7 ms·
The article addresses that: "These discoveries usually concern materials that can only be produced in a laboratory environment on a very small scale. What make
by DennisP 9y ago
The article addresses that:
"These discoveries usually concern materials that can only be produced in a laboratory environment on a very small scale. What makes our invention so promising is that the technology for mass production of this material is already within reach due to its similarity to an existing production process for solar cells."
- jandrese 9y agoI have to admit I'm a bit concerned about the amount of cost savings that can be realized by building it with the same methods as solar cells. Even with the precipitous drop in solar cell prices over the past few years they still aren't cheap.
- DennisP 9y agoSure but the question is, how much of that silicon do you need for your house vs. your car battery.
- wernercd 9y agoNo... the question is how easy will it be for "Solar" companies to slide into becoming "Solar & Battery" companies. Full solution - all with Silicon. If that's possible - and they can improve the cycle count... or do it cheap enough to make up for a low cycle count... or all of it - improve it, make it cheaper AND under one roof?
- hwillis 9y agoCurrent solar panels have nothing in common with this manufacturing method. It uses a machine based on obsolete amorphous thin-film silicon solar cells. The article just indicates that the technology is understood, not that solar manufacturers can produce batteries. Even if that were true, this is a release by a company... they aren't going to give away their technology for other people to use.
- wernercd 9y agoI never said this company would "give" away the technology... nor do they honestly have to produce it themselves. That's what licensing agreements are for. I just think that if I was a solar company that could use my equipment to produce batteries as well? That would be high on the priority list to include in packages... Companies sure do love bundling things together.
- yosyp 9y agoYou wouldn't want to combine a solar cell and a battery in a single package; maybe in a modular system instead. After some amount of charge/discharge cycles the battery will quickly lose its capacity and utility. I suspect the operational lifespan of photovoltaics is much greater than the best batteries, and will continue to be for some time in the future.
- wernercd 9y agoWell, when I say "single package" I mean provided by a single company. As in a complete package: Solar panels, batteries, etc. The full deal. I would expect the battery to be in the basement/garage/etc and not on the roof with the panels.
- hwillis 9y ago>Even with the precipitous drop in solar cell prices over the past few years they still aren't cheap. By what metric..? The amount of energy and power involved in the two uses is completely different. Do you happen to know the bulk cost of silicon, or how much silicon is used in solar cells, or how much of a solar cells cost it makes up, or what process is similar? You're not doing much more than a kind of free association. For actual context, spheroidal graphite powder is up to $10,000/tonne[1] and metallurgical silicon is around a quarter of that[2]. [1] http://www.mining.com/web/battery-grade-graphite-set-for-record-year/ http://www.mining.com/web/battery-grade-graphite-set-for-rec... [2] https://www.metalbulletin.com/Article/3208513/Silicon-prices-fall-on-low-demand-in-Europe.html https://www.metalbulletin.com/Article/3208513/Silicon-prices...
- jandrese 9y agoThe article states outright that they think they can make it to market quickly by leveraging Solar Cell production facilities. The bulk cost of silicon is a moot point. That's like asking how Pizzas can be made more cheaply if you reduce the cost of the flour involved. It's the extreme precision ultra pure processing that makes it expensive, not the bulk materials.
- hwillis 9y ago> It's the extreme precision ultra pure processing that makes it expensive, not the bulk materials. Batteries don't require 6N precision. Silicon anodes can be 99% pure and work fine. Metallurgical silicon is ~99.9%. Only the bottom shelf ferrosilicon stuff is <99%. My point is that you're making assertions that you don't fully understand. Why would batteries suddenly need extreme precision ultra pure processing? That doesn't make sense. > It's the extreme precision ultra pure processing that makes it expensive, not the bulk materials. That's my whole point. The expensive part is left behind because it doesn't have anything to do with batteries. The part that's left over is fancy sand and a mylar-making machine. The same machine used to make the very cheapest solar cells, the kinds in old calculators. The kind of machine that made the monitor you're reading this on. Not the 9N part.
- deleted 9y ago