8 ms·
Why Amsterdam Works So Well for Bikes
- jseliger 9y agoInterestingly, too, virtually any American city could copy all five.
- rb808 9y agoYou missed temperate climate. Yes there is a picture of snow but its rare. As are hot humid days where you get soaked just standing in the shade - which are all too common in much of the US.
- ced 9y agoMontreal is one of North America's top city for biking and has one of the worst climates for it. People adjust in all kinds of ways. It's mostly about density and culture IMO.
- ballenf 9y agoCold is much easier to handle on a bike than heat/humidity. You can wear warmer clothes and take them off at work, but you usually can't shower and change into a new set of clothes.
- PascLeRasc 9y agoI have to somewhat disagree. I feel so uncomfortable biking in thick clothes and layers, and you absolutely have to cuff up your pant leg to pedal anyway, so cold wind feels awful. Not to mention pedaling through snow/slush if you're on the side of the road is very hard.
- maxerickson 9y agoLots of commuter bikes have chain guards. And with better infrastructure, the roadside slush is less of a thing.
- sampo 9y ago> pedaling through snow/slush if you're on the side of the road is very hard. Cities with good biking infrastructure also have plow trucks to keep the roads and bike paths clean on snowy mornings.
- iak8god 9y ago> you absolutely have to cuff up your pant leg to pedal anyway You absolutely do not need to cuff up your pant leg. You just need an ankle band to keep your pant leg away from the chain: https://www.amazon.com/High-Visibility-Reflective-Ankle-Strap/dp/B0006ZK8CO https://www.amazon.com/High-Visibility-Reflective-Ankle-Stra...
- sampo 9y agoIs it common that American workplaces don't have showers?
- khedoros1 9y agoMany offices don't. Mine does, but it's always struck me as a little unusual. A few people use it, but most don't. I used to use it as a changing room to change shirts when I went walking on my break.
- Broken_Hippo 9y agoYes. American workplaces rarely have showers to use. That's one of those things you are expected to do at home. I'm still a bit shocked that my temporary factory job here in Norway provides safety shoes and launders the uniforms, let alone having showers on-site to use.
- rockostrich 9y agoIt's the only thing that I don't like about my office, even though we're a start-up and I was a little surprised to learn that we didn't have any showers installed. I'm probably going to sign up for a gym near work once winter comes so that I can shower after biking in.
- bryanlarsen 9y agoYou can't just wear warmer clothes on a cold day on a bike. If you do that, you'll start sweating, and that sweat can freeze, which can drop your core body temperature dangerously fast. So you want to layer your clothing so you can take off layers as you warm up; or you can just adjust your pace to prevent sweating.
- Fricken 9y agoOn cold days I dress for what's comfortable when my blood gets moving. Which usually means freezing my ass off for the first 5 minutes of the ride. It's like taking a cold shower: you never want to do it, but afterwards you're always glad you did, you feel fresh and invigorated.
- analog31 9y agoWhat I've learned is that each one is its own beast. There are certainly more cyclists on the bike path during the summer than during the winter, but oddly enough, I see more cyclists on the coldest days, than when it's raining. Cold also comes with dark, which may factor into the equation. For whatever reason, I'm blessed with a body that doesn't sweat very much. So I handle the extremes pretty well.
- ced 9y ago> Cold is much easier to handle on a bike than heat/humidity. I'll take Austin's summers over Montreal's winters any day. Snow is cold, messy and frankly dangerous. 95% of bikers stop during the snow months, but Austin still had tons of bikers even at peak heat. You just bike slower. Most of North America has bikable weather most of the time. It's not the primary reason why people don't bike.
- dasil003 9y agoAlso Minneapolis which is similar climate except more extreme in both directions. Sometimes the bike paths are plowed before the streets!
- analog31 9y agoTemperate climate, flat terrain, shorter commutes, and supportive public transit. A lot of people ride their bikes from home to a train station, rather than all the way to work. Disclosure: I'm a bike commuter in the upper Midwest.
- MrFantastic 9y agoIt also helps that Amsterdam is flat and the population density is high.
- sushisource 9y agoYeah. That's a big one. There's a huge bike culture in Seattle and for the life of me I have a hard time understanding why, this is one of the shittiest places on the planet to bike. Hills everywhere, wet half the time.
