3 ms·
This is selective accounting, there are many non-income Federal taxes that are ignored as well as who receives the benefits. Fortunately, the government has pub
by jandrewrogers 9y ago
This is selective accounting, there are many non-income Federal taxes that are ignored as well as who receives the benefits. Fortunately, the government has published data on total Federal taxes, not just income, as well as Federal transfers to households.[1] Among other things, it allows us to understand what percentage of the population pays net taxes to the Federal government, after all taxes paid and transfer income received is accounted for.
The data is somewhat surprising but I'll sum up: the top 20% of households are net tax producers, the next quintile pay their own way, and the bottom 60% are net tax consumers. In other words, the top 20% are subsidizing the bottom 60%, and 80% of the population effectively doesn't contribute to funding the government. Most of the middle class that thinks it pays Federal taxes doesn't, from a balance sheet perspective.
[1] https://taxfoundation.org/60-percent-households-now-receive-more-transfer-income-they-pay-taxes/ https://taxfoundation.org/60-percent-households-now-receive-...
- mikeash 9y agoThe transfer income numbers on their graph don’t match the ones in the CBO report they cite. Am I missing something? Edit: the numbers come from a supplemental table, not part of the main link. They did make this clear, I just missed it. Looking at that table, I’m highly suspicious of the conclusion that 80% of the country isn’t paying their own way. That particular table organizes households into quartiles by “before-tax income” which includes transfers and capital gains. That means a retired household receiving $50,000/year from a combination of social security, Medicaid, and capital gains gets lumped in with a working household receiving $50,000/year in wages. The retired household pays little tax and has massive transfers, while the working household pays more and gets much less.
- jgon 9y agoYes what you're missing is that the CBO is trying to give people relevant and accurate information and the Tax Foundation is a think tank founded by wealthy businessmen whose goal is to generally protest all tax increases and work to make people think that the US needs to greatly reduce taxes on the wealthy and on businesses.