3 ms·
> we released millions of year of concentrated solar energy This seems like an overestimate of how much energy it would take to do capture and sequestration. T
by titzer 9y ago
> we released millions of year of concentrated solar energy
This seems like an overestimate of how much energy it would take to do capture and sequestration. The energy density of fossil fuels is nowhere near that high. A gallon of gasoline is ~33kwh of energy, which is about the same amount of energy that falls on a square meter of Earth's surface in about 22 hours.
In terms of barrels of oil, with global consumption at 96 million barrels per day, assuming 12hrs of sunlight a day, I calculated 8600km^2 of Earth's surface, or a square about 93km on a side.
- mikeash 9y agoI don't think they're talking about total insolation. They're talking about the total amount of energy which gets stored up by the biosphere and kept in long-term forms of storage like oil and coal. I believe what humanity has used so far does account for millions of years of that.
- duozerk 9y agoIndeed. I edited my post accordingly.
- duozerk 9y agoAgreed; it's a good way to visualize just how much time was required for the biosphere to produce those fossil fuels but not how much energy would be required to scrub the carbon itself (and I didn't say that, although my statement was a bit misleading - edited). I still think my point stands - scrubbing it from the atmosphere would involve an amount of energy that is unrealistic without deep, deep changes in our society.
- acqq 9y agoOil is not the only fossil fuel we use. Moreover, if some result seems too good to be true, there's big chance there's something missing.
- Retric 9y agoThe surface of a sphere can't get 12 hours of sunlight a day. It collects light across a circle with same radius as the planet. A = (pi)r^2. The surface of a sphere is A = 4(pi)r^2. Net result on average you get 6 hours of full sunlight equivalent averaged cross a planet. In northern latitudes panels tilt to collect more sunlight, but that means you can't completely cover an area with panels without some of them being in the shadow of another panel. TLDR; you need 2 squares that are each 93km on a side, or one ~131 km on a side assuming 100% efficient panels and energy conversion. At say 20% net efficiency which would be very high that's a square ~300km on a side.
- titzer 9y agoThat's a fair analysis. My point was that it's not literally millions of years worth of energy stored, but only a very tiny fraction of that.
- acqq 9y agoComparing with the area which can't be really used for production as such is also misleading. Try comparing with the actual solar plant installations and it wouldn't look so simple. All the gold ever mined fits in an olympic pool, but it's also not saying anything about how achievable that picture is. Ignoring the order of magnitude is even more misleading.
- titzer 9y agoYou're welcome to be pedantic about the surface area and miss the fact that there are 8 orders of magnitude difference between "a million years of stored energy" and a single day's worth.
- acqq 9y agoIt really took 13.8 billion years for the Earth to come to the point we're now. 3 billion years life on Earth uses the energy of Sun, only a small part remained stored in the Earth's crust. Two billion years of cyanobacteria work (using the energy of the Sun!) was needed only to produce enough oxygen in the atmosphere to enable more complex life. The next billion of years the complex life bound the carbon from the CO2 (chemically not small achievement at all) and the complex environment interaction stored it in the earth crust. The humanity used a significant part of that stored energy in just 100 years. But it is really the product of billions of years of living organisms simply living. Their goal was never to be efficient. We efficiently used up already hundred millions of years of that work (and work of the environment which allowed for the carbon to remain in the crust). That is really a "once in billions of years" event for us. We burned a lot of it carelessly fast, a lot of it simply "because it's cheap." We're still "drunk" and deny. How much of energy is actually produced at the moment in solar plants? How much area do they need? How much is achievable? That's why I'm comparing your (wrong) estimate with the attitude like "I see the golden ring on my finger, I can get it easy, just go in the shop and buy it, now it's 'just' an Olympic pool of gold with which I can 'solve' the problem, see, it's easy." No.