3 ms·
You make it sound like "more choosy" is a bad thing. Aren't all the big technology companies choosy about who they'll hire? The numbers given the essay suggest
by eesmith 9y ago
You make it sound like "more choosy" is a bad thing. Aren't all the big technology companies choosy about who they'll hire?
The numbers given the essay suggest that Sweden's employment rate is not unusually low, so is your comment really a meaningful basis for making a policy decision?
When it's easy to fire people, it's also easy to fire people for personally motivated reasons, rather than reasons which are good for the company.
For example, the boss might want to fire someone to bring in a family member. Nepotism isn't illegal. But the union contract helps prevent these sorts of (non-business related) firings.
People tend to work better when they aren't worried about being fired for reasons that have little or nothing to do with their job.
- WalterBright 9y ago> You make it sound like "more choosy" is a bad thing. Aren't all the big technology companies choosy about who they'll hire? Let me rephrase - less willing to give someone a chance who may not have done well in the job interview. > employment rate is not unusually low Wouldn't that also suggest that finding another job won't be difficult? > fire people for personally motivated reasons Why would you want to work for someone that dislikes you and doesn't want you around? > People tend to work better when they aren't worried about being fired A workplace where people hate each other doesn't sound like a happy place, either.
- eesmith 9y agoI understand the model you are presenting. My question again is, is it useful enough to guide policy decisions? Based on the information given, it doesn't seem like it is. Perhaps there are other mechanisms in place (like this job-security council) which compensate? How would you expect the Swedish job market to look if employees didn't have these protections? You ask: "Why would you want to work for someone that dislikes you and doesn't want you around?" Here's an example from the blog of a small-town teacher I read. If you are a teacher, and coach Little League baseball, and the principal puts pressure on you to place the county education board member's grandson on the team (say it's from pressure from the board member), then who's going to back you if you refuse, and end up on the principal's bad side? Or are you going to quit your job, uproot your family, and move away? Because it's likely not easy to find another teaching job in the same small town. To put it another way, why is it that if 1 person dislikes you out of the 40 or 50 people you work with, and that person happens to be the principal, then you have to leave? Why does he deserve that much power over you?
- WalterBright 9y ago> power I've been an employee, and an employer. As an employee, one feels that the employer is holding the power, being an employer, one feels the employee has the power. After all, the employee can quit at a moment's notice and go work for someone else. Good employees are hard to find.
- SamReidHughes 9y agoYour example, which I presume is from America because we have Little League and counties, involves a public institution. In a private institution the person paying you money to do stuff for him deserves the power to stop paying you money because it's his money. It's also the employee's ability to make contracts that you're talking about -- you'd hinder an employee's ability to agree to a contract with a lower risk of employing them. I happen to find it convenient to be able to agree that if somebody doesn't like my output they can stop paying me. It's part of how I get them to start paying me in the first place. You would take this freedom to make contracts away from me. Presumably because you think you know better, and by taking away my freedom, you enhance my negotiating position. Why do you deserve that much power over me?
- eesmith 9y agoYes, I am an American, and the teacher from a public school in the US. The examples are easily transferred to private industry - I can be a volunteer Little League coach while working for a private company, and my department head wants to be on the good side of the CEO whose wants his grandson to be on the team. "In a private institution the person paying you money to do stuff for him deserves the power to stop paying you money because it's his money" Yes, I believe one of the "other mechanisms in place" in Sweden compared to the US is that Swedish workplaces are more structured around consensus and democracy, while US workplaces are more hierarchical and control-based - a sort of mini-monarchy. "I happen to find it convenient to be able to agree that if somebody doesn't like my output they can stop paying me." I believe Swedish companies can fire people who are unable to do their job. The question is, do you find it convenient that you can be fired for reasons which have nothing to do with your job? The Little League example is one. How do you feel about not being paid because your boss wants to hire a poorly qualified relative instead? Or not being paid because you refuse to work on weekends? "You would take this freedom to make contracts away from me. Presumably because you think you know better, and by taking away my freedom, you enhance my negotiating position." I did not understand this argument. What essential freedoms are taken away from private Swedish companies or from employees in Swedish companies? How has this had detrimental effects on the Swedish economy or lifestyle?