- geephroh 9y agoAnd don't forget to mention that with all of the construction downtown over the past few years, even the premier separated cycle-tracks on 2nd and around westlake have been partially shut down and/or re-routed into traffic. A hearty thanks to our Amazon overlords...
- rockostrich 9y agoManhattan is nominally flat with a high population and yet not it is pretty terrible for bikes, although with Citi Bike it's gotten a lot better.
- gxs 9y agoQueue comments about what a travesty it is that US cities were built to accommodate the automobile. To be honest, I think it's one of the coolest things that we take for granted. I can step outside, hop into my car right now, and drive literally anywhere in the US. I drive home from the Bay Area to LA all the time and I always find this very cool. Do I think we need more public transportation? Absolutely. And more bike lines since I ride my bike to work too. While we're at it, better laws to protect cyclists and public facilities for bike storage and repair. What I'm getting at is that we should embrace multiple forms of transporation and not take for granted what we do have.
- metawhatnow 9y agoI don't take it for granted—it's a travesty I pay for your convenient transport. Parking is one of many reasons why housing density is so low across the bay compared to many other cities in the world.
- dionidium 9y agoI can step outside, hop into my car right now, and drive literally anywhere in the US. I drive home from the Bay Area to LA all the time and I always find this very cool. I don't think anybody disputes that the Interstate Highway system between cities is a modern marvel. It's what we did inside cities that's tragic.
- sampo 9y ago> I drive home from the Bay Area to LA all the time and I always find this very cool. Driving home from Bay Area to Bay Area can take 1.5 hours at a bad time of a day.
- jozzz 9y ago> I can step outside, hop into my car right now, and drive literally anywhere in the US. Where can't you do this? It's possible to drive from London to Beijing if you really want to.
- AstralStorm 9y agoAnd comparatively easy to use trains as well. Likely much more convenient, faster and safer too. Or if you do not care about climate change, a plane trip is still better than a car trip.
- pmoriarty 9y agoThe trams and tram tracks in Amsterdam is still a problem for bicycles. Cross the tracks wrong and your bike tire gets stuck in the tracks and you go head first in to the street. Trams themselves can be as deadly as cars are to bicyclists. Fortunately they are more predictable and confined to their tracks. Ideally, both trams and cars would be completely underground or above-ground, and have no possibility of collision with bicycles or pedestrians at all.
- chrisdbaldwin 9y agoCan confirm. My mother face planted in this exact way while biking in Amsterdam.
- Nanite 9y agoFor crossing tram tracks it's best to approach with an "angle of attack" greater than 30 deg. to avoid your wheels getting guided by the track slots.
- oconnore 9y agoI'm totally confident that we could replicate Amsterdam in any US city if we wanted to. But before we get there, I need an article about what to do about the fact that so many of my fellow Denver Coloradans hate: bike lanes, buses, trains, places to live, sidewalks, wind turbines, solar panels (but also normal road maintenance and traffic). It's like there is a conscious effort to create more smog and traffic jams. It is boggling. We can't even start to think about having nice things until we diagnose this particular social disorder affecting America.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mfoy_ 9y agoCall me cynical, but: Anything that threatens the current way of life, the current status quo, or is representative of a school of thought that clashes with the aforementioned can cause cognitive dissonance. Simple as that. Many people don't really believe that driving is wrong, or harmful. But supporting radical infrastructure changes to accommodate an alternative means admitting to that to a further extent that most people are comfortable with.
- mrybczyn 9y agoNothing wrong with driving. Just drive appropriately. Car sharing. Taxi / Uber. Hybrids. Electric cars. Self driving cars. The freedom to transport yourself is a powerful force for good, and socialized public transport and bikes are not a real solution in many / most places. (am a biker, love biking, only commute by bike to work 3 months of the year)
- yason 9y agoDriving with shared cars, Uber, hybrids, evs, and self-driving cars doesn't fix the one and ultimate problem with cars in cities: space. A person walking needs maybe 0.5m². Self-driving electric Uber still needs ~50-60 m² of space per vehicle in moving traffic. Plus parking. And if we allocate enough space for people to drive in the first place they can only drive to places. The distances grow too long for biking and walking.
