11 ms·
Well, never use free VPNs! Also, don't choose a VPN based on some online review. Most of those are basically paid advertising. Either "pay if you want a good r
by mirimir 9y ago
Well, never use free VPNs!
Also, don't choose a VPN based on some online review. Most of those are basically paid advertising. Either "pay if you want a good review" or "pay more for highter rank", or stuff by independent affiliates, who get paid for referrals.
Better, choose VPNs that have been recommended by consensus in relevant communities. Torrent users. Wilders. Me ;) And by the way, I do consult for IVPN, but my opinions are otherwise unbiased.
- leadingthenet 9y agoWould you recommend IVPN?
- mirimir 9y agoWell, of course I would! They're one of the oldest. Except for the the first generation, anyway, such as Anonymizer (now basically owned by the CIA) and Cryptohippie (still very cool, but very expensive). And they have great clients for Windows, OS X and iOS. I've found a few others that are just as leak-free.[0] However, the data there are old, and just about all VPN services have improved their clients. What's most relevant about the site is the testing protocol. There's more about that in an IVPN guide.[1] I also recommend AirVPN, Mullvad and PIA. But not necessarily for their clients. I mean, IVPN doesn't have a custom Linux client. So in many cases, you need firewall rules. And you need to make sure that you're not using an ISP-assigned DNS server with the VPN. 0) https://vpntesting.info/ https://vpntesting.info/ 1) https://www.ivpn.net/privacy-guides/how-to-perform-a-vpn-leak-test https://www.ivpn.net/privacy-guides/how-to-perform-a-vpn-lea...
- kakarot 9y agoThe great thing about Mullvad is you can use OpenVPN instead of their client if you want. And those guys really know what they are doing.
- accatyyc 9y agoSame applies to IVPN, FWIW.
- rhblake 9y agoEven better, with Mullvad you can now use WireGuard instead of OpenVPN, for considerably better performance and possibly better security. I've configured my EdgeRouter Lite to route all wifi traffic on my default home network through WireGuard for a couple of weeks and it has worked very well. https://www.mullvad.net/blog/2017/9/27/wireguard-future/ https://www.mullvad.net/blog/2017/9/27/wireguard-future/
- mirimir 9y agoYou can use open-source OpenVPN with any VPN service that offers OpenVPN connectivity. You can also use AirVPN's client Eddie, which has a pretty decent built-in firewall.
- fapjacks 9y agoI use OpenVPN to connect to PIA both on my Linux machines and Android.
- DeathRabbit 9y agoJust adding another vote for Mullvad. Tried a few others, have had the best luck with Mullvad (bandwidth, # of servers, rock-solid connection, etc.)
- tacon 9y agoMy VPN activities run on a old Windows box, and I did not want to trust the VPN clients to not fail and blast my data in the open for a day or two before I noticed. I ended up writing a SafeVPN Windows service that kills processes within 30 seconds of VPN failure. I used PIA for a couple of years without issue, but then it went into some kind of decline for me, always driving network traffic to zero after a few hours. After changing hardware and reinstalling the OS with no effect, I finally tried AirVPN and things went back to normal. AirVPN is a bit more expensive, but their client is light years ahead of the PIA client.
- mirimir 9y agoIt's better to use Windows Firewall, because blocking is virtually instant. Basically, you set LAN as a private network, and the VPN as a public network. For LAN, you allow connections only to the VPN server(s) that you use, plus a DNS server that's not associated with your ISP. You can also allow connections to other LAN devices, if you like. For the VPN, you allow all output, but only input for established connections.
- j_s 9y agoCan you point to a writeup of how to do this? The only step beyond this that I have seen is a recommendation to use OpenBSD as a firewall in a virtual machine.
- mirimir 9y agoNo, sorry. I used to know a URL, but ... And most of your search hits will feature application-level blocking, which seems silly to me. Also, I don't use Windows much anymore. And I've forgotten the specifics. But. It's basically what I described. For public VPN network, just use the default (all output, only established input). For private LAN, deny all output and input, and allow output to selected IP addresses (VPN and DNS servers).
- j_s 9y agoThanks for taking the time to reply. It seems like this would be worth a write-up! Perhaps something like this can be scripted; if it becomes polished enough it could be recommended as a part of every VPN setup.
- sushid 9y agoVarious sites on the internet (e.g. Reddit, piracy sites, etc) will recommend either PIA and/or Torguard over anything else.
