5 ms·
Here in Germany we add half of this years world's photovoltaic solar panel production. Much of that is installed by small consumers, houses, farms, factories. T
by lispm 16y ago
Here in Germany we add half of this years world's photovoltaic solar panel production. Much of that is installed by small consumers, houses, farms, factories. This gets us away from the huge expensive centralized energy production. Panel by panel.
A new nuclear power plant has not been built in he last twenty years and is not planned.
Thus we can concentrate on bringing the price of renewable energy down.
The new reactors that are under construction in Finland and France are both much more expensive than planned and are coming years late. France also has to invest several hundred million Euros per reactor to keep them running. They haven't done much for those - a full fifty reactors. Here in Germany we need to spend some ten more more billion Euros on closing old East German reactors and for cleaning up an experimental storage site for nuclear waste. That experiment has failed. Spectacularly. Billions and billions that could have been invested in clean and renewable energy.
- motters 16y agoI really wish we had the same policy here in the UK. Here it's extremely rare to see a solar panel anywhere, and it seems highly likely that new nuclear (fission) reactors will be built in the near future.
- hugh3 16y agoWhat, to capitalise on the eight days per year of British sunshine?
- stcredzero 16y agoThere's a British company that makes evacuated heat-pipe solar hot water elements. They work very well in England in the winter. http://www.thermomax.com/ http://www.thermomax.com/
- motters 16y agoIf there's enough sunshine to grow grass and trees, there's enough to make energy.
- berntb 16y ago>>The new reactors [..] are both much more expensive than planned and are coming years late. There hasn't been many nuclear plants built for quite a while. Teething problems are to be expected. That said, there seems to be strong arguments for solar power's cost going so low that it takes over in a decade or two. The world should probably be thankful that Germany waste lots of money to hasten that date. But solar energy won't solve the energy generation in Finland or the rest of Scandinavia (hint -- think sun hours/angle in winter :-(.) But maybe Polywell or General Fusion works and solves all problems...?
- stcredzero 16y agoFor far northern countries, I'd put my money on advanced fission designs and perhaps Thorium.
- roel_v 16y agoOr they can just install their panels in another country and pay someone a bit for the use of that land.
- vegai 16y agoWe tend to be wary of such solutions after being screwed by pretty much everyone in the last big conflict. Sure, things are different now in many ways, but ...
- stcredzero 16y agoIn that case - Uranium from seawater!
- confuzatron 16y agoHmm. Except that 'huge expensive centralized energy production' produces electricity much more cheaply than the solar panels. If this wasn't the case, the German government wouldn't need the huge expensive system of subsidies for PV. By all means spend lots of money to encourage production of more expensive electricity, but don't pretend it's cheaper.
- jksmith 16y agoThis is an issue that's taken care of by the advancement of technology in the end. Carr describes well the economic sense for centralized power production in his book "The Big Switch," but centralized power production using legacy technology doesn't lend itself nearly as well to cost/benefit ratios as for instance units of computing power which have gotten substantially cheaper over time, so mainframe computing fell by the wayside. PV technology is more akin to computer technology than legacy power technology, so local power production using PV will end up being cheaper, provided your local utility doesn't step in and squash PV for their own benefit. Means becomes ends.
- confuzatron 16y agoIf PV technology is indeed akin to computer technology (how, exactly?) then perhaps subsidies aren't needed, just as they weren't needed in the arena of computing. I am just not convinced that the government funnelling huge amounts of money towards buying technology that isn't economical results in the technology becoming economical any faster.
- lispm 16y agoNo subsidies in the development of computing? That's a joke? Wait, who do you think has paid for the research. Ever heard of ARPA or DARPA? The whole computer technology came out of military applications paid by the tax payer. Ever heard of the origins of what we know as Internet, the ARPAnet? Google for 'secret history of silicon valley' and view the movie.
- 16y ago
- hga 16y agoI've not followed what's happening in France (there is, shall we say, less transparency in that country), but the Finnish reactor is having problems due to lax supervision of (sub)contractors: foundational concrete was not done correctly, forgings have to be recast, etc. These aren't nuclear power issues per se but general competence of construction (supervision) issues. I gather the French site has some of these sorts of problems as well. Getting onto strictly nuclear power issues, these are the first two attempts to build the new European Pressurized Reactor: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Pressurized_Reactor http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Pressurized_Reactor. It's not at all surprising if the first examples of a new design end up being more expensive and slower to build (which of course also means more expensive): there's new learning curves, lots of new regulatory work required, likely redesigns required, etc. Germany's experience with Soviet design East German plants would not seem to be applicable outside of the former Iron Curtain (although we can thank God none of them were of the RMBK design). Your failed "experimental storage site for nuclear waste" is just that, yours. You are of course welcome to decide that nuclear power is a failure and e.g. depend on natural gas from the former Soviet Union (or just living in the cold and dark), but most of the rest of the world doesn't seem to be following your path. As for your desire for "clean and renewable energy", none that I'm aware of that can be done on a large scale (I'm excluding geo-thermal) are suitable for either base line or peaking power unless you throw batteries into the mix. Which aren't particularly clean, low maintenance or long lived. (There is one trick you can do which is to pump water uphill into a reservoir but the Greens generally veto that sort of thing, we've moved from NIMBY (Not In My Back Yard) to BANANA (Build Absolutely Nothing Anywhere Near Anything)).
