6 ms·
Professors can’t stay silent about this extremist moment on campuses
- IslaDeEncanta 9y ago>Oh dear, these left wing protestors taking a microphone sure is comparable to fascists actually killing people. Give me a break.
- dang 9y agoWould you please stop using HN for political/ideological battle? You've done it quite a bit and it's not what this site is for. Similarly, would you please not post unsubstantive comments here? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- IslaDeEncanta 9y agoEvery comment in this thread is ideologically driven. It seems that if you don't want people commenting with political opinions, there shouldn't be political submissions. As far as substance goes, how is my comment less substantive than the top comment (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15575704 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15575704) on the thread? I said that it was foolish to consider protesting fascism to be worse than fascism, and that commenter said that protesters should be expelled. They're equally substantive comments that express opposing views on the issue in from the article.
- dang 9y agoA certain amount of politics is inevitable, but more than that turns HN into a war zone, which destroys the things the site exists for: intellectual curiosity and thoughtful conversation. So it's a tricky problem. We do two things to address it (see https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html): 1. Accounts that use HN primarily for political/ideological battle are obviously not using the site as intended, so we ban them. 2. Commenters are asked to avoid the inflammatory style of political argument. Comments need to get more civil and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive. Unfortunately it looks like you've been running afoul of both of these. You need to fix that if you want to keep commenting here. The "what about that other comment" argument, a.k.a. "the other person started it", doesn't really count as a defense because we can't possibly see everything that gets posted here. Not everyone who speeds gets pulled over for a ticket either. I agree with you that that comment was a bad one, but it doesn't mean yours were ok.
- evanlivingston 9y agoThe author is referring to students protesting the mandatory freshman lecture on Western Civilization, which has a history of being protested at Reed. There's a list of demands as well. http://reediesagainstracism.tumblr.com/demands http://reediesagainstracism.tumblr.com/demands Students typically have an incredibly small say in shaping the institutions that shape their future. If protesting wasn't uncomfortable, it wouldn't be effective.
- drjackyll 9y agoStudents shouldn’t have any say in shaping institutions they attend to gain knowledge. They are not smarter than their professors. Or if they disagree, they should attend another university and vite with their wallet/loan/whatever.
- slaymaker1907 9y agoThis post is poisonous to knowledge. I've politely corrected professors who I respect on multiple occasions. Just because you are informed about a particular subject does not mean that you are never wrong about that subject. I've noticed that STEM professors tend to be more willing to accept that they are wrong about something than in the humanities which I suspect is because it is much easier to prove that someone is incorrect about something in STEM.
- DashRattlesnake 9y agoI think students should definitely be able to offer polite feedback to their professors, like you describe. However, students definitely shouldn't be in a position to dictate the curriculum, which I think is more what the grandparent was talking about.
- detaro 9y agoTaken to that extreme, the only way to resolve issues with an university that "the university" (which seldom is a blob with one opinion) doesn't recognize itself would be by economic destruction of said university. That's horrendously inefficient when you have tools of diplomacy available. (Similar to how we do not resolve issues with governments by revolution, unless absolutely necessary) Also, there are clear legal limits to that approach.
- anjc 9y agoPut any student that disrupts the activities of the organisation through disciplinary procedures, ultimately expelling them if they can't behave. These disruptions will stop instantly, and they'll learn to behave appropriately in future.
- jostmey 9y agoI worry about an increasing movement toward radicalization on all ends of the political spectrum. I think Trump represented a shift to the far-right. Now I worry liberals might shift to the far-left. The middle ground seems to be disappearing
- agumonkey 9y agoHuman reality aside, it's an interesting tension phenomenon; like stormy weather.. voltage difference grows and then thunder. What impresses me more, in less than a decade we went from "ohhh web 2.0 and iphones" to "brexit, catalout, djt vs kju, nazi rallies". That's a quick and vast change.
