6 ms·
Bill Thurston answers: What's a mathematician to do?
- paulpauper 9y agoImho, it boils down to solving problems, explaining existing phenomena, and to gain a deeper understanding of things. For example, if you suspend a rope between two anchors, empirically, it looks like a parabola, but it's actually a hyperbolic cosine. fascinating.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hdevarajan 9y agoThurston is low dimensional topologist and Fields medalist. From the Wikipedia page: 'In fact, Thurston resolved so many outstanding problems in foliation theory in such a short period of time that it led to a kind of exodus from the field, where advisors counselled students against going into foliation theory[1] because Thurston was "cleaning out the subject"'
- Simon_says 9y agowas, sadly.
- unixhero 9y ago"Closed as question is not ...[x]" sigh
- paulpauper 9y agoI suspect a question is closed when it has already been sufficiently answered . Keeping it open means it would keep being 'bumped' and become redundant. If you look at Quora, often a popular question will have 4 good answers and dozens of low-quality ones. better to just close the question then.
- combatentropy 9y agoThen I wonder if Stack Overflow should add a reason for closing, "sufficiently answered," so that the editor can choose that instead of the inaccurate and incendiary "no longer relevant."
- akvadrako 9y agoThere can always be a better answer.
- etiam 9y agoInvigorating. And predictably the question has been closed, as "no longer relevant [...] This question is unlikely to help any future visitors; it is only relevant to a small geographic area, a specific moment in time, or an extraordinarily narrow situation that is not generally applicable to the worldwide audience of the internet." Makes me wonder how Stack Exchange is still getting both good questions and good answers.
- aluhut 9y agoGood SEO.
- phaemon 9y agoProbably because they have the discipline to close questions that aren't appropriate, even when people like the answers. Good for them.
- curiousgal 9y agoHonestly, it would deter me from ever answering a question there again. They could create a different category for these types of questions, other than simply closing them. The "moderators" are too self-absorbed in their self-righteousness.
- svat 9y agoWhy? The only thing closing a question does is prevent new people from answering. In some sense it's in fact a better “deal” for those who did answer before the question was closed, because they'll have less “competition”. (Of course no one is thinking in those terms, but I'm trying to understand why questions being closed or not should be a deterrence to someone answering questions that are open.) Where do terms like “self-righteousness” come from? (Also note that it's not the “moderators” who close or open questions, but the community itself: anyone with over 3000 points can close or reopen, which right now is over 500 users on MathOverflow. It's a small site as it's for research mathematicians; for comparison on Stack Overflow there are over 46000 users who can vote to close or reopen questions.)
- 9y ago
- KGIII 9y agoIf you scroll down, you'll find an answer where it appears that math broke their brain and they left to go start a restaurant and then did other things like computer graphics. The math department is home to some tragically spectacular mental breakdowns. But, I don't think his answer is limited just to mathematicians. The gist of it is 'Go do good things and be smart.' I think those same things could apply to even someone without a high school diploma, though probably with less chance of efficacy. It's a great response and unfortunate that they closed it.
- lainon 9y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8265509 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8265509
- j7ake 9y agoThurston has a great answer. People need to avoid thinking in academic departments and focus on asking which problems are important to them. Focus on problem first, then figure out what basic principles you need to tackle the problem, regardless of the field these basic principles come from.
- zitterbewegung 9y agoDoing mathematics and furthering human understanding is great. The problem is that no one wants to tell you how the sausage is made . It’s mainly on the backs of graduate students that have no chance of being professors. The ones that know how to code go into competition with people that have Bachelors in CS and four years of work experience . The good ones can land a Data science job . The ones that can’t become adjuncts forever in some community college. There are fewer and fewer that can win this rich mans game .
- alphaalpha101 9y ago>It’s mainly on the backs of graduate students that have no chance of being professors. In my experience, the people that say this are people that tried to do postgraduate study but either failed there or failed to get a job afterwards because they just aren't good enough. There are many wildly different jobs you can get with a PhD in Mathematics, from programming jobs to data analysis jobs, from finance jobs to insurance jobs. And yes, the top few can go on to become an academic. It's ridiculous to expect that even half of successful mathematics PhD students will go on to become academics. If that were the case, mathematicians could only have one or two PhD students in their entire career or the sector would grow unsustainably quickly.
- metafunctor 9y agoHaving personally known two mathematicians who committed suicide because they felt they didn't amount to anything by their 30s, I wish every new mathematician would read this post.
- jason_slack 9y agoThis is helpful for me. As someone who is old (well 40), lol, and studying to get a math degree. I often wonder what I will do with it. I already have a CS degree. I could teach, I could work to solve the unsolved math problems, I could work on compression or cryptography. I guess I still don't know what I do.