4 ms·
How strongly do you feel about the GPL2 license (edit: for the kernel pieces)? Would you be willing to dual-license it under the BSD as well?
by loeg 9y ago
How strongly do you feel about the GPL2 license (edit: for the kernel pieces)? Would you be willing to dual-license it under the BSD as well?
- zx2c4 9y agoThe kernel code is for Linux, which is already GPLv2, so I don't think it would help you much there. The userspace implementation is also GPLv2 at the moment. What motivations do you have for desiring a BSD license? Plans to make non-free software?
- jlgaddis 9y agoAn in-kernel {Free,Open}BSD implementation is my first thought.
- loeg 9y agoPorting to FreeBSD, where new GPL2 code in base is verboten. Whether you consider FreeBSD non-free or not is a matter of opinion. Even if the existing kernel implementation is highly tied to Linux, it is legally problematic for FreeBSD developers to reference GPL2 code while writing BSD-licensed code.
- zx2c4 9y agoI think for FreeBSD kernel-land, there will have to be significant rewrites, anyway, since the Linux code is fairly Linux-specific. At some point though, I'd love to do a kernel implementation for the BSDs (in addition to the userspace one, which is coming much sooner), and I suppose you could expect for that to be BSD-licensed, appropriately.
- loeg 9y ago> I think for FreeBSD kernel-land, there will have to be significant rewrites, anyway, since the Linux code is fairly Linux-specific. Probably true! > At some point though, I'd love to do a kernel implementation for the BSDs If BSD developers can reference the Linux implementation's source, it is easier for them to go ahead and do it independently :-). Do you anticipate having time to do a BSD kernel implementation soon yourself, or is it just a would-be-nice idea on the infinite TODO list? I'm trying to gauge whether we should wait for you or try and do it ourselves.
- justabystander 9y agoIt might not be about commercializing so much as including it in some of the *BSDs which don't allow for GPL code in the core. Otherwise, they'll probably have to write a new implementation. But yes, there is that risk.
- j_s 9y agoBased on progress demonstrated since June 2016, I'd say not any time soon. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11996465 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11996465
- loeg 9y agoI'll keep asking ;-).