3 ms·
I think it is reasonable to question their competency. I think we all do it to an extent with coworkers. The mistake is concluding it based on this type of sca
by BeetleB 9y ago
I think it is reasonable to question their competency. I think we all do it to an extent with coworkers.
The mistake is concluding it based on this type of scant information.
You treat it like any other unknown. You investigate deeper. If you work with the person for a while, you'll know his reasoning abilities far better than the information you gleaned from that hat.
>If someone walked in with a young earth creationist hat I would similarly question their ability to think critically (and have a hard time not just categorizing them as stupid).
And yet I've worked with a young earth creationist who was the best coder in his team (the rest of whom were not creationists). From my general experiences in life, his example is not much of an outlier.
Science Nobel laureates have believed in stupid things, as did many well known mathematicians of the past. Given that, why would you question his abilities?
- fossuser 9y agoI think that's fair and it's important to dig deeper. People in the past did believe stupid things, but it's also a mixture of what information was available to them at the time to reason about. Some ideas that may have been the best option at the time should be discarded today given that we know more. I'd think if you brought those people from the past to today they may discard some of their ideas (though changing your mind is hard). It's not that a creationist can't be a good programmer - people seem to be able to apply their reasoning abilities selectively and I've met smart religious people that jump through crazy hoops to justify why they're religious. It is a data point against them though and it would reduce my impression of their intelligence.
- AlexandrB 9y ago> I'd think if you brought those people from the past to today they may discard some of their ideas (though changing your mind is hard). Possible, but unlikely for any beliefs they hold dear. And thinking that other people stick to crazy beliefs because they are less smart than you is a great way to end up with a lot of crazy beliefs yourself. After all, why would you ever question them? You're too smart to believe something crazy! "Science progresses one funeral at a time." -- Max Planck
- fossuser 9y agoI don't think people stick to crazy beliefs because they're not as smart as I am - I think sticking to old/comfortable beliefs is a problem in general with how our minds work and something you have to fight against basically all the time, it's the default behavior. Part of the way of doing that is trying to evaluate what evidence is available and update how you think accordingly. It's when people refuse to do this that it's a problem (or worse when they think they're doing it, but really they're just trying to come up with 'evidence' for what they already believe to be true). It should be a struggle towards whatever is true - not trying to prove what you already believe to be true. I think it's sad that so much time and effort is spent spinning in circles when we could make so much more progress if we were collectively able to fix these issues with how we think.
- subsection1h 9y agowhy would you question his abilities? Biblical literalists have no regard for empirical evidence. You mention scientists having stupid beliefs. Scientists develop evidence-based explanations of phenomena through experimentation using available tools. Our tools are obviously imperfect; thus, imperfect observations are made and imperfect explanations can form as a result. Biblical literalists, on the other hand, don't even try to ensure that their beliefs are supported by empirical evidence. People have argued that this behavior of biblical literalists is limited to issues relating to their religious beliefs only, so as long as their professional responsibilities don't encompass issues relating to their religious beliefs, there's no problem. Unfortunately, the beliefs of biblical literalists encompass a wide range of issues. If I run a renewable energy company, do I really want to take a chance by hiring a biblical literalist who might now, or someday, believe that his unsubstantiated god wants humans to use fossil fuels[1] or that climate change isn't real because his unsubstantiated god promised to not flood the Earth[2]? No, thanks, I think I'll pass. [1] http://dailysignal.com/2017/10/20/trumps-epa-chief-charts-new-course-interview-scott-pruitt/ http://dailysignal.com/2017/10/20/trumps-epa-chief-charts-ne... [2] https://www.politico.com/story/2010/11/shimkus-cites-genesis-on-climate-044958 https://www.politico.com/story/2010/11/shimkus-cites-genesis...
- RightMillennial 9y agoSo you're saying that you would reject otherwise qualified candidates based on their religion (a protected class in the U.S.), which is illegal?
- creaghpatr 9y agoAnd how would you figure out if someone was a biblical literalist or a garden variety Christian or an athiest anyway, unless it’s somehow relevant to work?
- CalChris 9y agoIt’s not illegal for me to reject non-Flying Spaghetti Monsterarians on the basis of their religion. It is unconstitutional for the govmint to do so.