4 ms·
I’m so tired of seeing this example being brought up. The packages are for making those services cheaper not more expensive. This is essentially partial zero-r
by BoorishBears 9y ago
I’m so tired of seeing this example being brought up.
The packages are for making those services cheaper not more expensive. This is essentially partial zero-rating.
Zero-rating has its own effect on competition, but people are acting like an ISP is blocking access based on subscriptions which is an doomsday of a non-neutral internet I’ve seen trumpeted that’s I don’t believe will happen, and hasn’t happen in other countries.
Well I guess net neutrality is another one of those topics I’d better know to not go against the guard on.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y agoYou do realize that there is no difference in the result whether you start with high prices and then selectively make some services cheaper or you start with low prices and then selectively make everything else more expensive, right?
- BoorishBears 9y agoWhere have the prices been shown to rise? US carriers didn’t raise prices when they introduced their “soft” zero rating on video traffic. My point is everyone is jumping to the worst conclusions instead of objectively considering the situation around what ISPs are doing without net neutrality laws. Not supporting blanket pro net neutrality talk != supporting an unregulated lawless Wild West of ISPs but everyone acts like it is (see how quickly my comment was buried before anyone even responded)
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y ago> Where have the prices been shown to rise? You do realize that the result is the same, whether you first reduce your prices as costs decrease and then raise them again, or just don't bother reducing them in the first place, right? > US carriers didn’t raise prices when they introduced their “soft” zero rating on video traffic. So, are you saying that moving around the video traffic doesn't cost them anything? Or how else are they paying for that, if not by keeping the price for other traffic artificially high?
- BoorishBears 9y agoIt cost them less, you get downgraded to lower res streams and in exchange they don’t limit how much you can view. And the idea is they have a choice, raise base prices, or add packages. It’s not add packages or don’t.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y agoNothing wrong with packages. Just everything wrong with packages for particular services. The solution is really simple: Offer packages of traffic. If people need 10 GB/month for low-res video streaming, then sell 10 GB/month for 5 EUR.
- rnhmjoj 9y agoReading the articles it seems this ISP is forcing you to buy a package of services to get any internet access at all; this is terrifying. Optional zero-rating is bad but not much worse than internet with a stupidly low data-cap already is, even if the net result may be the same.
- BoorishBears 9y agoThat’s not true, this image has made at rounds already, multiple first hand users confirmed this is a set of options to save on top of a base package.
- icebraining 9y agoThat depends on the base package, if you get a pre-paid plan you don't get any included Internet service. You can still access the regular Internet, but it debits 2€ for any day you use it, and only gives you 60MB for that day. To use more you must purchase some extra package.
- soneil 9y agoI’d think that still stifles competition. If netflix and youtube don’t count towards your data cap (which seems to be how this particular example works), surely that’s going to influence how you view other streaming services? “I could use amazon prime, but my data cap will be blown after two movies”, etc. It’s not really competition if the ISP picks the winners.
- BoorishBears 9y agoIt does stifle competition, but it benefits the consumer, which is why I feel like it should be regulated on a case by case basis. The same way a company can take multiple steps that stifle innovation, that individually to end completion, but cumulatively put it in a position where it can’t be competed with.
- ch4s3 9y ago> but it benefits the consumer In the short run, until there is no competition. This is a classic tactic of monopolists; serve consumers at below cost, wait until competition dies, and then raise prices to higher than pre competition levels.
- BoorishBears 9y agoThat’s what the second paragraph addresses. To me the focus should be on those monopolies, not this singular “tool” in their arsenal that itself, isn’t a huge factor in a formation of a monopoly
- ch4s3 9y agoWhy not both?
- alkonaut 9y agoEven just having one service such as Netflix not count against a data quota is terrible and completely undermines competition. I don't think there is any major difference between that, and any other version of a non-neutral internet. Its barely a slippery slope.