4 ms·
"It looks like nothing changed since 2014, but GOOG and FB now have direct influence over 70%+ of internet traffic." The web needs to really become decentraliz
by EGreg 9y ago
"It looks like nothing changed since 2014, but GOOG and FB now have direct influence over 70%+ of internet traffic."
The web needs to really become decentralized. Even Tim Berners-Lee has said it [1]. He has started a project to re-decentralize it called Solid [2].
Email was decentralized but now it's become super centralized with GMail etc. And look at how easy it is for the NSA to vacuum all that up from one spot.
Wordpress powers 20% of the decentralized web. Because it's a free, open-source piece of software with a plugin ecosystem that runs on a popular runtime - PHP. We need stuff like that, but for things like SOCIAL MEDIA. Nothing currently exists that can rival facebook, google+ etc.
I believe that the software can change the internet's topology. Right now all signals go through giant centralized server farms. Consider how people use Google Docs for collaboration Facebook / Slack for conversation or Dropbox for their files. The default is to immediately connect to "the cloud" which is in reality some company's server farm. AWS just capitalized on this trend and made it easier.
In fact, you can do all of it LOCALLY by default. There's no reason that bits need to go through Google's servers for a classroom to collaborate on a document, or for an African village to plan a community dinner. Except one: lack of open source software that can run locally, and rival Facebook, Google etc. in ease of use.
We are building that software and started around 2011. My company Qbix [3] wants to decentralize not just the web, but also identity [4], data [5] and social networking [6]. We look to partner with companies who want to decentralize cellphone signals (like gotenna) and energy generation (like solar panels) so human networking in the future has a LOT more local options to utilize before ever jumping onto the public internet.
PS: Whenever I post this topic, with links to back it up, I get downvoted heavily. But I never get any explanation why. If you are an HN member who disagrees with this thesis, first of all that's not enough reason for a downvote. And secondly, I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW WHY you feel so strongly against what I'm saying here: that the web, cellphone signals and energy generation should be decentralized. Contribute constructively to the conversation, and explain what alternatives do you think are better. Are you so ferventlu against developing software to run on local networks as to militate against comments advocating it? Am I breaking some HN rule by linking to our work that we passionately believe in and spend most of our time on? What are the words behind your downvote?
1. https://www.ted.com/talks/tim_berners_lee_on_the_next_web https://www.ted.com/talks/tim_berners_lee_on_the_next_web
2. https://solid.mit.edu https://solid.mit.edu
3. https://qbix.com https://qbix.com
4. https://github.com/Qbix/auth https://github.com/Qbix/auth
5. https://github.com/Qbix/architecture/wiki/Internet-2.0 https://github.com/Qbix/architecture/wiki/Internet-2.0
6. https://qbix.com/platform https://qbix.com/platform
- digi_owl 9y agoThe problem not a technical one, it is a social/economic/political one. It is how the big players gets to dictate policy virtually unchecked. Email, on the protocol level, is still decentralized. But Google and a few other big players have via their spam filters dictated how every email server on the planet is to behave, or else. And we are seeing similar things happening with web servers and browsers, just look at the railroading the W3C DRM spec got.
- EGreg 9y agoW3C DRM happened because of Tim Berners-Lee himself. And I agree that, since W3C is a central point, it is the target for attacking. But it's possible to decentralize things in a way that stays decentralized, for LOCAL communications. Email spam is only a problem across the global internet. Not within local networks. Same goes for other types of communications. Human speech for example has remained peer to peer even as radio was invented :) I really think the problem is a technical one. The social and political outcomes are almost inevitable, just like the two party system is a nearly inevitable outcome of the first-past-the-post ballot. Lots of paradigms changed as technologies were introduced. The phone, radio, the printing press etc. Technology has a great impact on society.
- fiatjaf 9y agoYou're wrong. The problem is a technical one. Do you remember what was it like before the TECHNOLOGY of the internet was created and deployed?