3 ms·
>The strongest argument against torture is efficacy; not even close. Efficacy is a very weak argument at best. A torture efficient enough for a given situation
by trhway 9y ago
>The strongest argument against torture is efficacy;
not even close. Efficacy is a very weak argument at best. A torture efficient enough for a given situation easily breaks that argument in that situation.
Discussing torture efficiency is basically a torturers' shop talk. That was a masterpiece act of political spin back then decade ago when the societal moral outrage toward torture was basically defused by converting it into a discussion on whether torture is efficient and whether the specific applied torture methods fit legal torture definition. And it basically continues that way since then (with your comment being pretty typical of that). Instead of asserting the morally right choice of non-acceptance of torture, the society has basically walked into the trap of waiting for invention of efficient torture methods.
- QAPereo 9y agoDiscussing torture efficiency is basically a torturers' shop talk. In the same way that discussing the total lack of efficacy of magic makes you a sorcerer, sure.
- trhway 9y agoThere is no "same way" here. Sorcerers don't exist. Torturers do.
- QAPereo 9y agoSorcerers do exist, it's just that their methodology is based on faulty premises, and what they do doesn't work because magic isn't real. Just like torturers, who do all kinds of things according to supposed art/science, but in reality it's just bullshit for show. Edit: If you're claiming that it works, I'll still keep asking, "Prove it." Cite those many, "Many times in history..."
- trhway 9y ago> torturers, who do all kinds of things according to supposed art/science, but in reality it's just bullshit for show. sounds like you flat out dismiss all the human history with myriad of cases where torture (or even just a plausible threat of torture) did work. It may have worked not up to your taste of torture efficiency ... well ... that would be a torturers' shop talk and i'm not interested in it.
- mjcohen 9y agoYep. Those witches convincingly confessed when tortured.