3 ms·
Doesn't 91% seem far too low to be useful for the general population? Consider that only 7% of the background population experiences one or more depressive epi
by loeg 9y ago
Doesn't 91% seem far too low to be useful for the general population? Consider that only 7% of the background population experiences one or more depressive episode per year[0] (edit: okay maybe 8% in youth). Assuming independence and using the higher 8% background rate figure for youth, .91 * .08 = 7.3% of the population will receive a true positive result and (1-.91) * (1-.08) = 8.3% of the population will receive a false positive result. This is "pretty bad" — false positives outweigh the true positives — making the value of a positive result useless.
(Consider what happens to people so-diagnosed as suicidal when in fact they are not (false positives). Involuntary psychiatric imprisonment is a terrible thing if it isn't absolutely necessary.)
[0]: https://www.healthline.com/health/depression/facts-statistics-infographic https://www.healthline.com/health/depression/facts-statistic...
- hk__2 9y ago> I don't have the stats grounding to come up with the proportion of true positives to false positives, but I suspect this would be "pretty bad" — vastly more false positives than true positives IANAStatistician, but let’s consider the system is right 91% of the time and we try to detect those 7% you mentioned. Let’s take 1000 people. 70 people are depressive and 930 aren’t. Out of those, 700.91=63 will be correctly classified as depressive by the system and 9300.91=846 will be correctly classified as non-depressive. That leaves us with 63 positives, 846 negatives, 7 false negatives and 84 false positives. False positives largely outnumber false negatives, but they also outnumber the true positives. (if a statistician read this, please correct me if I’m wrong)
- loeg 9y agoYeah. I came to largely the same conclusion but used the 8% number for youth, given the current title.
- PeachPlum 9y agoIsn't the point of research to advance science one step at a time, not go from "does this look promising" to "yes, it works perfectly 100% of the time" in a single quantum leap.