanting people to call you by a certain pronoun isn't the issue at all. Its creating a law that punishes people if they don't call you by your chosen pronoun. A law. Seriously, a law. I'm trying to think of any other laws that punish people if they don't say certain words.
- mFixman 9y agoThere are already hate crime laws against other minorities.
- boznz 9y agoMy Wife will be first in the slammer, English is her second language and she often gets he and she mixed up..
- ggggtez 9y agoStudy looks like it's not scientifically rigorous. But believe whatever you want.
- pwtweet 9y agoWhat blows my mind is that you believe it. From the same report what White American's (Conservatives's) think/believe: “The political climate is focused on repressing Caucasians, especially white males.” “I believe that BLM and Antifa are terrorist groups and are as antithetical to the United States as any neo-Nazi group or white nationalist group.” “I don’t believe climate change is happening because of humans.” “I work in a totally PC environment and if I dare state that I feel homosexuality or sexual promiscuity is not in line with what the Bible teaches, I feel attacked and accused of being insensitive.” “Blacks can have things that are just for them, but no one else can.”
- irrational 9y agoBut, those are just about beliefs. None of those have to do with the establishment of laws. 51% of democrats (a majority!) want to establish a law punishing people for not using the right words.
- cafard 9y agoAnd 74% of Whigs support a law that requires Americans to believe obviously improbable poll results. That's why I'm voting with either the Anti-Masonic party or the Free Soil party next election. OK. Sorry for the snark. But I find this wholly improbable.
- civilian 9y ago"if you don't have data, you're just another person with an opinion"
- awinder 9y agoLets not cherry-pick here, 65% of Republicans want to fire people for bending a knee.
- irrational 9y agoThat's not the same thing as creating a law. It's the creation of a law that is the issue.