- justinzollars 9y agoHaving lived in Ohio, the far right is exactly the same as the far left here in San Francisco. What is funny is they do not realize this. So I think its more a personality type selection than actual thought process or belief. The result of believing the other side is evil, is no one is willing to work together so we all lose. I think this could be a function of things we've built on the internet such as the ability to "hide" or "block" - even moderators are bad I, an elected DNC delegate is banned from the DailyKos because I disagreed with the Democrats proxy war policy on Syria. We are in trouble.
- DashRattlesnake 9y ago> So I think its more a personality type selection than actual thought process or belief. Yep, I think that's an important insight. I know a few people who grew up in very evangelical/conservative Christian communities who later dropped that ideology for left-wing ones (e.g. feminism). Their attitudes and behaviors are almost exactly the same, except that the content of their ideas has been swapped out.
- harpiaharpyja 9y agoWhy the downvotes? Seems like a relevant anecdote.
- gozur88 9y ago>We introduced ourselves and took our seats. But as we were about to begin, the protesters seized our microphones, stood in front of us and shut down the lecture. I'm not sure who gave these people the idea the heckler's veto is a legitimate tactic on a college campus or why the administration puts up with it. Those students should be summarily expelled.
- DashRattlesnake 9y agoI agree, they should be expelled for deliberately disrupting a class like that (or at least be forced to drop it with an F on their transcript). I think the lack of an appropriate response like that is what "gave these people the idea the heckler's veto is a legitimate tactic on a college campus." They tried it, it worked, so they do it again but bigger.
- shams93 9y agoThis is not how we did things in the 90s we used to debate these speakers and knock down their ideas with rational discourse it's not that hard to deflate the arguments of the far right they're mostly based on a series of bad assumptions like assuming everyone has a deep fear of anyone who looks different than them. It's better to let them speak and then deflate their arguments to the bone in debate.
- shams93 9y agoHowever when it comes to speakers advocating racism, race is not even real, there is only one human race with ethnic variations we don't allow people to come to medical schools to advocate using voodoo doll to cure cancer why should racists be speaking on college campuses?
- throwgoog452 9y agoRace is real. It's obvious when you look around. The major continental races show up on any k-clustered human genomic analysis. And any competent forensic anthropologist can identity race from skeletal remains. We should treat people with equal dignity. Race should not be a factor in individual decisions. Left doesn't stop there, though. They go further, insisting that race is not only irrelevant, but unreal. They step beyond fairness and into propaganda and lies. It's why the left is now on the retreat in every institution of power. I'm not the only one who's sick of having to parrot lies. By alienating people like me, people who would ordinarily be sympathetic to the left's causes, the left is guaranteeing a conservative backlash of biblical scope.
- smasuch 9y agowhole lotta people on this "hacker news" website that love to say authority shouldn't be questioned
- quotemstr 9y agoIt's a variant of Chesterton's fence: question an authority when you've learned how that authority works and what motivates it. For god's sake, if you want to be a contrarian, be intelligent about it. Some freshman with a copy of Derrida and a bullshit social justice grievance does not know enough to question 4,000 years of civilization.
- smasuch 9y agoI'll keep that in mind next time an non-economist posts something here about bitcoin
- omgitzwowzie 9y agoDo you? Anyone can question anything. That's how a free and fair society works. The professor has a lot of detailed knowledge on the topics they cover, but maybe not a radical critique of the underlying assumptions of what they teach. I'm not super familiar with this case, but glancing over the student's demands, many looked reasonable.
- quotemstr 9y agoOf course we have a right to question anything. But pragmatism demands that we don't spend an arbitrarily large amount of time indulging arbitrarily unlikely scenarios. These protesters are attempting to use brute force to give their horrible ideas more salience than they'd get in a fair intellectual forum, and that's not fair to people who actually want to learn about the far more well-established ideas that we've honed over thousands of years.
- rhn_mk1 9y agoIs this academic extremism something confined to the USA so far? I don't remember hearing about riots at European universities yet.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jseliger 9y agoIs this academic extremism something confined to the USA so far? I don't remember hearing about riots at European universities yet. It's actually fairly uncommon; most people are normal and most schools are reasonable: https://jakeseliger.com/2017/04/24/ninety-five-percent-of-people-are-fine-but-its-that-last-five-percent https://jakeseliger.com/2017/04/24/ninety-five-percent-of-pe... . But bad things are happening at a small number of schools, and, unfortunately, many administrators in particular are enabling or tolerating them, so those things make the news. There are some genuinely bad trends, but there's also some inflation of the state of reality on the ground.