- jernfrost 9y agoI am a Norwegian and I know people who have worked under American style easy firing laws. From what they have told it is not a very good model. It causes resentment and disloyalty towards the company. People say they are much more loyal to a Norwegian company, because they feel it is loyalty both ways. In American companies, people tend to give less shit about their company because they know the company is never there to have their back. I don't think it is without reason that when American companies fire people, they are not allowed to be around and get all their stuff in a box to not sabotage the company. Such practice is evidence of very weak mutual respect, trust and loyalty. Ultimately that is a bad way of running an economy. You incur very high transaction costs in business when trust levels are low. I've seen this myself when American companies have been involved in buying Norwegian companies. American companies are completely overdoing it when it comes do due diligence, writing contracts and involving lawyers. This represents a huge unnecessary cost. This experience is not unknown to others as well. You can read about Japanese experience with American work life. They are also used to a model with high degrees of loyalty. I read about a Japanese company trying to run the Japanese way in the US. They hired people for modest salary because they used lots of money on training to get very skilled employees. The problem was that this model was impossible in the US, because as soon as employees got the skills they switched to a higher paid company, which offered no training. The Japanese company did not understand how to build skills in the US. And rightly so. That is a big problem in the US. A huge part of the population have very low skilled jobs because it is very hard to raise the skill level of employees in the US, when you don't have a high chance of retaining those workers. Of course there are pros and cons to both approaches. Norwegian and Japanese companies are more likely to keep unproductive workers as you say. But seen from a holistic view, for society as a whole that must be a better approach than producing lots of homeless people, or people living off welfare.
- WalterBright 9y ago> I don't think it is without reason that when American companies fire people, they are not allowed to be around and get all their stuff in a box to not sabotage the company. Unfortunately, all it takes is one bad actor to ruin it for everyone, and the company then goes "have security escort him out" from then on. > But seen from a holistic view, for society as a whole that must be a better approach than producing lots of homeless people, or people living off welfare. Easier firing of less productive people leading to homelessness / welfare would require it to be impossible to get another job. That seems a stretch. If the company accumulates enough unproductive people, it goes out of business and everyone gets dumped on the street.
- eesmith 9y agoI heard back from a friend of mine working for a Swedish company. He told me a story about "more choosy" from another viewpoint. His department got a new department head, who previously had been working in a US branch of the company. He wanted to increase the department head count, so they started the hiring process. One of the candidates came through. The employees almost all thought the candidate was unqualified. The department head disagreed, and wanted to hire the employee anyway. The union intervened, and the candidate was not hired. As you say, "A workplace where people hate each other doesn't sound like a happy place, either." Why should the boss get to choose who you are going to work with?
- stale2002 9y agoMore choosy means that work will be perpetually understaffed, and there will never be enough people to do the work, even if the company WANTS to hire more, they just can't take the risk.
- nickpp 9y agoAnd the company will turn to other ways of getting that work done: contractors&temps. Maybe this is why the "share economy" is so popular lately.
- eesmith 9y agoAre Swedish companies perpetually understaffed, moreso than in (say) the US? The report doesn't lead me to that conclusion.
- WalterBright 9y agoBusiness work is hardly steady-state. Being unable to quickly shrink/expand the workforce means the business will be perpetually over/understaffed, making the business less competitive. Of course, there's always going to be friction in changing staff. But increasing the friction should be approached with caution.
- eesmith 9y agoYes, you are correct that businesses are not in a steady-state. I'm pretty sure that Swedish companies employ contractors for this situation, just like US companies do. And as the article point out, Swedish companies can have massive layoffs if need. I really feel like the negative effects you are thinking of are not, on their own, significant enough to use your model to guide policy decisions. Perhaps the Swedes have given it sufficient caution? By the way, one example I found of short-term contract work in Sweden is as a temporary replacement for when an employee takes a year off for paternity leave.
- WalterBright 9y ago