9 ms·
Oldest recorded solar eclipse helps date the Egyptian pharaohs
- waynecochran 9y agoI’ve seen two total eclipses and one annular eclipse. You wouldn’t even notice an annular eclipse if you weren’t looking for it. I’m not sure how this would have helped Joshua or have been worthy of note.
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> You wouldn’t even notice an annular eclipse if you weren’t looking for it. What? The partial eclipse I saw in 2017 was easily noticeable by anyone who looked even remotely near the sun.
- waynecochran 9y agoYou notice it is slightly darker. Most folks aren’t looking at the sun. It surely wouldn’t affect an army.
- rtkwe 9y agoTactically yes it being a little dimmer doesn't directly weaken or strengthen a particular army. What is can do is affect morale given that events like this were shocking and often recorded as some kind of ill omen by people that saw them.
- skywhopper 9y agoTo be fair, partial and annular eclipses are noticeable if you are looking for them, but they are absolutely nothing like a total eclipse, which really would feel like something apocalyptic if you were to experience it by surprise without understanding of what you were seeing or knowledge that it was temporary.
- rtkwe 9y agoYeah, there's definitely a huge difference between those two and a total eclipse but the assertion keeps coming up that ancient peoples wouldn't notice unless it was a total eclipse which is ridiculous.
- jessriedel 9y agoIt gets slightly darker, as if it's a bit overcast, but the effect is very subtle due to the logarithmic response of the eye. And it doesn't help to look at the sun because it's much too bright to see the shape.
- dboreham 9y agoI saw the same eclipse in the zone of totality and I'm not sure I agree with you. You noticed something (a little less bright, a little colder) but only because you were expecting it. If you were not expecting the sun to do something unusual I think you'd either just not notice or put it down to some thin cloud cover moving over the sun. I say this because when viewing the total eclipse, things were pretty much normal, albeit a bit less than regular full sun brightness and temperature, until minutes before the onset of totality, so 95+% coverage.
- planteen 9y agoI've seen one total and one annular. Though an annular eclipse is not nearly as dramatic, I imagine a person outdoors a few thousand years ago would have noticed it. It looks as if it is sunset (golden hour type colors) and shadows look strange with a donut pattern.
- waynecochran 9y agoYeah, but wouldn’t have made the history books or affected an army. A total eclipse on the other hand would have been a show stopper ... especially in ancient battle.
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> Yeah, but wouldn’t have made the history books or affected an army. I can't believe that nobody wouldn't at least jot down, "Dear diary, today a huge fucking chunk of the sun was missing for about an hour. I sure am glad I'm literate, and that the godkingpharaohboss decided that a chunk of the sun missing warranted a brief note on precious lambskin/temple wall/holy book margin."
- ComputerGuru 9y agoYou can't tell any part of the sun isn't visible by looking at it directly without some sort of shielding from the glare.
- lfam 9y agoYou can tell because every shadow will show the weird shape of the sun. Here is a photograph of the shadows during an annular eclipse: https://imgur.com/gallery/8c7rdEU https://imgur.com/gallery/8c7rdEU Whether or not people >1000 years ago would notice this and record it... I refrain from pretending to know.
- planteen 9y agoIn addition to the shadows, a cloud passing over in about a 2 hour window would make it apparent.
- baldfat 9y agoHistorically the stars and sun played a MUCH greater importance than today. They absolutely would have seen and recorded this event. Reason why is we see it in many other recording of them and throughout the ancient world. This helped us to much more accurately date history.
- davidgay 9y agoYou are forgetting the case of when the sun is behind light clouds (which is not everywhere, but definitely does happen): http://slideviewer.appspot.com/show?tag=dgay,solar-eclipse,1999&offset=1 http://slideviewer.appspot.com/show?tag=dgay,solar-eclipse,1... (no filter)
- hcrisp 9y ago> I’m not sure how this would have helped Joshua... Especially when the text goes on to say that the sun "hasted not to go down about a whole day" during which time Joshua defeated his enemies [0]. The article does not address this part of the verse. It also omits the subsequent statement that "And there was no day like that before it or after it..." [1]. [0] https://www.blueletterbible.org/kjv/jos/10/13/t_conc_197013 https://www.blueletterbible.org/kjv/jos/10/13/t_conc_197013 [1] https://www.blueletterbible.org/kjv/jos/10/13/t_conc_197014 https://www.blueletterbible.org/kjv/jos/10/13/t_conc_197014
- pcl 9y agoPerhaps that depends on how large of a ring is around the moon? The sun was noticeably eclipsed to the naked eye during the annular eclipse I've seen (2012 in California).
