4 ms·
I'm not arguing that their facts are wrong. I'm asking: Why this article, at this time, from this organization? And I'm offering what I believe to be an accurat
by throwanem 9y ago
I'm not arguing that their facts are wrong. I'm asking: Why this article, at this time, from this organization? And I'm offering what I believe to be an accurate answer to that question.
You can argue if you like that I'm merely engaging in ad hom, but I think that's a rather shallow reading, and not noticeably accurate; what I'm actually doing is identifying the intellectual tradition in which the publication bases its analysis, and calling the validity of that analysis into question on the basis of the grievously flawed results which in recent years it has exclusively produced.
Considering that the same publication is concurrently pushing its plan for war with North Korea - a plan which to its originators no doubt seems every bit as sensible and effective as the one they came up with last decade and which has clearly worked out so amazingly well - I think the provenance of even so anodyne an analysis as this one is nonetheless worth bringing to the attention of the HN commentariat, that we may all judge it in light of its full context. Perhaps I am wrong in so thinking.
- jacquesm 9y agoWell, it's 'this article' because SEJeff posted it and I and many others upvoted it. So that leaves your attempt to try to link this article with other articles on the same website rather unsupported. Unless you would like to link all of us with your conspiracy theory. To me it's just an interesting look at how arms embargo evasion works, and how shockingly easy it was to get this deal done.
- throwanem 9y agoWhat? I'm talking about why they published it when they did and several months after it was actually news, not why SEJeff submitted it here. HN only enters into the issue at all inasmuch as the article happened to appear here. More specifically, this is a publication whose purpose is to advance a foreign policy narrative that's favored by one specific school of foreign-policy thought - indeed, a publication founded by that school of thought's own founder. Call it "conspiracy theory" if you like to suggest that such a publication might act in ways which tend to advance that narrative, but I'm not sure it's really so unreasonable as all that. (Since the next step in this progression should be suggesting I have some sort of covert dog in the fight, I'll go ahead and disclaim that in advance: I'm nothing in foreign policy circles and no one of import listens to anything I have to say. But in light of the quality of results which neoconservative foreign policy produced last decade, I feel like it's worth taking a moment to point out that maybe we could come up with something better to do in this decade.)