3 ms·
> you are the one editorializing Of course I am, this is the comments to an article submitted to HackerNews. > Factually, capitalism/globalization has benefit
by c3534l 9y ago
> you are the one editorializing
Of course I am, this is the comments to an article submitted to HackerNews.
> Factually, capitalism/globalization has benefited lower classes materially
So we're in agreement.
> but has stripped them of agency
Social mobility has gone up since 1700s and continued to go up, with little more than a few hiccups along the way. Regardless, whether or not globalization is good or bad is an opinion and one that does not belong in an article about a single specific study on tax avoidance / possible tax evasion.
I'm not going to reply to the rest of what you said because of that same basic point. It's a complicated issue that tackles a lot of different areas of economics, history, and politics that doesn't have any real agreement with the experts that study those things. I certainly have no hope of doing the subject justice as a comment to an article.
And that's precisely why that shouldn't be shoehorned into an article about taxes to begin with. You have no hope of defending general condemnation of globalization and piling on nonspecific blame on the "ultra rich." If a journalist has an opinion and they want to argue why they're right backed up by objective facts and research, I'd love to read that sort of thing. But precisely because I don't want to live in an echo chamber, I don't want to hear your opinion stated as fact without anything to back up.
- barrkel 9y agowhether or not globalization is good or bad is an opinion You'll note that judging whether globalisation has helped capital more vs labour more is not an assertion of goodness or badness of globalisation, either way. Just like someone can say that cars make road accidents more likely (fact), without it being a judgement on whether cars are good or bad (opinion). I think you've been triggered and are reacting to something that wasn't written; you've over-read into the piece.
- SapphireSun 9y agoYou are living in a pre-11/9 mentality my friend. A few years ago, it was easy to think that material possessions were enough. The yawing chasms in the fabric of society are now baldly apparent. The old system is crashing. We need to acknowledge reality now and work as fast as possible to fix it after we figure out how.