- lukasb 9y agoThe paper is available (in HTML even) and much better: https://academic.oup.com/astrogeo/article/58/5/5.39/4159289/Solar-eclipse-of-1207-BC-helps-to-date?guestAccessKey=96454415-36e7-4640-9fde-d942f3ad00b4 https://academic.oup.com/astrogeo/article/58/5/5.39/4159289/...
- elliotec 9y agoWho says they didn’t get eye damage from it? Also, I have a feeling most people I know have looked at the sun unprotected for at least some small period of time (including myself) and our eyes seem ok for now.
- jcims 9y agoI used to try to stare at the sun when I was little. It would blot itself out in less than a second with this squishy shimmery black spot (presumably retinal fatigue). It was hard to keep that spot in one place (saccades) though so I would keep chasing it around the sun. Im mildly myopic with astigmatism, but no abnormal blind spots afaik.
- wnissen 9y agoYour brain is really, really good at filling in blind spots. There is a big one where your optic nerve connects to the back of your eye, you can even see it yourself. http://pbskids.org/zoom/activities/sci/blindspot.html http://pbskids.org/zoom/activities/sci/blindspot.html In order to keep from overwhelming the brain with irrelevant optical data, there is a lot of processing going on, and one of the things that happens is a filling in of places where there's no stimulus coming from that part of the eye. It's possible you have blind spots and don't know it. Also, only UV-blocking sunglasses will keep you from getting cataracts.
- canttestthis 9y agoBecause you didn't look at it during an eclipse, when its more dangerous than looking at it on a regular day.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pi-err 9y agoA bit OT but how did ancient civilizations know that they should NOT watch an eclipse with a naked eye? The knowledge would have been lost or unavailable at each occurence. Remote areas would probably never get the word. So how didn't they get massive eye damages back then?
- metalliqaz 9y agoWell, we can assume that they knew not to look directly at the Sun on a normal day, right? So there was perhaps already an understanding that caution was warranted. But how do you know they didn't get eye damage? Seems reasonable to think that people did sustain damage to varying degrees. It still happens today... not even that rare, actually. Also, assuming they weren't running for cover due to mistaking a total solar eclipse as a bad omen, they may have been interested in other things that prevented them from staring for extended periods. The 360 degree sunset, for example.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- njarboe 9y agoLike most dangers communicated to people in the modern world, the danger of looking at the sun is way overblown. You can look at the sun for over a minute straight without any damage. How much damage, how fast, what kind of damage, and how this varies with peoples genetics is not well known, of course. Doing such experiments would harm peoples eyes. How long can you look at a little bit of the sun right around the total eclipse? Very not known. But "safety first" and you get things like and emergency warning sent out to all cell phones before the eclipse saying not to look at the sun. Looking at the bright sun is not a pleasant sensation. I imagine people in ancient times were more in-tune with their physical senses and were less likely to do things that hurt them just for curiosity sake.
- theoh 9y ago"What kind of damage" is pretty well-known. See e.g. "Light-Induced Damage to the Retina" http://photobiology.info/Rozanowska.html http://photobiology.info/Rozanowska.html
- adictator 9y agoWe have older recorded dates for Solar Eclipses. Not sure why those are glossed over... http://sarojbala.blogspot.com/2014/08/dates-of-ramayana.html http://sarojbala.blogspot.com/2014/08/dates-of-ramayana.html
- peter303 9y ago“One chance in ten an individual directly experiences a solar eclipse.” Any spot on Earth sees one in four centuries; life expectancy 40 years. However its pretty certain that people would have heard from neigbors who saw one. Othe eclipses are fairly common. Lunar eclipses are seen everywhere on Earth every couple years; Moon eclipsing a planet every few years. Combining these eclipses with rumors of solar eclipses, ancient skywatchers would predict the Moon would eclipse the Sun sometime.
