3 ms·
> I think we've seen dramatically accelerating programmer productivity. Really? I think that the change that has contributed to the lion's share of that boost
by pron 9y ago
> I think we've seen dramatically accelerating programmer productivity.
Really? I think that the change that has contributed to the lion's share of that boost has nothing to do with language features, and has everything to do with the availability of open-source libraries. The other major contributions have been the widespread adoption of automated unit tests -- also not a language feature, and the practicality of GCs -- if considered a language feature, it's a transparent one.
When Brooks said, around '85, I think, that we won't see a single improvement contributing to a 10x improvement within a single decade, people said he was pessimistic. After 30 years I don't think we've seen a 10x improvement with all methods combined, and if we have, most of it is due to libraries.
Do you think that writing, say, an ERP, a power-station control and management software or an air-traffic control system from scratch (without off-the-shelf/open-source libraries) today would be 10x less costly than it was using C++ in 1987, or even 3x less costly than using Java in 2002 (I'm taking 30 and 15 years respectively as milestones)? Remeber that 10x within a decade was seen as pessimistic.
Although I was just a novice programmer in 1987, I think that the answer to both is an emphatic no. Even when it comes to small/simple programs (which are a completely separate domain), I'm pretty sure that aside from the availability of libraries, Python doesn't have even a 3x factor over VB/Delphi/other "RAD" languages, as they were called way back when.
- boznz 9y agoAgree 100%
- lmm 9y ago> Do you think that writing, say, an ERP, a power-station control and management software or an air-traffic control system from scratch (without off-the-shelf/open-source libraries) today would be 10x less costly than it was using C++ in 1987, or even 3x less costly than using Java in 2002 (I'm taking 30 and 15 years respectively as milestones)? Remeber that 10x within a decade was seen as pessimistic. I'd want to amend that to no domain-specific libraries - I think part of the language advantage is making very general libraries possible. But yes, I do think writing such a system to the same standard would be better than 3x cheaper than in 2002. (I don't think that's what would be done - our implicit expectations around software usability are very different today to what they were in 2002. But I do think we'd get more than 3x better value for the same money than in 2002, certainly risk-adjusted - I think in 2002 there would have been a substantial chance that the project would fail outright) For smaller programs I'd agree that we haven't improved that much, although it's very difficult to talk about how hard it would be to write small programs without libraries because small programs are mostly just using libraries.