3 ms·
> I doubt an electric motor can provide enough braking power to stop any car at highway speeds in the distance required by most countries This really isn't a p
by dsfyu404ed 9y ago
> I doubt an electric motor can provide enough braking power to stop any car at highway speeds in the distance required by most countries
This really isn't a problem. A hub motor should have no problem providing more stopping force than the tire/road interface can manage.
Heat is no problem either. Either dump the excess energy into a battery or just design a motor housing that can cool itself well enough. You have way more area and mass in a hub motor than in a brake rotor. You'd almost have to try to screw it up.
Maximum stopping distance laws are a complete joke. Anything can stop fast the first time. It's the 5th, 6th, 7th time that's a problem. Electric motors actually have the advantage in that situation because they fade more linearly than a hydraulic system.
- hinkley 9y agoMy research the last time I bought a new set of tires has convinced me to get new tires when I've only gone through half the rated mileage. The fall-off on braking performance on worn tires is crazy bad.
- tlb 9y agoHitting the brakes in a 2500 kg car at 100 mph generates a megawatt of braking energy (100 * 1607/3600 * 2500 * 9.8 * 0.9 = 984 kW). Plausibly sized hub motors can't handle this even momentarily. Brake rotors have less thermal mass, but can get red-hot without damage.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gandreani 9y agoAnother comment in this thread mentioned that the limiting factor is the MOSFET/Switch in the controller, instead of the motor itself
- abakker 9y agoHow many actuations is the motor good for? The mosfets? Brakes are great, work for a very long time, and have lots of redundancy, they are also easy to fix without diagnosing issues with mosfets, windings, switches, and wires.