8 ms·
How a destructive idea paved the way for modern math
- Bromskloss 9y agoThe monster in question is the Weierstraß function [0], noteworthy for being continuous everywhere yet differentiable nowhere. I don't if the article talks about other "monsters" too. I didn't look further than to this one. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weierstrass_function https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weierstrass_function
- jhkim 9y agoIt seems like the equation shown in the article doesn't satisfy the condition listed on the wikipedia page. Did the author make a mistake?
- supergarfield 9y agoThe Wikipedia article gives Weierstrass's original condition, but it was later improved to just ab ≥ 1 (as noted, not very visibly, at the end of the article). However, the Nautilus article also says that "Conventional wisdom held that for any continuous curve, it was possible to find the gradient at all but a finite number of points", which is clearly not true, so I'd be cautious about its technical correctness.
- euyyn 9y agoFrom the way they try to explain it, I think they meant to say a "countable" number of points, instead of finite.
- alimw 9y agoOn what basis are you calling this assertion "clearly not true"?
- bonzini 9y agoYou can define a periodic function that goes from 0 to 1 as a straight line and then from 1 to 0 as another straight line, basically a triangle wave. It is not differentiable on an infinite (and countable) number of points: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triangle_wave https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triangle_wave
- lmm 9y agoI imagine they would have been talking about functions on the interval rather than our modern sense of functions on the reals. (Of course there are plenty of examples on the interval as well, but no obvious ones)
- bonzini 9y agoTake something like arcsin sin pi/2/x(x-1), where "arcsin sin pi*x/2" is "pointy" like a triangle wave. There you have it.
- vilhelm_s 9y agoThere is a lot of discussion at this Stack Exchange question, "Is Kline right that Cauchy believed that continuous functions must be differentiable?" (https://hsm.stackexchange.com/questions/3480/is-kline-right-that-cauchy-believed-that-continuous-functions-must-be-differenti https://hsm.stackexchange.com/questions/3480/is-kline-right-...) Mathematicians didn't state this as theorem or axiom, so it's hard to pin down exactly what they might have believed; the people answering the question talk about "except at isolated points" rather than "except at a finite number of points".
- bonzini 9y agoIt talks about Koch's snowflake and Brownian motion.
- dorfsmay 9y agoThanks. This actually sums it better than the article.
- acqq 9y agoThis page has the "zooming in" animation and a good explanation: https://sites.math.washington.edu/~conroy/general/weierstrass/weier.htm https://sites.math.washington.edu/~conroy/general/weierstras... It's mentioned in the Wikipedia article: "The Weierstrass function could perhaps be described as one of the very first fractals studied, although this term was not used until much later. The function has detail at every level, so zooming in on a piece of the curve does not show it getting progressively closer and closer to a straight line." Does anybody know any even earlier "fractal studied" before they were named so? I guess the author probably meant "Bolzano function" (~1830, published in 1922, mentioned in the Notes section).
- Asooka 9y agoIt can also be integrated, and can be used as the basis for doing Fourier transforms. Completely useless as far as I've researched, but curious nonetheless. Here's an example paper: https://arxiv.org/abs/1502.07734 https://arxiv.org/abs/1502.07734
- phkahler 9y agoI take issue with this. The function is an infinite series of cosine functions which can be shown to be convergent everywhere. It's also easy to write a series for the derivative of it, but that is probably divergent and hence not well defined anywhere. It's a nice trick. But if one truncates the series at any finite number of terms, the problem goes away and it is differentiable everywhere. I see parallels to the countability of the reals, and a similar issue with vague notions of infinity.
- rocqua 9y agoI suppose the inaccuracies caused by the 'prose' of Ampère's false proof that all continuous functions are differentiabe might be what inspired Hilbert's demand for rigor. In turn, this lead to Godel's incompleteness. We are then left in the curious situation of despising any hand waving, whilst knowing deep down that at some point we need to accept things without rigorous proof. Of course, that other reason to hand-wave remains. Often, things are `obvious' and yet very very tedious to proof. It is an odd balance to strike.
- whatshisface 9y agoUnprovable statements weaken provable ones no further than the extent to which the undecidability of the halting problem makes my toaster burn my Eggos.
- visarga 9y agoYour toaster has a halting problem?
- eternalban 9y agohttp://lambda-the-ultimate.org/node/4302 http://lambda-the-ultimate.org/node/4302 There seems to me an enormous mistake there. ... Suppose I convince [someone] of the paradox of the Liar, and he says, 'I lie, therefore I do not lie, therefore I lie and I do not lie, therefore we have a contradiction, therefore 2x2 = 369.' Funniest thing is I agree with both of them ..
- whatshisface 9y agoYes, it has the halting problem for a machine much less powerful than a Turing machine, where the answer is always yes unless the thermostat fails. The idea is that just like there are programs less powerful than the halting oracle there are statements less powerful than the completeness of arithmetic.
