3 ms·
If $4700 in ads could sway an entire US Presidential election, that has to be the most cost-effective use of money to achieve a foreign policy objective in the
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
If $4700 in ads could sway an entire US Presidential election, that has to be the most cost-effective use of money to achieve a foreign policy objective in the history of the world.
- jrs95 9y agoPeople believing it did is probably even more damaging than the ads themselves. Undermining confidence in our democracy == undermining our democracy.
- AaronFriel 9y agoIt's far from that. Didn't Google report thousands of hours of YouTube videos created? Combine this with disinformation on Twitter, Facebook, and less transparent media like 4chan and Reddit, and the sheer amount of person hours spent impersonating Americans pushing one talking point or another can have a profound effect. The problem with Correct the Record was, other than an extremely shortsighted objective, the fact that everyone knew about it. People who legitimately defended Hillary Clinton were assumed to be shills, to be "correcting the record" and this backfired tremendously. Keep that in mind with these releases. The advertising dollars aren't the major news. It's the sock puppets and vote/conversation manipulation that are by far the largest component of the disinformation campaign. Those costs won't be public, either.
- shpx 9y ago"We found 18 [Youtube] channels likely associated with this campaign that made videos publicly available, in English and with content that appeared to be political (These channels also posted non-political videos, e.g., personal travelogues). There were 1,108 such videos uploaded, representing 43 hours of content and totaling 309,000 U.S. views from June 2015 to November 2016. These videos generally had very low view counts; only around 3 percent had more than 5,000 views. These channels’ videos were not targeted to the U.S. or to any particular sector of the U.S. population."
- AaronFriel 9y agoThat seems like a low count of channels, videos, and hours, does that include the content existing channels were paid to create? e.g.: the divisive messaging on Black Lives Matter, where the Internet Research Agency was found to have paid existing content creators to post messages for or against the organization.
- DashRattlesnake 9y ago> If $4700 in ads could sway an entire US Presidential election That's a little disingenuous. IIRC, Facebook identified at least a $100k more on its platform, and they permitted finer-grained targeting than Google. You're right that it's hard to believe stuff like this tipped the election outcome, but it's not impossible that it did. The sales pitch of targeted online ads is that they're cheaper and more effective than mass-market ads. Also, given the way US elections are conducted, the right pressure applied in the right areas could deliver an outsized effect on the outcome. Taken together the amount of money needed to sway a close election could possibility be less than one would expect.
- rdtsc 9y ago> Also, given the way US elections are conducted, the right pressure applied in the right areas could deliver an outsized effect on the outcome. True. But presumably the experienced veterans on Clinton's team also knew about it. It's not exactly a secret how US elections work, at least it shouldn't be the people trying to be elected. $1B+ budget would have been enough to blanket all the right areas with ads day and night and even have money left over for people to walk door to door and ring doorbells.