- everdev 9y agoCulture helps a lot. In the US bikes are seen as an annoyance by many drivers. I was in Amsterdam this summer and without much knowledge of the city, found it easy, safe and fun to get around by bike. Went to Paris and Barcelona as well and didn't feel as comfortable on a bike in either of those cities.
- vvanders 9y agoThat's because most us roads aren't safe for biking. Just a couple weeks ago I was heading down 101, 55mph with blind curves and came around the corner to a pack of bikes doing 5mph uphill. I managed to slow down in time but the people behind me almost lost it. I don't know if they had a deathwish or what but I can't imagine why they thought biking on 101 was a good idea.
- the_gastropod 9y agoThis is victim blaming. If it was a stalled car that you nearly ran into, whose fault would it be? Clearly, yours. If you are traveling so fast that you cannot stop at the limits of your vision, you are diving dangerously. Full stop.
- vvanders 9y ago> If you are traveling so fast that you cannot stop at the limits of your vision ... I could stop just fine, I'm worried about the idiots behind me. Taking the moral highground doesn't help if you end up dead in the end. There's a ton of motorhomes, boats and equipment trailers on these roads. Even at 35mph they may not be able to stop in time when they are towing ~15-20k GVW. There's a large difference between being rear ended in a car and rear ended on a bicycle. One is engineered to do everything to keep you alive, the other ends up with you plastered across someone's bumper. The solution is to build these roads to be safe, however riding on them in their current state just makes the roads more dangerous for everyone.
- sampo 9y ago
- wffurr 9y agoI ride my bicycle in Boston year-round, and I found Amsterdam to be pretty stressful to bicycle in. Very crowded streets and very confusing traffic. I'm sure it was much less dangerous than Boston, but I never really adjusted to the pell mell chaos in Amsterdam. Maybe I just wasn't there long enough.
- grenoire 9y agoYou get used to it. It's a different set of skills, and your reaction times also improve over time. Hand signals help too. Although I still avoid the very center, with all the oblivious tourists walking on bicycle lanes...
- wffurr 9y agoMaybe that was it; I was one of those oblivious tourists, except trying to ride a bicycle in bicycle lanes full of other oblivious tourists. :) I had a fabulous ride out of the city to Monnickendam. That more than the city itself was amazing cycle infrastructure to me.
- Broken_Hippo 9y agoI have been that tourist. It takes a few to adjust to the heavy bicycle traffic while walking around there because it challenges the "who-goes-first" hierarchy. The states: Cars go first, and watch out. Norway (Trondheim): Pretty much walk where you will, others will stop. Amsterdam: Bicycles go first, and the others wait.
- grenoire 9y agoThe real hierarchy in Amsterdam is trams > cycles > cars > pedestrians.
- Broken_Hippo 9y agoHeh. Yeah, I forgot about the trams. Its been a bit since I've been the annoying tourist - probably time to go again :)
- hellofunk 9y agoAmsterdam's bike-friendliness is at best average compared to the rest of the Netherlands :)
- Doxin 9y agoAs a dutch person: Amsterdam is, in my opinion, a scary place to ride your bike. It's far too busy and people seem to care more about overtaking you than about safety. I can't imagine what other countries must be like if this is the pinnacle of cycling :P
- fnord77 9y agoalso it is very flat. despite the many bikes here, SF sucks for biking because of the hills
- GoToRO 9y agoWith an electric bike everything is flat :)
- jimjimjim 9y agoflat. compact. population not indoctrinated to believe that cars are avatars for their penis.
- sctb 9y agoIf you won't comment within the guidelines, please don't post at all. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- legitster 9y agoHow come none of these are about how absolutely flat Amsterdam is? I have never been to a more flat place in my life than the Netherlands. That definitely played into the decision for us to bike around everywhere while we were there, but continued to be uninterested at home.
- fulafel 9y agoCities tend to be on coasts and coastal areas are flat more often than not. It's not very unusual.
- eggie5 9y agoThe main reason why biking is so popular in Amsterdam is mostly because it's flat and secondly all the other things like cars being second-class citizens...
