4 ms·
My first thought is there are three possible explanations for this. 1. Apple is not concerned about increasing demand with reviews because there is already a b
by slg 9y ago
My first thought is there are three possible explanations for this.
1. Apple is not concerned about increasing demand with reviews because there is already a backlog of orders that exceeds supply. This is similar to Tesla's anti-selling of the Model 3 in favor of a product that already has wide supply.
2. Apple was really making last minute hardware and software changes that prevented them from producing a large number of review units ahead of time.
3. Apple knows there are flaws in the phone and wants to limit the amount of time a reviewer might have in order to discover those flaws before the first publish date.
Considering Apple's history, that they still provided week long review windows for a handful of sources, and none of those sources are particularly technical device reviewers, I would lean towards option 3.
Is there any other possible explanation for this change?
- lolsal 9y agoI would say there may be many more possible explanations than you listed here. We cannot know, only speculate.
- IBM 9y agoThe idea that anything reviewers write will have any measurable impact on iPhone sales is laughable. Can reviews or other media coverage kill a startup? Sure. It happened to Juicero. An Apple product is like a Star Wars movie, it doesn't matter what anyone writes, people are going to see it. Nobody really intermediates between Apple's relationship with customers, and that's been proven over and over again (most recently with The Verge's months long campaign painting the removal of the headphone jack as "user hostile").
- slg 9y agoWill bad reviews kill an Apple/Star Wars release, obviously not. That however doesn't mean that reviews don't have any effect. Otherwise why would these companies go through the process of giving out review devices or holding critic screenings? Or why would all these reviews get so much traffic if their content had no effect on the reader's ultimate buying decision?
- IBM 9y agoIt's obvious why they're doing it, they're a business. Why wouldn't they try to maximize buzz for their product? It may help on the margins but it's not at all like some startup. Apple is a 41 year old company and an established brand. They're a known quantity to customers and there is already a relationship there. Their experience with past Apple products will have more impact on their decision than any review will.
- aetherson 9y agoCompanies, and maybe more so executives, live and die on the margins. Would bad reviews for the iPhone X sink Apple as a going concern? Certainly not. Might they result in missing guidance for the quarter? Possibly, and that would cause the stock to fall and a lot of people to be upset -- even though Apple would still be a hugely valuable, profitable, going concern.
- Eric_WVGG 9y agoI was thinking about the reception of the latest Apple Watch ("Series 3"). The Watch had some issues with Wifi common-use scenarios that Apple testers failed to anticipate (obviously they wouldn't want these devices connecting to random coffeeshop hubs, etc.); this resulted in many of the reviewers having ongoing connection problems, which led to a lot of "this will be really cool when they work out the kinks" reviews. Compare to the early work on iPhone X: a bunch of "normals" just gushing about how cool it is. The initial messaging is undeniably better. Personally, I chalk it up to an experiment that they can afford, largely due to your #1 observation.
- ecesena 9y agoI wrote about the Watch here, if you're interested. https://hackernoon.com/im-returning-my-apple-watch-3-cellular-602d24899bfd https://hackernoon.com/im-returning-my-apple-watch-3-cellula...
- ecesena 9y agoI see I’m getting downvoted and don’t really understand why, the parent comment asks about experience with the watch and I was sharing mine with the cellular version. I could copy & paste the article here, but what’s the point of the www then.
- Doxin 9y agoThe GP comment is'n /about/ the apply watch. Plugging your review on a comment that's only tangentially related to the apple watch might come off as crass self-advertising to some.
- jen729w 9y ago> 2. Apple was really making last minute hardware and software changes that prevented them from producing a large number of review units ahead of time. Apple was not making “last minute” changes to this hardware. This hardware was locked in at least six months ago.
- aetherson 9y agoThis is certainly true, but I suppose it's possible that they were making last minute changes to the hardware 6 months ago (or whenever was the deadline to get it locked), and as a result don't have very many review units until this week. That said, I don't think that the numbers here are all that plausible. Maybe if they only gave out 50 or 100 review phones, we might say they were supply-constrained, but surely they can't be so supply-constrained that they could only give out a dozen.
- slg 9y agoThis was basically my thinking behind saying it was an unlikely scenario. "Last minute" doesn't mean they were literally deciding the hardware days before shipping the units out. It meant they were making changes right up to their deadline limiting supply and/or quality of review units. This applies the same to software although the "last minute" there is obviously later than it would be for hardware. It is possible the software was not tuned as finely as Apple likes as early as Apple wanted hence why the review units went to reviewers who likely wouldn't be as technical as some of the more traditional tech press.