- baud147258 9y agoThe universities and high schools students in France frequently participates in protest organized by left-wing orgs, like against all the last reforms to the work code.
- Invictus0 9y agohttp://reediesagainstracism.tumblr.com/demands http://reediesagainstracism.tumblr.com/demands I'm all for equality, but increasingly, these BLM-emulative student movements aren't egalitarian, but racist in the other direction. See #7 for example. Many of those demands, like #24, aren't even possible let alone reasonable. There are specific laws governing the employment of non-naturalized residents.
- dominotw 9y agowhats AODs, SES, CSO, HCC, MRC, PMP, CAT, CRES ?
- eesmith 9y agoThese are Reed-specific acronyms that anyone relevant at Reed would understand. I found almost all of them through a search like "PMP site:reed.edu", such as https://duckduckgo.com/?q=PMP+site%3Areed.edu https://duckduckgo.com/?q=PMP+site%3Areed.edu . AOD = "Alcohol and Other Drugs" violation. They probably want to know if there is a racial bias in who gets cited. SES = "Socioeconomic Status"; poor people in general have a harder time getting through college. CSO = "Community Safety Officer", aka, campus police HCC = Reed Health and Counseling Center PMP = Peer Mentor Program CRES = Comparative Race and Ethnic Studies program; think "comparative religion" course but for race and ethnic studies. CAT = "Each year, one quarter of the faculty is considered for reappointment, tenure, promotion, or an increase in salary. This evaluation is conducted by the faculty Committee on Advancement and Tenure (CAT), which makes recommendations to the president." (This was the hardest to find. It took a couple of minutes.)
- eesmith 9y agoThe demand that "CRES is to be taught by people of color" is also illegal.
- aslkdjaslkdj 9y agoThis is a good summary of the entire situation without the emotion of an op-ed: https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2017/09/11/reed-college-course-lectures-canceled-after-student-protesters-interrupt-class https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2017/09/11/reed-college-...
- gooseus 9y agoWith a link to their supplementary syllabus, I was curious about that: https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/0Bw66lFPav-Gsa3prajMyTDM2RXM https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/0Bw66lFPav-Gsa3prajMy...
- Tech-Noir 9y agoThis article is about students protesting a humanities course at Reed College in Oregon. Why does it have a huge image depicting protesters against "Nazis in Berkeley"?
- quotemstr 9y agoIt's simple: when it becomes acceptable to violate standards of civility when addressing particularly ultra-bad ideas, soon enough, every idea you don't like becomes ultra-bad.
- Top19 9y agoTim Wu, who coined the term “network neutrality”, wrote an excellent op-ed in the N.Y. Times yesterday. He said that now speech,l is a form of control and censorship, whereas 100 years ago limiting speech was a form of control / censorship. Interesting to see how the pendulum shifts...
- JungleGymSam 9y agoYou need to rewrite that whole paragraph. What?
- heurist 9y agoMight as well read the op-ed: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/27/opinion/twitter-first-amendment.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/27/opinion/twitter-first-ame...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mnglkhn2 9y agoI notice this submission is now flagged. Anybody has any idea as to why or in which way is inappropriate?
- grzm 9y agoLikely because discussions on this topic generally generate much more heat than light. That's not to say the issue isn't important or worth discussing; some forums (virtual and otherwise) are better suited for constructive discussions on a given topic than others. HN members often flag such submissions even when they agree with the premise for just this reason. To be clear, as I understand it, submissions receive a "[flagged]" tag when enough community members have flagged it: it's not a moderator action.
- mnglkhn2 9y agoThank you for the answer. I figured that it had to do with "keeping the peace."
- erdojo 9y agoThe prof should sue the students for harassment and tortuous interference. The student's are preventing the prof from doing her job and fulfilling her duties to the University.