3 ms·
I believe American companies are uncompetitive in the "new world order" - where 99% of durable consumer goods (yes, that's how economists call it) categories ar
by baybal2 9y ago
I believe American companies are uncompetitive in the "new world order" - where 99% of durable consumer goods (yes, that's how economists call it) categories are either made in China, or not being made at all (edit.)
Americans are not as innovative and strong as Chinese in the way they appropriate designs and ideas: Chinese extract all value from novel high margin niches quickly, they run at the forefront at the race to the bottom in mass market goods, and do painless exits from product niches that are sucked dry and are out of trend/hype cycle.
American companies needs to become more innovative to compete with Chinese. Completely scraping the useless concept of "intellectual" property of every kind, and the idea that one can "own" and idea and create captive markets through that ownership will be the first step in that direction.
- xenihn 9y agoYeah, my main takeaway from this is "Learn Mandarin, and ensure that your kids learn it too."
- baybal2 9y ago>"Learn Mandarin, and ensure that your kids learn it too." Why not? Getting basic Yue will not be a bad idea too. I'm not a Russian native, but I spent a big part of my childhood in the country. I remember that Muscovite elites had that idea at the time (mid nineties): "my kid will be going to Stanford, no money spared," while smarter far-easterners were sending their kids to back then still cheap China to learn the language and get connections. Guess whose kids fared better in 20 years time? Now, Russia has lost its last vestiges of industrial self-sufficiency, and has no economy for all those US schooled "creative" banker kids to work in. The few people who do get business today, are ones who can drive a truck to Yiwu, have basic commerce background, and knowledge of Chinese along with local connections.
- stevenwoo 9y agoI was listening to something about economics on NPR this last weekend and it talked about some of the reasons for German manufacturing surviving and thriving after China joined the WTO and part of it was the Chinese market desired German quality in certain fields - there are niche markets that Germans specialized in that Chinese consumers recognize as having some value (not sure if brand or quality of goods or combination as it was not mentioned) over anything they could get in China, and that German manufacturers are on average much smaller, and the workers cooperated a bit with owners there to lower wages to out compete the Chinese. So it is possible, and also manufacturers were outsourcing from China to Thailand (before that last natural disaster), and Vietnam because of slight wage inflation in China at one point, too.
- mcguire 9y agoAutomobiles? Other luxury goods? Chinese manufacturers may be able to make the goods, but they'll never (or, not soon anyway) be able to make the cachet of BMW or Mont Blanc.
- pault 9y agoOn the other hand, it's easier for the Chinese to develop an understanding of premium brand design than it is for Germany to develop hundreds of millions of cheap factory workers.
- stevenwoo 9y agoI was speculating it was not cars because they discussed how many of the manufacturers were small and one has to go to Maserati/Ferrari to get small car manufacturers AFAIK.
- elefanten 9y agoLet's ignore the ridiculous 99% figure on which you rhetorically position your argument. - I don't know that innovation is the right term for the rapid value extraction you're talking about. It's more like a powerful and well-configured economic environment for manufacturing-related value extraction. Many aspects of that environment are temporal and historically contingent. Things like labor costs, labor conditions, rule of law/regulations and international tolerance for norm-breaking are not constants. And some of those may have passed inflection points recently (ie- labor costs and tolerance). So, good competitive circumstances. "Innovation"... I don't know. -How profitable and sustainable are these value extraction operations, on average? I really don't know, but how reliable of a business plan is it? I'm not doubting people get rich off it, but it feels like slash and burn territory rather than a blueprint for building big, sustainable businesses. -Sure, there's a case to be made against IP. But this article and this thread are examining the outright fraud of trying to pass off counterfeits as a different company's product. That's categorically different and clearly problematic even in an IP-free world.
- baybal2 9y ago>I don't know that innovation is the right term for the rapid value extraction you're talking about. It's more like a powerful and well-configured economic environment for manufacturing-related value extraction. Yes, you are totally right in what you are saying. You do get the subtleties of the matter even better than me here. That environment/business-ecosystem is what China has managed to sustain for 30 years and what America never managed to create to begin with, unless you count times of Bennie Franklin. See this: if you give a hungry Chinese business owner a hen laying golden eggs, he will probably slaughter it upon first opportunity, but he will spend the proceeds from sale of than hen and its eggs to breed more of them and do it again. If you give such hen to a hungry American or Western European, he will probably run away, hide that hen, and will be brooding over it until he dies from hunger or the hen dies from old age. What seems to me to be the raison-detre for a lot of American business people is to find some easily securable cash cow captive market niche, and then deep a huge patent/legal/copyright moat around it to monopolize it. That is an example of very passive-rentieristic mindset. Chinese entrepreneur can slaughter his cash cow business and go on to next big thing, while American has no willpower to do so. >Many aspects of that environment are temporal and historically contingent. Things like labor costs, labor conditions, rule of law/regulations and international tolerance for norm-breaking are not constants. This is true too. Western companies that were setting up shops in China in nineties are long long gone. They were there not for simply cheap labour, but ridiculously cheap labour. Chinese industrialists have long closed businesses like rubber sandals factories and are continuously moving their industrial groups from one "next big thing" to another faster than anybody else on the planet. Nobody in SV are like those guys. Doing things this way takes special talent. >How profitable and sustainable are these value extraction operations, on average? I really don't know, but how reliable of a business plan is it? I'm not doubting people get rich off it, but it feels like slash and burn territory rather than a blueprint for building big, sustainable businesses. Yes, the slash and burn approach it is. You can build a substantial business group using it, but you will have to keep moving all the time. I see it as a valid business strategy with major strength of being strong against Western type competitors. You enter early, scale faster than others, by the time any foreign competitor simply realise the existence of your market niche, you already ran margins into zero and is doing an orderly downscaling and profitable exit. You leave rotten capitalists nothing, but crumbs behind you. They can't grow and challenge you that way. In China this tactic is called "Locust business" - any trendy product makes healthy double digit profits for three month before the locust swarm of late comers, and you need to switch to the next big thing. A guy describes that phenomenon very vividly in this video - https://www.youtube.com/1IYu4wzy9Lw https://www.youtube.com/1IYu4wzy9Lw This is how it was with countless novelties that make our daily lives today that came out of China - consumer 3d printers, hdmi stick computers, drones, bluetooth car monitors, dashcams, portable bluetooth boomboxes, wifi lightbulbs, LED lighting, air washers, hoverboards, vapes, spinners and so on. I met 3 Chinese millionaires from mainland during my life in Vancouver, all of them did something in electronics, and all of them went through many many of those slash and burn cycles. One started from making socks, then phone holsters, then small gadgetry where he went through 3 very different product. Another did sandals and mp3 players. The third one started with radios, but ended making semi fab tooling where he nuked Western competitors that had 10 digit valuations.