2 ms·
> How much would something like Idris lower costs at Experian? That is, in your "cost" metric, what weight do you assign to the cost of catastrophic bugs? As a
by pron 9y ago
> How much would something like Idris lower costs at Experian? That is, in your "cost" metric, what weight do you assign to the cost of catastrophic bugs?
As a practitioner (and evangelist) of formal methods, you won't hear anything from me against the use of formal methods, although I have plenty of reason to believe that Idris (as an example of a particular design) is not very good at formal verification. The cost of bugs must be factored in, but we haven't seen the Idris approach effective at reducing bugs at a cost commensurate with their impact, except when their impact can be truly catastrophic. All the effective formal methods I know of look nothing like Idris.
As someone who has used formal methods to good effect (I believe) and is now learning Lean (which is can be put in roughly the same camp as Idris), I find it very interesting, but I cannot even imagine how it can form the basis for something that will one day be used at scale, especially given that there are such better alternatives.