- uvdiv 16y ago>Here in Germany we add half of this years world's photovoltaic solar panel production. Much of that is installed by small consumers, houses, farms, factories. This gets us away from the huge expensive centralized energy production. Panel by panel. Your solar capacity only exists because of extreme government intervention. It's far more expensive than what you call "expensive" centralized electricity. The most recent feed-in tariffs are 31.9 - 43.0 Euro cents per kWh (2009 installations), fixed for 20 years. Older installations are given subsidies: the original rates were 45.7 - 54.7 Euro cents/kWh (2004 installations). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_incentives_for_photovoltaics#Germany http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_incentives_for_photov... http://www.solarbuzz.com/FastFactsGermany.htm http://www.solarbuzz.com/FastFactsGermany.htm For comparison, wholesale spot prices for utilities in Germany averaged 3.9 Euro cents/kWh for baseload in 2009 (through 3Q), and 5.0 Euro cents/kWh for peaking power. Residential retail rates (as of 2007 -- slightly dated) are about 14 Euro cents/kWh before taxes. http://rwecom.online-report.eu/2009/ir/3/reviewofoperations/environment/germanelectricityprices.html http://rwecom.online-report.eu/2009/ir/3/reviewofoperations/... http://www.cbs.nl/en-GB/menu/themas/industrie-energie/publicaties/artikelen/archief/2007/2007-2187-wm.htm http://www.cbs.nl/en-GB/menu/themas/industrie-energie/public... >A new nuclear power plant has not been built in he last twenty years and is not planned. Your government banned them. >The new reactors that are under construction in Finland and France are both much more expensive than planned and are coming years late. Yes, they've had enormous cost overruns and are years late. And German solar power is an order of magnitude worse. We're talking about Olkiluoto #3 (Finland) and Flamanville #3 (France), the two new reactors being built in Europe. Both EPRs of 1,600 MW(electric) capacity (net). Olkiluoto had an inital cost estimate of €3 billion, and is overrun by 50% and counting (so €4.5 billion so far). Flamanville' overrun (to date) is smaller, from €3.3 B to €4.0 billion (20%). (These are the most recent numbers I can find; correct me if you find better ones.) http://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/29/business/energy-environment/29nuke.html http://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/29/business/energy-environmen... http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=newsarchive&sid=a40zu0t.S6k4 http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=newsarchive&sid=a... Crucially, nuclear reactors actually achieve their nameplate capacity -- they run at full load almost all the time. For example, look at these reactors' older siblings: Flamanville #2 has a lifetime load factor of 70.53%, and Olkiluoto #2, 93.55% (IAEA data). And this is typical. A 1,600 MWe EPR can conservatively be expected to average 1,100 MWe or more. http://www.iaea.org/cgi-bin/db.page.pl/pris.ophis.htm?country=FR&site=FLAMANVILLE&units=&refno=47&opyear=2009&link=HOT http://www.iaea.org/cgi-bin/db.page.pl/pris.ophis.htm?countr... http://www.iaea.org/cgi-bin/db.page.pl/pris.ophis.htm?country=FI&site=OLKILUOTO&units=&refno=4&opyear=2009&link=HOT http://www.iaea.org/cgi-bin/db.page.pl/pris.ophis.htm?countr... To date, all of German solar panels (i) add up to just one of these EPRs at best, (ii) have earmarked at the minimum €70 billion in subsidies between them, over their next 20 years. To be fair the present value of that €70 billion is a bit less (it's future money). But it's eye-opening. According to solar industry sources, there are some 11,500 MW of solar PV capacity in Germany (9.8 GW through 2009, and another 1.7 GW through May 2010). http://www.pv-tech.org/news/_a/germanys_solar_capa567_by_3gw_in_first_half_of_2010_more_fit_cuts_to_come/ http://www.pv-tech.org/news/_a/germanys_solar_capa567_by_3gw... The actual amount of electricity is only a tenth of that. If you look at PV power plants in Germany, their load factor is only around 11-13%. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_power_in_Germany#Largest_photovoltaic_plants http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_power_in_Germany#Largest_... Which you could independently predict by looking at a solar insolation map; for instance 1,000 kWh/year from a 1 kW capacity panel is a load factor of 11.4%. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:EU-Glob_opta_presentation.png http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:EU-Glob_opta_presentation.... So 11,500 MW of German PV capacity should generate only 11 billion kWh/year, or 1,250 MW agerage. All of it adds up to about one EPR. (To anyone actually reading this, I recommend Google Calculator for these kinds of calculations, type-checked with physical units like 'kWh'). And a lower bound for the committed subsidy is, using the lowest possible rate of 31.9 Euro cents/kWh, €70 billion: http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%2811%2C500+MW+*+0.11%29+*+20+years+*+0.319+Euro%2FkWh+in+Euro&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&oq=&gs_rfai= http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%2811%2C500+MW+*+0.... (The "PV tech" article gives a higher figure of €100 billion; I'm not sure what their assumptions are.)