4 ms·
I think the difference is that people know when the image messes with their perception. i.e. we see the optical illusion, yes, but we also know it's not real, o
by ars 9y ago
I think the difference is that people know when the image messes with their perception. i.e. we see the optical illusion, yes, but we also know it's not real, or incorrect in some way.
A neutral net does not. That's the missing element - neural nets "need to know how to know when they don't know".
- egeozcan 9y agoI don't think so. Many of my friends thought I was trolling them when I told them "the actual color" of "the dress" [1]. When we do know that there is an optical illusion, it is because of the context we have that the machines don't, like, we can read the title of the article ("These 11 optical illusions will blow your mind"). [1]: https://www.google.de/search?q=the+dress https://www.google.de/search?q=the+dress
- roywiggins 9y agoOur eyes are much, much better at handling color balance "in person" than on a screen. Normally, we have the entire surrounding environment to compare colors to and make a guess.
- egeozcan 9y agoThis is what I'm saying: We have more context. There is theoretically nothing keeping machines doing the same kinds of analyses when given the same information.
- svantana 9y agoActually in this sense NNs are actually smarter than humans - NNs can guide you to its weak points, through backprop. That is indeed how adversarial examples are found. Vice versa, people are notoriously bad at finding their own weaknesses (as demonstrated by Dunning-Kruger etc).
- fjsolwmv 9y agoDunning-kruger doesn't mean the popular misconception you are thinking of