- rocqua 9y agoI refer to Godel's second incompleteness theorem. That is, no system of axioms can prove itself to be consistent. Thus, all provable statements rest on an unproveable statement.
- xelxebar 9y agoThis reminds me of the Devil's Staircase [0], a continuous function that is flat almost everywhere and yet still spans the range [0,1]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cantor_function https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cantor_function
- WallWextra 9y agoAnalysis in general is notorious for these kinds of things. There's a neat little Dover book called Counterexamples in Analysis full of them.
- mathperson 9y agoThere is also "counterexamples in topology"!
- Myrmornis 9y agoReally nice essay. I think it might be an enjoyable read even for the majority for whom real analysis is somewhere between excruciatingly boring and excruciatingly painful.
- alfredallan 9y agoReally nice indeed, but I think it'd have been much nicer with actual examples/equations.
- notduncansmith 9y agoThis video has more information about these "monsters": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=56gzV0od6DU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=56gzV0od6DU Fractals are one of the most important epistemological tools of our time.
- danharaj 9y agoSynthetic differential geometry formalizes calculus in a way that precludes most monsters. Quite nicely, it allows you to use infinitesimal reasoning. The price to pay is the law of excluded middle. If you're a programmer, you're probably fine giving that up. The wiki page has good references: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synthetic_differential_geometry https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synthetic_differential_geome...
- xelxebar 9y agoOh. I'm happy someone brought this up! For anyone interested, Anders Kock has a nice slim-but-dense book on the subject entitled "Synthetic Differential Geometry" [0]. Kock even offers a PDF of an older version [1] on his site. [0] http://a.co/717X9pE http://a.co/717X9pE [1] http://home.imf.au.dk/kock/sdg99.pdf http://home.imf.au.dk/kock/sdg99.pdf
- adrianratnapala 9y agoOnly if you are that exceedingly queer kind of programmer who thinks that which is not within reach of Coq can never be truth. I am a programmer, but I like C better, and assert(A && !A) looks like a monster to me.
- irishsultan 9y agoWell, you probably meant assert(A || !A), but even so that will of course never be an issue if A is a value, it becomes only a problem if A is replaced by something like a() (which I assume to be a pure function for the purpose of this comment). Of course a() || !a() is never going to be false either, so assert(a() || !a()) will never abort your program, but that doesn't mean a() || !a() will ever be true (if a() never finishes calculating then neither will a() || !a()).
- danharaj 9y ago(A && !A) is always false even if (A || !A) isn't justified . In other words, !!(A || !A). When we reject excluded middle we are no longer talking about truth, but evidence.
- 9y ago
- graycat 9y agoBeauty and the Beast: Smooth meets the Monster. Let n be a positive integer and let R be the set of real numbers. Let R^n be Euclidean n-dimensional space. E.g., R^1 is the real line; R^2 is the plane; and R^3 is (approximately) the space we live in. Let C be a closed subset of R^n. In R^2, examples of closed subsets include a sample path of Brownian motion (as in the OP) and the Mandelbrot set. An example in R^1 is a Cantor set of positive measure. Then there exists a function f: R^n --> R so that (1) f is infinitely differentiable, (2) f(x) = 0 for all x in C, and (3) f(x) > 0 for all x not in C. So, smooth beauty f meets the monster beast set C. Of course, the level set of any differentiable function is closed. But now we know that any closed set can be the level set of an infinitely differentiable function. So, we also know that there can be an infinitely differentiable function positive outside of C, 0 on the boundary of C, and negative on the interior of C. So, we know that for any closed set, there is an infinitely differentiable function that has the boundary of the closed set as a level set. Since a level set of a differentiable function is closed, we also have the the boundary of any closed set is closed. "I have found a truly wonderful proof," but the mathematical notation is too difficult to type into a blog post! But, no worries: I published it in JOTA. The Brownian motion example was noticed by A. Karr.
- xelxebar 9y agoInteresting. Or put more tersely, Let O be an open set in R^n. There exists a smooth function f: R^n -> R with support cl(O). Off the cuff, I'd try proving this by covering O with bump functions and trying to glue those together. I'll try thinking about this more when I've got time. :)
- gogopuppygogo 9y agoI love stories about anti-authoritarians. While they don't specifically state that Karl Weierstrass was one, it seems clear to me from his actions that he was.
- thenewwazoo 9y agoBut was he a true Scotsman?
- dogruck 9y agoThis essay’s conclusion is it’s best part. I like how it points out how radical abstract concepts eventually reunited with natural phenomena.
- mar77i 9y agoIt's as if the universe aligned for Nautilus (which is also a snail producing a natural fractal as its house) to publish such a fascinating article about how calculus and geometry partially unite to produce such a fascinating article. Wait... what?