7 ms·
Techies are famously apolitical. Nose-down in the code is where most of them like it, and as long as they can make the big bucks or work on interesting stuff a
by pmoriarty 9y ago
Techies are famously apolitical. Nose-down in the code is where most of them like it, and as long as they can make the big bucks or work on interesting stuff at the likes of Facebook, Apple or Google, they'll avoid thinking too hard about the ethics of what they're enabling.
- Apocryphon 9y agoThat's the way things have been for a very long time. And yet, isn't the tech industry all about changing the way things are?
- vkou 9y agoI think after 25 years of the internet experiment, it's safe to say that the tech industry is all about changing who is rich, and who isn't. We've rebuilt all the same power structures, but with different players. We could have had a cultural renaissance, a democratization of information and thought. Instead, we got a plague of click-bait tabloids, echo chambers, walled gardens, algorithmic gatekeepers, and television that you don't need a cable subscription for.
- FilterSweep 9y ago> we got a plague of click-bait tabloids, echo chambers, walled gardens, algorithmic gatekeepers, and television that you don't need a cable subscription for. Exactly. It was a decision made for Internet users, on behalf of Internet users, _but not BY Internet Users_. It appears there was debate in the 90s/00s going on, far above our heads whether any given connection to the Internet is to be considered a highly-modularm, highly-democratized "Terminal" or the individual "Pseudonym". Where "Pseudonym" here is the ever-growing bag of personal data, fingerprinting, ISP info, History, Cookies, etc. etc. that distinguishes you from your twin brother/sister). Instead of Advertising Industry crafting a better message that appeals to the User of any given Terminal, Advertising Industry instead decided to collect as much data on everyone as possible, and infect their pages with invasive malware peddling wares they (usually) don't even need. Mark Z. made his stance absurdly clear with his identity talks, and generally the rest of the Big Players followed. And analytic and advertising systems being built upon the "Pseudonym" approach creates a plethora of unsustainable clickbait drivel.
- pmoriarty 9y agoAdvertisers were tracking users on the web ever since the cookie was invented, which was long before Mark Z came on the scene. He's just been particularly flagrant and open about his contempt for privacy -- or rather, for the privacy of his company's users. I'm sure he still wants and and can buy privacy for himself, his family, and others he cares about.
- rafiki6 9y agoI really don't get the facebook hate...the internet != facebook. You can opt out of using Facebook. You can use private connections and browsers to make sure you aren't being tracked by facebook. Facebook is non-essential. If you are worried about your privacy don't use it. The rest of the World Wide Web is still there.
- pmoriarty 9y agoYou underestimate how central communication over Facebook has become for some segments of the population. All their friends are on FB. All their family is on FB. Business associates are on FB. Their hobbies and news are on Facebook, and on and on and on. Sure. They could opt out of that, just as some people opted out of having a telephone in their homes back when it was the primary mode of communication -- but they were so few that one was considered strange for not having one. Of course, the objections to using Facebook are much stronger than they've ever been for having even a television, nevermind a telephone. Yet most people can't seem to tear themselves away. Not that they'd want to. They've got everything they need on Facebook, don't they?
- karllager 9y agoI wholeheartedly concur. Most people see the problem of power in that they don't have it. I believe, fewer people understand, that power itself is the problem, and not its particular location in a point in time. > We could have had a cultural renaissance, a democratization of information and thought. I have hopes, that we will see a new mindset in the coming decades, which looks back at our times and recognises its primitive state. There are ways to give the power back to people and raise them in ways that encourage benevolent cooperation and progress.
- jerkstate 9y agoI think that's a pretty pessimistic view. There is more information available for auto-didacts than ever before, and it's easier than ever to find a community of people with common interests, no matter what those interests are. Some of what's new is bad, but none of the bad stuff is actually new.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sidlls 9y agoThe thing is they don't really make "the big bucks." Bigger than typical, sure, but not "big" in the sense usually meant by the phrase. Some lucky few do, same as in any other industry.
- kobeya 9y agoSalaries in the range of $200k/yr, plus benefits, is not big bucks?
- sidlls 9y agoNot in the sense that it leads to financial independence, no. A person earning this salary is still usually one relativley minor catastrophe away from bankruptcy. Also, these salaries aren't sustained: bubbles exist, and thousands of developers won't make those salaries consistently.
- TulliusCicero 9y agoIt can easily lead to financial independence if you're even moderately frugal instead of goldfishing your paycheck. Just look at /r/financialindependence, most posters aren't bringing in 500k+ a year or whatever, they're mostly upper-middle class professionals who live a middle-middle class lifestyle.
- sidlls 9y agoFinancial independence means they could quit today, not have a single change in their lifestyle, and remain insulated from catastrophe (e.g. medical illness) destroying that ability. It doesn't mean $1M in the 401k and a couple of residential houses they rent out.
- dahdum 9y agoIt means they could quit today, and be able to comfortably live the rest of their life without earned income. It doesn't mean the exact same lifestyle - many people plan to retire early to LCOL areas. Especially in that subreddit(1). You're right about the 401k - that $1M doesn't help too much until you hit retirement age. You need substantial unearned income or enough principle to draw down to be FI. 1. FatFIRE targets $4M-$7M, and is closer to your definition.(https://www.reddit.com/r/fatFIRE/ https://www.reddit.com/r/fatFIRE/)
- clairity 9y agothat's simply not true. at the very least, you need to separate politics from policy in your quip. many techies i've met are keenly interested in policy discussions (how to design better systems). fewer seem to be interested in politics (the jockeying of individuals for power). but even then, i'm not sure the mean and deviation around those two poles warrant generalizations like yours.
- Bartweiss 9y agoI think a lot of this perception really just stems from how many programmers aren't conveniently aligned along the American political axis. There's a strong tendency to say that anyone who doesn't have an easily-legible stance "isn't political", but that elides the difference between "doesn't care" and "isn't compatible with the existing political options". Even on "politics versus policy", I meet some programmers who limit themselves to policy based on lack of political interest, and some who limit themselves based on lack of political options. If you're something like left-libertarian or a privacy-supporting technocrat, modern US parties have roughly nothing to offer you. Those views aren't just outside the mainstream, but perpendicular to it. You can't just try to pull the Democrats left or the Republicans right to reach your views, you have to hope for some complex multi-directional change. Many of the most political programmers I know have one of those positions. So they lobby against SOPA, or push for pollution taxes over caps, but they don't see much value in advocating for any of the existing players. (Of course, programmers are also just normal people; all of these generalizations are best understood not as actually common but as how programmers diverge from the mainstream when they do diverge.)
- clairity 9y agoyah, no one is really aligned with conventional political parties, because we're trying to squeeze 230 million voting-age citizens (in the US) into (effectively) 2 increasingly disconnected boxes. political parties seem to have detached themselves from the common citizen as they chase moneyed donors (who themselves have concentrated in the past few decades). power is consolidating along many dimensions, and that's both disconcerting and isolating to us ordinary citizens.
- kiliantics 9y agoThere's no such thing as apolitical. If you aren't doing anything about the state of things as they are, it just means that you are comfortable with things as they are. Techies just don't care much about the rest of society because they got theirs and they think they deserve it - that anyone else could just as easily be in their position, so if they're not then it must be their own fault.