3 ms·
The right way: influencing ranking by load times for some exemplar (and easily replicable) device and inter-actability events. That way, sites like HN are boos
by falcolas 9y ago
The right way: influencing ranking by load times for some exemplar (and easily replicable) device and inter-actability events.
That way, sites like HN are boosted to the top, while sites which take 10 seconds for their JS frameworks and ads to load before showing text on the screen are penalized.
- SquareWheel 9y agoPage load speeds are a ranking factor.
- falcolas 9y agoWhy add a special ranking for amp pages, if page speed is already a major factor? It would seem like the reality is that page speed is not an important factor, and that re-tuning that factor would have been a better solution if Google's primary concern was for the health of the open web; not just Google's ecosystem.
- SquareWheel 9y ago>Why add a special ranking for amp pages, if page speed is already a major factor? I touched on this confusion elsewhere in this thread, but AMP is actually not a ranking factor. The carousel is a vertical which has been integrated into the page. However, I do agree with you. It's confusing to end-users when it's described as a non-ranking factor because it still appears on the search page. It just doesn't influence organic search. I would also like to see page speed become even more important, as performance is very important to user satisfaction. I spend a lot of time trying to minimize bits wherever possible. It's not just pure loading times either, but perceived speed too. Small effects like animations can make a page feel faster, even if it's technically slower.
- kemayo 9y agoMind you, it's at the top, which I think matters regardless of whether it's technically in the search results. It's an implicit "use AMP and we'll show you first" statement.
- falcolas 9y agoAmp results being "in a separate vertical" is a distinction without a difference. You do a search, and the amp sites show up at the top of the results page. They are, quite literally, at the top of the search results.
- SquareWheel 9y agoI know, but this is a difference in how normal people and search people talk about SERPs. "Ranking factors" almost always refer to organic search. That's part of where this friction has come from. Personally, I wouldn't be surprised to see the carousel disappear once Google deems that AMP has become self-sustaining. I think they're using it as motivation to get publishers on board, and then they'll fall back to regular organic ranking afterwards (to which AMP pages will still benefit). But in the mean time it's causing a lot of consternation.
- lllr_finger 9y agoIf a site gets 100m unique in a month they will be at the very top. They can then choose to provide a fast site, or slap on a bunch of analytics, tracking, and 3rd party bloat that provides business intelligence and millions in revenue - while staying ranked at the top. They get to have their cake and eat it too, and there was no incentive (before AMP) to reign that in.
- falcolas 9y agoThat's the thing about parameters - they can be tuned. The factor for page speed could have been tuned to matter as much, if not more than their unique views, trashing their ranking the moment they started adding bloat. Google appears to have decided not to, in an apparent effort to boost their ecosystem, at the cost of the open web.