5 ms·
Democracy does seem to have a problem delivering fiscal responsibility, it's too easy to put it off for the next government.
by tonyedgecombe 9y ago
Democracy does seem to have a problem delivering fiscal responsibility, it's too easy to put it off for the next government.
- jacobush 9y agoThe problem is larger than fiscal. It’s about long term thinking in general. We have no common cause, vision or “myth” to gather round.
- rralian 9y agoI was thinking this the other day actually. That we are generally best served when people extrapolate their interests for the long term. And this is a big part of religion and faith. But they don't always help people value the collective long-term interest.
- ams6110 9y agoCommon rallying causes have been systematically dismantled. You can't be patriotic because our history isn't perfect. You can't be religious because it might offend someone. God and country have been the common denominators of our culture and they are no longer seen as relevant, and there is nothing else to replace them. It seems like we are more interested in finding and emphasizing all the ways we are different from each other rather than rallying around anything we might have in common.
- alphaalpha101 9y agoIf you think Americans aren't patriotic or religious you really need to get out more. Americans are incredibly patriotic and religious and very proud of being so, compared to any other western country. To us, it seems insane how patriotic and religious you guys are.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> You can't be patriotic because our history isn't perfect. This is untrue; very few people have a problem with patriotism. Lots of people have a problem with various forms of nationalism, but none of that is about imperfection of history except insofar as certain breeds of nationalism center around glorifying and recreating bad aspects of history. > You can't be religious because it might offend someone. While this has always been true to an extent for faiths other than than that of the most dominant local form of Christianity, it is less true (not more) now than in the past.
- toasterlovin 9y ago> This is untrue; very few people have a problem with patriotism. Look, I come from the left. Growing up, there was definitely the sense that it is in poor taste to express enthusiasm about America or being an American. That it was something reserved for red necks who drive pick up trucks. The American flag, as a symbol, was considered gauche and the only time you would wear anything with the flag on it is if you were being self-consciously ironic. There was no sense that America was great. Instead, the focus was almost exclusively on America's flaws.
- danans 9y agoThis critique is overly focused on shallow aesthetics ("gauche", "pickup-trucks"), which really have nothing to do with patriotism, and more to do with some kind of tribal name-calling, which I'm sure takes place on both left on right. It is just as patriotic to acknowledge and grapple with a country's flaws as it is to express pride in one's country. There's no contradiction between the two.
- toasterlovin 9y agoIn my experience, there is a deep vein of antipathy toward America on the left. I brought up condescension toward the flag because I think it is emblematic of that antipathy. I mean, the flag is just about the purest symbolic representation of America that exists. So if your attitude toward it is that you wouldn’t deign to adorn yourself or anything you own with it, and you disparage it as fitting only of some lower class, what viable interpretation of that fact is there other than that you feel negatively about the thing which it represents? Or perhaps another way to think of it: if you had a friend who, every time a certain person came up, immediately started to enumerate that person’s flaws, what would you conclude about their feelings toward that person?
- mywittyname 9y agoI don't think its offense that has killed traditional religion. After all, the religious types have traditionally been one of the loudest political groups in the US. People willing to hold up signs with dead babies to send a political message don't appear to care about offending others. I definitely see that Christianity is getting less-and-less relevant in the US (as it has been in most other Western nations), but it seems like patriotism is its replacement, the Constitution is the new Bible and the founding fathers are the new apostles.
- saas_co_de 9y agoaccording to most of the histories I have read monarchs and dictators have not been well known for fiscal responsibility either so I am not sure if this is a democracy problem.
- chestervonwinch 9y agoYou can't logically conclude that it's not a democracy problem simply because you named a separate condition that implies lack of fiscal responsibility.
- saas_co_de 9y agoyes, but if fiscal irresponsibility is present in democracies, monarchies, dictatorships, corporations of all sizes, and of course individuals, then on what basis would you claim that democracy has a unique problem with fiscal irresponsibility?
- emodendroket 9y agoWhere's the system that doesn't have this problem, I guess is my question.
- maxerickson 9y agoHere in the US it is evident that we have plenty of resources available, the "supply" part of the economy is working great. There are people that have limited access to this fountain of goods, probably for multiple reasons. There's an argument to be made that making a number bigger in a ledger for the sake of increasing access to that fountain of goods is not a "crisis".
- Retric 9y ago200+% inflation rates destroy the meaning of any such ledger really quickly. The US had 17% inflation rates* fairly recently and just avoided that cliff. Higest short term rate listed: 23.7% in june 1920. http://www.usinflationcalculator.com/inflation/historical-inflation-rates/ http://www.usinflationcalculator.com/inflation/historical-in...
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> The US has 17% inflation rates fairly recently I'll bite. What's your source.
- daxorid 9y ago17% is a little high, but I'm guessing the GP is referring to 1980: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Early_1980s_recession#Inflation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Early_1980s_recession#Inflatio...
- Retric 9y agoAnnual inflation capped at "1980 soared to 13.5%", but the inflation rate spiked above that in the same year. http://www.usinflationcalculator.com/inflation/historical-inflation-rates/ http://www.usinflationcalculator.com/inflation/historical-in... lists a peak of 14.8% but if have seen 17% elsewhere. 1917-1920 had some periods over 20%.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- alphaalpha101 9y ago'Fiscal responsibility' is not a meaningful concept.
- emodendroket 9y agoOr, more cynically, you can deliberately create fiscal crisis conditions to justify cutting programs you wanted to get rid of in the first place.
- topspin 9y agoThe cynic in me believes that sort of scheme is SOP in the US. Here are CA lawmakers back in 2003 weighing the benefits of prolonging the budget crisis for leverage to push through tax increases: http://articles.latimes.com/2003/jul/22/local/me-budget22 http://articles.latimes.com/2003/jul/22/local/me-budget22
- peoplewindow 9y agoDon't over-generalise from the USA. There are plenty of democracies that run balanced budgets and thus don't have a deficit, or even run a surplus. For example, Germany, Switzerland. The UK government has won the last three elections on a backdrop of "we're going to cut spending still further to try and balance the budget" and voters supported that. The USA is actually somewhat unusual amongst democracies in how little effort there truly is to reign in spending. The Republicans seem to have lost any ability to enact real policy. Only the Dems seem able to make major changes to US society and it's always in the direction of more spending. When the Reps get in, they seem too weak, too divided and too beholden to the military to pass any real spending cuts.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoThe UK government has won the last three elections on a backdrop of "we're going to cut spending still further to try and balance the budget" and voters supported that. What they promised and what they delivered were two different things.
- peoplewindow 9y agoThe deficit has halved. They promised it'd fall even faster than it did, but my point stands - democracy is not incompatible with responsible spending.