5 ms·
I agree that net neutrality becomes much less important if there's real competition between ISPs. But for most of the US, there isn't. Monopolies and non-compet
by mikeash 9y ago
I agree that net neutrality becomes much less important if there's real competition between ISPs. But for most of the US, there isn't. Monopolies and non-competitive duopolies are common. Yes, this should be fixed, but it's really, really hard, far harder than regulating neutrality.
- Thisisdense 9y agoNo such thing in Portugal as well
- BoorishBears 9y agoGetting blanket downvotes for going against the hivemind so nevermind.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y agoIn other words: They have not used it for anything more than trying to kill their competition? Well, nothing to worry about then!
- BoorishBears 9y agoWhat? Where did I say something about killing competition?
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y agoWhat else is zero-rating possibly intended to do? Zero-rating is obviously selling below cost, and businesses sell below cost to kill competition.
- will_hughes 9y ago> What else is zero-rating possibly intended to do? Zero-rating is obviously selling below cost, and businesses sell below cost to kill competition. That's not the only scenario for zero-rating. Not too long ago, getting international backhaul in Australia was absurdly expensive. So various smaller ISPs joined IXs, and then offered customers plans which had a certain amount of quota for your usual traffic, but traffic which was routed via an IX was zero-rated. This included game servers, FTP mirrors, usenet, and various internet radio services. This is technically against net neutrality, but I don't see this as being a bad thing for anyone involved.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y agoWell, what I meant was zero-rating of services, which is what this discussion is about (rather than based on actual operational costs). And actually, arguably, that is not necessarily against net neutrality. Net neutrality ultimately is about whether anyone can send traffic to the ISP's customers under the same, non-monopolistic, conditions. As such, making a geographic distinction isn't really that much of a problem, if it is not used to also implement other distinctions. The question is: Could anyone who would have wanted to send traffic to those customers bought transit on the open market at market rates in order to deliver traffic to within the reach of the zero rating? It's a problem if you can buy special interconnects from the ISP in order to have your traffic zero-rated. It's not really a problem if the ISP says "any traffic delivered to this exchange (that is well-connected to many competing transit providers) is zero-rated".
- mikeash 9y agoWhat's complex about it? ISPs should be dumb pipes. They shouldn't care what you use them for any more than the electric company does. Seems pretty black-and-white to me.
- BoorishBears 9y agoAnd I disagree, because the average consumer would not want to pay for what it would cost if the ISPs priced that into their fees. There’s no need for an ISP to throttle, they could just charge consumers the exact cost to build out as much capacity as they need. But that cost would raise rates to one that consumers don’t want to pay. To me this is about idealism meaning the real world. In a perfect would I’d love for ISPs to be dumb pipes, but even in your example, Electricity companies don’t charge you like a dumb pipe and offer time of use pricing, pricing based on zones, discounts or rebates based on energy efficiency. Likewise different sites generate enormously different costs on the ISPs side, and consumers are benefiting from ISPs balancing being a dumb pipe, with not charging the consumers the price of a pipe that can carry every type of load at every time at perfect speeds.
- mikeash 9y agoMost ISPs are currently dumb pipes. The net neutrality fight is to keep them that way. The average consumer is paying for what it would cost, given that ISPs generally turn a profit.
- BoorishBears 9y agoI don’t know any ISP that doesn’t have some degree of throttling, and zero rating is becoming more and more common
- mikeash 9y agoThrottling has nothing to do with net neutrality, unless it's targeted at specific services.