4 ms·
What's complex about it? ISPs should be dumb pipes. They shouldn't care what you use them for any more than the electric company does. Seems pretty black-and-wh
by mikeash 9y ago
What's complex about it? ISPs should be dumb pipes. They shouldn't care what you use them for any more than the electric company does. Seems pretty black-and-white to me.
- BoorishBears 9y agoAnd I disagree, because the average consumer would not want to pay for what it would cost if the ISPs priced that into their fees. There’s no need for an ISP to throttle, they could just charge consumers the exact cost to build out as much capacity as they need. But that cost would raise rates to one that consumers don’t want to pay. To me this is about idealism meaning the real world. In a perfect would I’d love for ISPs to be dumb pipes, but even in your example, Electricity companies don’t charge you like a dumb pipe and offer time of use pricing, pricing based on zones, discounts or rebates based on energy efficiency. Likewise different sites generate enormously different costs on the ISPs side, and consumers are benefiting from ISPs balancing being a dumb pipe, with not charging the consumers the price of a pipe that can carry every type of load at every time at perfect speeds.
- mikeash 9y agoMost ISPs are currently dumb pipes. The net neutrality fight is to keep them that way. The average consumer is paying for what it would cost, given that ISPs generally turn a profit.
- BoorishBears 9y agoI don’t know any ISP that doesn’t have some degree of throttling, and zero rating is becoming more and more common
- mikeash 9y agoThrottling has nothing to do with net neutrality, unless it's targeted at specific services.
- BoorishBears 9y agoAnd it is... video services specifically
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y agoWell, that happens and is a net neutrality violation. But it's a net neutrality violation because it distinguishes between services, not because of the throttling. There are plenty of perfectly "net neutral" plans that throttle your connection after a certain amount of traffic in a month.
- BoorishBears 9y agoI know that, I know what net neutrality is, I don’t want to discuss this anymore I got downvotes enough for one day.
- mikeash 9y agoSome ISPs do indeed throttle some video services, and that’s a violation. It wouldn’t vastly increase prices for them to stop doing that, though. They’re doing it to push their own video services, not to save money.
- ricardobeat 9y agoAt this point, everything should be encrypted and ISPs shouldn’t even have the ability to discern what kind of traffic is going through their pipes. We’re a bit behind schedule on that...
- icebraining 9y agoBut these services have no incentive to do that - they want to be detected, so that they can be zero-rated (or receive any other advantage). How would you prevent them from opting out of your encryption system?
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y agoI think you don't understand what net neutrality is? Yes, electricity companies do charge you like a dumb pipe, exactly as ISPs should (and most are). A dumb pipe does not mean that the ISP cannot count your traffic and bill you for it, possibly even at varying rates throughout the day. It only means that the ISP doesn't get to look at the contents of your traffic, just as the electricity company doesn't get too look at what you use your electricity for. A non-neutral electricity company would be one that didn't charge you according to load on their network and generation facilities, but based on the application you use electricity for. Now, they usually do offer various plans intended for different types of uses--but mind you that that does not mean that you only get to use them for those uses, the contract is about load profiles and energy prices. For example, you might have a plan for storage heaters. But there is absolutely nothing that forces or requires you to use the electricity for storage heaters. The contracts is simply about different prices per kWh during different times of the day. If you run a startup that produces gadgets at night using cheap electricity from that plan, that is perfectly fine. Fetching email from gmail's IMAP server produces exactly the same load on an ISP's network as fetching email from some local email provider's IMAP server. Net neutrality is about not distinguishing between those. There is nothing wrong with offering a "1 GB/month, 1 Mb/s" plan that is well-suited for only receiving and sending emails. The problem is when they want to prevent me from using IRC instead, or they only allow specific email providers.
- BoorishBears 9y agoI do understand net neutrality, my example might have been poor though. Electricity companies can’t (reliably) tell what you’re using the power for so in a sense they do act as dumb pipes (except they do care if you use it for commercial vs residential), but they don’t strive to be dumb pipes. To put it in terms of your space heater analogy, they can’t give you electricity that only works with your space heater, so they’ll give you rebates for using a specific space heater. The goal is the same, the implementation just takes the limitations of granularity in metering electricity usage. I know what net neutrality is, and I have no problem with a non-neutral internet. It’s not the same as a lawless unregulated internet. Right now zero-rating is what ISPs have taken advantage of it for. People argue zero rating means base prices must be encompassing the cost of the “free” service, but it’s coming with strings attached like reduced bandwidth or as a way to attract new users. While I do feel certain companies might be able to use zero-rating to reinforce monopolies, I don’t feel zero-rating inherently creates an environment where companies can’t compete. If ISPs do take further moves to absurd it, those moves can still be regulated/blocked, but my experience in many other countries has been that it doesn’t progress further than that, certainly not to the 2 mock images shown in the article (the one real one has a subtle, but important difference, access isn’t blocked if you don’t choose one of those packages, you just pay the normal base rate) That being said, I’ll refrain from talking about net neutrality on HN. This is the crowd that would have the most reasons to support it. After all, zero rating on Netflix doesn’t help a unicorn become the next Netflix, and there are plenty of people here who feel like all of this goes against the very spirit of the internet. But it’s impossible to have a meaningful discussion when everything you say is immediately downvoted to ghost status. I mean I made that were barely more than a single fact got downvoted until they couldn’t easily be read anymore, and people are still mass downvoting my statements hours later.