- peterwwillis 9y agotl;dr Bicycles are first class vehicles in Amsterdam, public transit coming in second, cars last. This will never work in America because Americans are completely obsessed with three things: 1) Living in suburbs, 2) Owning cars, and 3) Not paying for realistic public transportation. If Americans had to pay for realistic public transportation, it would be harder to afford a car, and they might not be able to live as far from their jobs as they often do now. It's not exactly a chicken-and-egg problem as much as an eat-my-cake-and-have-it-too problem. If you live in the county seat of Hunterdon County, New Jersey, you're about 50 minutes drive to Trenton, 1hr to Newark, 1.2hrs to Philadelphia. There is no real public transit to get to a bigger city (one that might have jobs). There are, however, "shuffle routes", basically small shuttles that run four or five times a day inside the county, from which you can take more shuffle routes and eventually buses and trains to get to a major city. But this is more an exception than the rule: to get into and out of Hunterdon County, you must use private transit companies like greyhound and trans-bridge. Large swaths of the country are like this, and it directly affects cities because people are coming to work in the cities in cars, or via trains and buses after they drive to them. Bikes are not really even remotely an option.
- dkarl 9y agoA pet peeve of mine is how infrastructure-oriented, and therefore how mid-to-far-future-oriented, city cycling discussions tend to be. There are people on the road right now. City planners like to assume that all current cyclists are a distinct breed of weirdos and there are no marginal gains to be made by making marginal improvements. It will take grand action to get "normal" people to ride bicycles. In truth, regular cyclists are just the tail of a larger population of people who want to bike more and drive less, and who occasionally try. Every improvement to safety and convenience means more of those people will ride for transportation more often. 1. All streets are bike streets This is already true for people who leave home on a bicycle expecting to handle all their daily business. Please consider that basically everyone who leaves home on a bike is forced to include some segments of "car" streets in their route. Planners like to imagine all of a city's cyclists moving around on the streets and paths they've specifically improved for bicyclists, like they've laid out a model train track and all the toy trains are running on it. If cyclists were restricted to traveling that way, it wouldn't be a practical means of transportation. Educate drivers and take cyclists into account in traffic engineering. Make cycling a little more tolerable now and you'll have more cyclists and more of a political mandate for infrastructure projects in the future. 2. Separated cycle tracks, not bike lanes I hate the "not" here. I know the author is describing Amsterdam, but he calls his five points a "template," and "not bike lanes" doesn't belong on any city's template for becoming bike-friendly. Bike lanes are cheap and quick to install, so put them everywhere you can spare the space. I know they're not all that safe. I've been hit in one. At the same time you work on installing bike lanes, work on the grant and bond proposals that will let you build separated cycle tracks in the future. There's grass-roots interest in cycling right now in the United States. People want to bike, and they're trying, despite the lack of infrastructure. Focusing solely on expensive, high-profile improvements that are years out is a disservice to people who are taking to the roads right now, and it could leave a lot of them with a sour taste in their mouths as they struggle to safely navigate the streets near their work and wonder why there's so much excitement about projects that even if fully completed years from now will still leave them many blocks short of their work and other nonnegotiable destinations. Bike lanes might not have a place in the future, but none of us live in the future as of yet. (I suspect planners and advocates feel pushed towards the most ambitious projects by career considerations, and I can sympathize with that. Everyone wants to be the most forward-looking. Everyone wants to have the highest hopes and standards. Everyone wants, when the future finally arrives in reality, to have been the first to get there in their heads. Everybody wants to be seen as valuing the least advantaged and most vulnerable people who will be the last (in perception, not necessarily in reality) to finally be brought onto the road by the most advanced evolution of infrastructure. Nobody wants to be associated with the suboptimal and downright dangerous compromises we will live with until then.)
- Rainymood 9y agoIn Amsterdam when you're on a bike you become a demigod. Crosswalks? Screw that. Traffic signs? Screw that. You're on a fucking bike and you're in amsterdam: you're a demigod. You are the one to rule them all, no pedestrian or car will be able to stop you! Source: Lived in Amsterdam when I was a student
- YouKnowBetter 9y agoThe "forgotten" reason why Amsterdam works so well for bikes is that they're exempt from all laws and everything & body will be prosecuted and/or lynched when one interferes with their G*d given Rights. Source: lived in the city's center for 30 years.