- mirimir 9y agoThat's because PIA and Torguard are willing to outbid others to get that ranking :) Or so I've heard. That's why you generally ignore online reviews.
- sushid 9y agoWell my Torguard license is expiring soon. Who would you personally recommend instead?
- mirimir 9y agoAirVPN, IVPN, Mullvad or PIA. They've all been around for several years, and focus on privacy. And I've never heard anything bad about any of them. PIA is the least expensive, and IVPN costs the most. AirVPN and IVPN are probably the fastest. IVPN and Mullvad probably have the best technical expertise.
- EGreg 9y agoWhy do you think that just because a VPN isn't free, it won't ALSO sell you out on the other side?
- blacksmith_tb 9y agoIt's not so much that they couldn't sell you out, but that if word got around that they had, it would be bad for business.
- thomnottom 9y agoThat's not what was said. "Free VPNs are not to be trusted" does not imply "All paid VPNs can be trusted".
- FooHentai 9y agoBut to flip that around, what about adding payment into the mix has any bearing at all on the trustworthiness of a VPN provider?
- macintux 9y agoPayment means there may be a viable business model other than sharing private information. Realistically I don't know how you can ever be sure, but I'd absolutely never trust a free VPN service.
- JamesBarney 9y agoBasically how much they have to lose. Say for instance there are two vpn services. Both have a 100,000 users. One makes $1,000 a year off of advertising, and the other makes $1,000,000 a year($9/month). Now both are approached by a nefarious gentleman who offers them $20,000 a year to harvest their user's information. But every year there is a 25% chance people find out and your service is shut down. Who takes the deal? Maybe the free guy, but very few people would risk a 1M/year revenue stream to make a little extra cash, but someone might risks a much smaller revenue stream for a comparatively bigger payoff.
- btown 9y agoWhat is your opinion on PrivateInternetAccess?
- ideonexus 9y agoI've been very happy with PIA. It's cheap with minimal impact to my bandwidth. The concern is that, like all VPNs, we are trusting them not to keep logs. PIA claims that they proved in court that they do not keep logs because they provided no useful data to an FBI request. There's a debate over whether this proves they don't keep logs or not here: https://www.privateinternetaccess.com/forum/discussion/26284/pia-looks-like-you-were-not-turthful-in-the-announcement-request-for-info https://www.privateinternetaccess.com/forum/discussion/26284... Is this semantics? I am uncertain. I do think that it's in PIA's best commercial interests not to keep logs. It's the core of their business model. The moment a PIA customer's identity is revealed through them is the moment they lose all business.
- pnutjam 9y agoI've used PrivateInternetAccess, they are trustworthy, but US based so count on them rolling on you if someone has a good reason to be interested in you.
- mirimir 9y agoWell, they apparently didn't roll for a US court, in a case involving harassment, as I recall. Would they roll for the NSA? How would they handle a NSL? I have no clue. Their founder has said that, although he lives in the US, none of their server admins do.
- godelski 9y agoThey've been recommended by a lot because they recently backed up their claims of no logging (FBI asked them for data, and they couldn't provide it). You'll see that they are ranked pretty high on this list, where there are some breakdowns. They are pretty cheap and popular too. Popular helps by making associations more difficult. That is seeing a VPN server accessed page X and that you were accessing the VPN server at said time. A college student was connected to a bomb threat by this method, being he was the only one on campus to be using TOR at the time the bomb threat was made (from TOR). You'll be fine with any VPN that is relatively popular and doesn't do any tracking.
- jen_h 9y agoOr just DIY if you're just a regular Joe or Jane, it's quick, cheap, and easier than most assume.
- needcaffeine 9y agoI’m curious about your DIY solution and what that involves.
- msh 9y agoAlgo is quite easy to install and run
- tomaskafka 9y agoAnd then you have stuff like AV companies' VPNs for which you pay AND your data gets sold. (Basically, all AV companies listed on stock market sell your data.)
- mirimir 9y agowell, I've suspected that. But can you point to evidence? I wrote a post last summer for IVPN's blog. Bottom line, AhnLab and Emsisoft seemed to be the only commercial ones that don't share data. AhnLab: “AhnLab will not collect any personal information other than [data collected during software use] and will not disclose such data to any third party.” Emsisoft: “Any information we collect from you is only used by us to serve you better. Your information is never given to a third party.”
- midwife_cry_sys 9y agoEverytime you turn around we heart of another free VPN selling data. How else do they stay in business.