3 ms·
Perhaps (and I realize I'm being devil's advocate here), "photo-journalist" is no longer a profession where one should expect to make a living? Photographers c
by rwmj 9y ago
Perhaps (and I realize I'm being devil's advocate here), "photo-journalist" is no longer a profession where one should expect to make a living? Photographers can still work for commissions or for the pure joy of it, but these days everyone carries a camera and can take decent photos of news and sports events.
- chris_wot 9y agoWell, no... many photojournalists spend a huge amount of money in equipment and go to places others won’t venture. Copyright get, limits, however, are way too long. They should be maximum 25 years IMO.
- rwmj 9y agoI'm guessing that's more of a commission basis, rather than journalists going on-spec to warzones and hoping to sell the photos. And if not, then they could move to a commission / work-for-hire model and still make a living.
- tomatocracy 9y agoFreelancing for sports photography has been common for a long time. Many photographers covering an event but only one may get the picture which illustrates the key point scored/etc well (because luck and skill both play a part). As to "why not replace that with photos from the public" - with press accreditation they can sit court-side and have space to use large lenses, monopods etc. All that equipment and access costs money, and it's not just a one-off cost either (on the equipment side competition also drives quality up meaning upgrading equipment relatively frequently is required, and it does wear out over time as well) - hence the cost of the "best" photos will always be higher than random crowd pics in a functioning market (which needs copyright protection).
- rwmj 9y agoThis is the same sort of argument as "horses require expensive stabling, food and years of training". All true, but that didn't stop horses from becoming obsolete as a mode of transport, in the same way that I'm suggesting photo-journalists may become obsolete because technology and the internet makes their jobs less and less necessary. What happens when cameras get so good and cheap that photos from the crowd are as good as the ones from beside the court? Or we can place numerous nearly-free court-side cameras operated by AIs to capture everything?
- stinkytaco 9y agoIt also doesn't mean that horses becoming obsolete means you can just use anyone's horse.
- tomatocracy 9y agoIt's a market, same as any other, and there's a cost-quality curve same as many markets. That curve might move over time but it won't change the fact that the people who own the images get to decide on what terms they are used and the people who own the court get to decide who they let in with cameras and to where (and if they install your nice AI cameras to replace the freelance photojournalists they currently let in, that may well raise the market price because they've just created a nice little monopoly for themselves). I don't get to go and ride someone else's horse for free whenever I feel like it just because cars exist.
- 2muchcoffeeman 9y agoThat doesn't make sense. Even if that were the case, what gives you the right to just use someone else's work for a profit? And why does a major studio get to decide that people no longer need to be paid for taking photos?
- rwmj 9y agoThe alternative is that we need to have a complex system of payments and invasive DRM/spyware to monitor everything posted. People will share these photos widely anyway, but occasionally and randomly someone will be sued for $150,000 per violation and have to defend against that. Is that a good trade-off for keeping a few photo-journalists in business?
- 2muchcoffeeman 9y agoWell, if everybody has a decent camera these days, they why not just ask amateurs to submit photos in return for attribution and a small prize to the next event or cash reward if their photo gets chosen? There's no need to hire photo journalists if you really don't want to. Also no need to use their work (for a profit!) without asking or paying because you decided it was unnecessary.
- detaro 9y agoDoes your imagined copyright reform target only photojournalists, or all creators? It's also not a pure choice between your two extremes. There are various tools that could be used to push this towards a more reasonable middle ground. E.g. through some level of standardization for claim levels, incentives to solve conflicts without actual lawsuits, ... In this specific case, I find the argument "photography isn't as valuable anymore" not very convincing. If the specific pictures have low value, there was no need to use them without permission. That the photographer likely is incentivised to start with high claimed damages to then get a lower sum in a side-deal sounds like a general bug in how these cases tend to work in the US, copyright-related or not, and should be fixed elsewhere.
- Joeboy 9y ago
- cowsandmilk 9y agoThat is an irrelevant argument. If a news outlet wants to rely on images taken by the public, they are free to do so. And many outlets have moved towards that. That doesn't mean that they should be free to take images a professional photographer has taken at an event and use them willy-nilly. 247 Sports likely used Tannen's photos because they were better than ones that could be gotten for free from fans in the crowd. If you want the better photos, pay up.
- rwmj 9y ago> If a news outlet wants to rely on images taken by the public, they are free to do so. In fact they're not free to do so, not the way that copyright currently works.