2 ms·
> I thought your original quote was direct quote Actually, what I actually said is more accurate than my off-the-cuff paraphrase in the above comment. There i
by lisper 9y ago
> I thought your original quote was direct quote
Actually, what I actually said is more accurate than my off-the-cuff paraphrase in the above comment. There is no flaw in the reasoning. The reasoning is correct, and I say that in the presentation too. It is the premises that are false.
> your true belief is that there is a flaw in the logic
No. See above.
> My understanding is that all the different accepted interpretations are mathematically equivalent
Yes, that's true. The part of the Copenhagen interpretation that is scientifically untenable is the non-mathematical part, the part that says that there is this physical phenomenon called the collapse of the wave function which is non-unitary and outside the scope of the theory, but which causes real measurable effects (i.e. the destruction of interference). That part is demonstrably false, notwithstanding that it is a fair approximation to the truth in many interesting cases, which is the reason that it has survived as long as it has despite being demonstrably false.
What is also false (and the reason I have such a bee in my bonnet about all this) is all the pedagogical baggage associated with the Copenhagen interpretation, how it's intractably weird, and no one understands it, and you shouldn't even try to understand it because you'll "go down the drain" (Feynman's words). That's all bullshit. QM is not hard to understand. The key is that measurement is just large-scale entanglement, and there are no particles. That's it. That's the big reveal. This has been know for decades. I learned it 17 years ago and it was considered old news even then. There's some evidence that Heisenberg knew it but didn't want to advance the hypothesis because there was no way to settle the question experimentally at the time. But since Bell and Aspect and Zurek (and Cerf and Adami) there is no question that it is true. It is as well established a result as any in science, and has been for decades. But for some unfathomable reason it's still controversial.
- fjsolwmv 9y agoWho is opposed to the idea that measurement is entanglement?
- lisper 9y agoAnyone who defends the Copenhagen interpretation. To be more precise, anyone who thinks that the "measurement problem" is still an unresolved problem, or anyone who defends the concept of "wave function collapse" as having any scientific or pedagogical merit whatsoever, except as a historical example of how science can go badly wrong. Richard Feynman would be the poster child for this point of view were he alive today. Freeman Dyson defended it to me the last time I spoke to him, but that was 20 years ago so maybe he's come around. According to a poll taken in 2013 [1] Copenhagen was the most popular interpretation among physicists. Sean Carroll apparently thinks Copenhagen is tenable [2] along with many of his commenters. [1] https://arxiv.org/abs/1301.1069 https://arxiv.org/abs/1301.1069 [2] http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2013/01/17/the-most-embarrassing-graph-in-modern-physics/ http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2013/01/17/the-most...
- thethirdone 9y ago> Actually, what I actually said is more accurate than my off-the-cuff paraphrase in the above comment. There is no flaw in the reasoning. The reasoning is correct, and I say that in the presentation too. It is the premises that are false. In that case, I think your presentation was accurate to what you wanted to convey, but I disagree that the Copenhagen interpretation has a major problem. It is perhaps harder to get a good grasp of than another interpretation, but the really hard parts of QM is in the math. >> My understanding is that all the different accepted interpretations are mathematically equivalent > Yes, that's true. The part of the Copenhagen interpretation that is scientifically untenable is the non-mathematical part, the part that says that there is this physical phenomenon called the collapse of the wave function which is non-unitary and outside the scope of the theory, but which causes real measurable effects (i.e. the destruction of interference). I was not quite clear. I meant that all of the predictions are identical (thus leading to the math calculating them being the same). If that is not true, either I have been terribly mislead or you have a groundbreaking result in QM. > That's all bullshit. QM is not hard to understand. The really hard part about understanding quantum mechanics is dealing with the underlying math. It is not intuitive. Complex numbers tend to make an intuitive understanding hard. Properly understanding the Quantum Fourier Transform is not easy, and that doesn't even use measurement. I never touched the Copenhagen interpretation in my study of the QFT and it was still hard.
- lisper 9y agoThere's a difference between understanding QM and doing QM. (See the preface of Griffith's book [1] for an explanation of what I mean by that distinction.) Doing QM is indeed hard. But it has been claimed by many (with again Feynman being the canonical example) that understanding QM is hard too, so hard in fact that one should not even try. That is false. Anyone who understands high school algebra and what a complex number is can understand QM. > I meant that all of the predictions are identical That depends on what you mean. Formally, yes, all the predictions are identical. But informally, the Copenhagen interpretation predicts that the EPRG experiment should yield FTL communications. > If that is not true, either I have been terribly mislead or you have a groundbreaking result in QM. I don't know how groundbreaking they are, but QIT has led me to profound insights that Copenhagen could not, e.g. [2] [3]. It also leads to interesting questions, for example: on QIT it is immediately obvious that it is not possible to undo an entanglement without bringing the entangled particles physically back together again (because if this were possible that would lead to FTL). So it is a deep mystery why the two-slit experiment works at all, because every photon must be entangled at a minimum with the particle that emitted it. I don't know, but I suspect that if you pursued this line of thought it would lead to some insight about how lasers work. [1] http://www.fisica.net/mecanica-quantica/Griffiths%20-%20Introduction%20to%20quantum%20mechanics.pdf http://www.fisica.net/mecanica-quantica/Griffiths%20-%20Intr... [2] http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/12/quantum-teleportation-demystified.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/12/quantum-teleportation-dem... [3] http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/10/parallel-universes-and-arrow-of-time.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/10/parallel-universes-and-ar...