- ttyprintk 9y agoAnd Ireland claims an even older eclipse http://www.astronomy.ca/3340eclipse/ http://www.astronomy.ca/3340eclipse/. Nov 30, 3340 BC.
- bustadjustme 9y agoI don't follow their reasoning. Given their premises: 1. The solar eclipse of Oct 30, 1207 BC is recorded in the book of Joshua, describing events concerning the people of Israel in Canaan (specifically, a battle with some Canaanites). 2. A battle between Israel and Egypt (under Pharaoh Merneptah, son of Ramesses II) is recorded on the Merneptah Stele (which says it was recorded in Merneptah's 5th year). The researchers conclude: > So the Israelites must have been in Canaan by Merneptah's fifth year. > ... > The confrontation with Israel probably occurred in his year 2 to 4 (Kitchen 2006), so 1207 BC is probably year 2, 3 or 4 of Merneptah. Huh? They must have been in Canaan by 1207, sure, but why does that imply the Israel/Egypt battle happened in 1207? It seems like 1207 is just an earliest-possible date for the battle... From what I can tell, the Merneptah Stele has no other information indicating it should be linked to the eclipse or the account from Joshua. Have I just missed something?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- burkaman 9y agoThey think the battles are the same. The book of Joshua doesn't say they fought Canaanites, just that they fought "their enemies". The theory is that the Egyptians were the enemies.
- wbhart 9y agoIt does say they fought Canaanites. It specifies that they were Amorites, and names the cities.
- wbhart 9y agoThe Merneptah Stele says Israel was wiped out. So it's a pretty tenuous explanation to say that this is the battle recorded in the book of Joshua. Also the book of Joshua says the battle was against the Amorites, that the sun delayed going down for a full day, and that Israel was victorious. I think it is fair to say the majority scholarly opinion (biblical minimalist or maximalist) is going to consider this theory the work of cranks. The maximalists don't get their way without a fairly extensive revision of Egyptian chronology, a la David Rohl [1]. The minimalists consider the record of the conquest of Canaan by Joshua to be completely ahistorical. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Chronology_(Rohl) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Chronology_(Rohl)
- spoiledtechie 9y agoIt's always interesting to see Scientists use the Bible, when much of the western world has described it as fiction. I otherwise, believe it to be non-fiction.
- jmts 9y agoYou're conflating the theology of the Bible with the history of the Bible. A (non-believing) scientist/historian might very well decline that Jesus has any supernatural connection, but agree that it is plausible that he was an actual person, born of non-supernatural causes, and had his story confused through time. I have read theories that God and the Angels just happened to be an race/community of people that impressed those who met them by their size, prowess, or their artifacts, and told their story. This sounds entirely plausible to me as an explanation for the existence of some earthly being who either became or actually was named God. Similarly, I have read of the supposed existence of ancient birthing/funeral rituals whereby the spirit of one individual is tranferred into the body of another. I can completely rationalise this as an explanation for how Methuselah and his peers were able to 'live' as long as they did. Though I no longer remember the book I read these things from, and I do not claim that they are scientifically or historically accurate, I think it is a mistake for anyone to suggest that the Bible does not have some historical importance distinct from religion when the correct context is applied. I am not sure whether this is the same non-fiction you refer to.
- mamon 9y ago>> how Methuselah and his peers were able to 'live' as long as they did Another possible explanation is that ancient Jews used "Moon years" aka months as unit of measurement :) Then Methuselah's 969 "years" would translate to 80 years, 9 months.
- kbart 9y agoScientists also look at the old children fairy tales for historical facts[0], but that doesn't make them to be true. The story that has been passed from generation to generation for ages accumulates a lot of secondary knowledge not necessarily related to the primary topic. 0. http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/04/some-fairy-tales-may-be-6000-years-old http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/04/some-fairy-tales-may-...
- intellectronica 9y agoIt is quite uncontroversial nowadays in studies of the biblical texts to accept that the book of Joshua (as well many of the other foundational texts) was written in the 7th century BCE. To assume that the writer had any idea what astronomical events happened centuries earlier is implausible.
- willyjoe 9y agoI used to hate that part of the bible, seemed so obviously wrong. But now I mostly believe it wasn't an eclipse and happened as stated (also Joshua's long day about 50 years later). TedX talk on the subject: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eESlenGhKN0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eESlenGhKN0