3 ms·
Feels like someone has an agenda, this is the 10th time I've heard this story and it has exactly the same information. Father told/showed daughter prototype ph
by dijit 9y ago
Feels like someone has an agenda, this is the 10th time I've heard this story and it has exactly the same information.
Father told/showed daughter prototype phone in breach of an NDA that I know he signed if he had access to that hardware. Daughter felt really proud of superstar daddy and took to the internet to show off.
Apple has three recourses,
1) Sue the employee to the fullest extent covered under the NDA. My employer can hold me personally liable for any loss of revenue and it wouldn't be hard to claim damage on this.
2) Ignore the incident, set a precedent that leaks are ok. Or internally lambast the employee which is akin to bullying in some eyes.
3) Terminate the employee, allow a clean break and for the employee to persue other jobs with newly accrued information (IE; that when your NDA says "NOBODY (inc. Family) are to be told [...] that it generally means it.
This is a non-story. Yes, it's sad. But it's wholly self-inflicted and I think Apple took the least destructive path on this.
- notheguyouthink 9y agoCan someone explain why you're down voting this person? His/her comments seem very reasonable, am I missing something? I hate that HN lets you downvote without an explanation. edit: And now I'm being down voted for asking a question!? Wtf is going on.. I'm trying to get information here..
- frandroid 9y agoMy guess is, the downvotes are for "This is a non-story", while it jumps to the top of HN.
- nix0n 9y agoFrom the official HN guidelines[0]: > Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading. [0]https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- notheguyouthink 9y agoHmm, shame - I was hoping to promote actual discussion about the real reason at hand, but I guess that's not allowed. I do find it very strange that we're not supposed to foster discussion, but rather quietly accept silencing of dissenting views. Seems very against the meaningful discussions that I come up HN for. Strange for me. Thank you, despite it breaking the rules I guess. I'm let down by HN this day. :/
- philbarr 9y agoFirst rule of HN: do not talk about downvoting. Second rule of HN: you get the idea....
- notheguyouthink 9y agoWell more explicitly, I don't give a shit about downvoting - but why someone downvotes is very important. Eg, if someone writes a long well thought out post, full of information, and is down voted heavily - should we not question it? It seems the HN mantra is "well the masses have spoken, best not to question them". I don't give a damn about someones magic internet points, but what I'm being told is I cannot try and prompt actual discussion? I just have to remain dumb about something I'm missing, because that's what a HNer is supposed to do? This seems so wrong :/ Honestly, this seems like an above (not by you exactly) of the root idea. By all means, don't talk about down votes, but I wasn't - I was talking about the content, that others apparently did not find worthy. Why was it not worthy? Why is it a good rule to not understand why things aren't worthy? Again, I'm not talking about magic internet numbers, I'm talking about content - yet we're not allowed to do that either. Wtf?
- philbarr 9y agoI totally agree with you. But every time I raise this as an idea I get downvoted :) I can only assume everyone else is perfectly fine with it - except yours is not the first post I've seen like this.
- philbarr 9y agoYou're allowed to downvote on HN even if it's just because you disagree. It's something Paul Graham said years ago. And it's a stupid policy and should be changed.
- grzm 9y ago> "Feels like someone has an agenda, this is the 10th time I've heard this story and it has exactly the same information." This is the nature of a lot of journalism these days, with many outlets either (a) reiterating what's in a press release or (b) reporting what has already been reported elsewhere. This happens with plenty of stories, even without an agenda.