4 ms·
Or rather, John Q Millenial is already using Google for most things and will search 5% more, but his dad John Q Boomer will finally be convinced to save $50/mon
by nostrademons 9y ago
Or rather, John Q Millenial is already using Google for most things and will search 5% more, but his dad John Q Boomer will finally be convinced to save $50/month by cutting his TV subscription and using the Internet only and will search 45% more. Or if that doesn't happen, John Q Boomer dies off and his place, as a consumer, is taken by John Q Student who already uses Google for 100% of his consumption.
That's what happens when you get a technological revolution - the new means of production completely replaces the old. Imagine you were born into a wealthy Virginia plantation in 1830. Your mental model of the world is that cotton is king, wealth comes from working and owning the land, slavery is just how things are done, traveling beyond your plantation is prohibitive in time and cost, and your family is part of the landed aristocracy and secure in its social position. If you live to the ripe old age of 90 and die in 1920, you will have seen cotton become just another commodity, inconceivable wealth generated by newfangled machines that you could not have imagined, over half the population move to tenements in cities, people crossing the Atlantic in a matter of days, slavery outlawed, and your plantation burned and its title stripped from you and divided amongst your slaves.
And yeah, if the state survives, it will absolutely get involved. I would bet even money that the concept of a nation state fractures and starts to disintegrate within 20 years, though. The idea of a nation-state as it currently exists is a construct of the Industrial Revolution: the new technologies being developed benefitted from vastly increased scale and social organization, and so those populations that organized themselves as nations were able to defeat those that did not in battle. (Note that in the example above, the "state" was Virginia in 1830 but the United States in 1920; the U.S. of 1830 was organized as a loose confederation of states while that of 1920 was organized as a nation-state with a strong central government, and it took the "Union" defeating the "Confederacy" to bring that about.) I don't know what sort of social organization the information age will demand, whether it'll be city-states in a trade confederation or corporate feudalism where you pledge loyalty for your employer in exchange for protection, but it'll likely not be the nation state as we currently know it.
- sova 9y agoThanks for sharing your view, I find it very illuminating. The notion of a nation-state must now adapt to be both regional and digital. We still need voting for local things, I want our =water supply to be clean, etc. Having people who are able to vote through the internet would theoretically strongly increase democracy-in-participation but it also brings in a lot of strong questions of how to do regional decisions when some people are casting their ballots remotely. If everyone became an absentee voter, the whole structure for regional decision making comes into question. Thanks for writing your write-up. I don't think I ever heard of an instance when a plantation's land was divided amongst the slaves that worked it, but that would be a form of social justice I can get behind.
- tryingagainbro 9y agoYeah but the state, union of states, confederations or whatever will exist in a form or another. Antitrust in pretty much hard coded into every country's legal doctrine.