9 ms·
Comcast Tries to Derail Fort Collins Community Broadband
- user-on1 9y agohow to encourage other cities to get such alternate broadband options? can colorado guide the rest of the cities and states to go through similar initiatives?
- germinalphrase 9y agoHow realistic is the idea of creating commmunity/neighborhood level wireless networks to sidestep anti-consumer manipulation? Anyone tried to do so?
- greglindahl 9y agoI was a part of the Google experiment in Mountain View, which had a mesh network built using equipment installed on light poles. People who bought the special ~$150 indoor receiver got decent throughput, once Ruckus Wireless shipped the 20th firmware revision (I kid not.) Almost all of the complaints came from people who didn't buy the right equipment. And that was a lot of people. A decade later, the same thing is probably much cheaper and easier.
- x0x0 9y agoThere's at least two people on HN that operate community wired networks. I have my notes on the wrong computer, but you could probably find them with search. The economics sound not great. Fixed wireless may have nicer economics with the right geography. My parents use it on a farm. I doubt you're going to be able to stream HD netflix/amazon over it through.
- robterrell 9y agoSince the Santa Rosa fires, I have been trying to figure out some combination of community broadband and/or mesh network that would provide service during and after emergencies. Our fire chief lives in Santa Rosa (and lost his house) and his description of the incredible chaos caused by a lack of communications was heartbreaking. i.e. People were evacuated to hospitals that were in the process of being evacuated. I wish there was a way to run a mesh network on a USB stick Pi Zero sort of thing. Just spread them around town and have a wifi network for when shit gets bad.
- sliverstorm 9y agoRather than giving full internet connectivity, some kind of local minimal bbs might be both more feasible and just as handy. You could maybe link nodes with ham digital radio, and serve clients with wifi. Each node would have a mirror of the bbs and sync changes.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- vvanders 9y agoArs had a great article on one in Orcas Island a while back: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2015/11/how-a-group-of-neighbors-created-their-own-internet-service/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2015/11/how-a... Somewhat unique situation but very cool.
- nickpsecurity 9y agoHere's Chris Hacken's writeup on his NEPA operation: http://chrishacken.com/starting-an-internet-service-provider/ http://chrishacken.com/starting-an-internet-service-provider... Costs here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13689309 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13689309
- rpedela 9y agoWhen I traveled to Estonia and Lithuania a couple years ago, they effectively had this. Most businesses had wifi and freely gave out the passwords. After awhile I had enough passwords stored on my phone that I had internet everywhere I went within the city even though I didn't have a mobile plan.
- csydas 9y agoSeoul in Korea is much like this - when my partner and I took a surprise trip there, we were worried about getting around and purchasing a SIM as neither of us spoke Korean, but there was rarely a place where there wasn't some sort of wifi access from the major telecom providers with both a paid and free version. You couldn't necessarily do things like youtube or Facebook over the public access, but things like maps, email, and messaging were all very doable.
- mizzao 9y agohttps://common.net/ https://common.net/ is a startup delivering this kind of service.
- Chardok 9y agoBut Colorado is unique in that town and cities in the state have been able to vote locally on whether to overturn this ISP-lobbying-for-law Once again Colorado has impressed me on the level of pragmatism they show in their state laws. They have been looking very politically healthy compared to the rest of the US, in my opinion, and I think it is going to pay off for them in the near future.
- germinalphrase 9y agoAgreed. I wouldn't be surprised to see Hickenlooper develop a more significant national profile.
- jbuzbee 9y agoI lost a lot of respect for Hickenlooper after he waffled on a death penalty decision pushing it off for the next governor. I could have accepted a decision in either direction, but he chose to not make a decision at all. When you are elected the top official in the State, you're expected to make hard decisions. He failed. http://www.denverpost.com/2013/05/22/nathan-dunlap-granted-temporary-reprieve-by-governor/ http://www.denverpost.com/2013/05/22/nathan-dunlap-granted-t...
- Zamicol 9y agoAnd the red light bill with a head scratcher veto. https://www.colorado.gov/gov-hickenlooper-vetoes-%E2%80%9Cred-light-camera%E2%80%9D-bill https://www.colorado.gov/gov-hickenlooper-vetoes-%E2%80%9Cre...
- mkopinsky 9y agoHis explanation is at https://www.colorado.gov/governor/sites/default/files/legislative_actions/veto_letter_-_hb_16-1231.pdf https://www.colorado.gov/governor/sites/default/files/legisl...
- sliverstorm 9y agoTo me it looks like a somewhat balanced mix of liberals and conservatives, both with a bit of a libertarian/federalist streak. Not a lot of other states seem to look like that right now.
- irickt 9y agoThis linked article has much more reporting: https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/a37v4z/big-telecom-spent-dollar200000-to-try-to-prevent-a-colorado-town-from-even-talking-about-a-city-run-internet https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/a37v4z/big-teleco...
- bproven 9y agoComcast did the same thing to Longmont CO about 3-4 years ago. Luckily the local residents were not fooled: https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/11/19/longmont-internet-service/19294335/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/11/19/longmo... I am a former resident of FC - I hope they are able to put a little competition to Comcast.
- davesque 9y agoComcast and Centurylink (though they may haven taken different names at one time or another) have been a duopoly in Colorado for decades. Their prices have gone up and up too -- more, it seems, than inflation. Maybe we'll finally see that come to an end.
- snarf21 9y agoYou are lucky to even have a second choice for broadband. In large parts of the country, the list of choices is only Comcast.
- Top19 9y agoThose type of executives will be going to jail soon enough. There is a theory, I think first proposed by Arthur Schlesinger Jr (who won two Pulitzer prizes, had an equally renowned father, and was one of Kennedy’s top advisors) that American history tends to move in 80 year cycles divided into two forty year periods or so. Every 40 years US society shifts from capitalism and individualism to community and strong federal government. Neither period is inherently bad, but it’s just that capitalism and democracy don’t coexist as much as rule independently, taking turns. Schlesinger dated the capitalism period to 1980 starting with Ronald Reagan. That means it should end in 2020 or so. For all the crimes that fall out of the statue of limitations, I can imagine, not necessarily in a good way and probably will be frowned upon by later historians, that McCarthy-style commissions will be set up and these executives blacklisted from business.
- unnawut 9y agoWould you mind recommended any of his books to read about these cycles?
- drewg123 9y agoSometimes just faking Comcast out with the threat of doing a competing service is helpful. The president of the HOA in the neighborhood next to mine was sick of poor service from Comcast, and put a neighborhood broadband proposal on their HOA association agenda. Comcast (the only choice for wired broadband here) got wind of it, and immediately started upgrading their infrastructure and digging new fiber to the curb. Now they have faster and more reliable service than we do.
- danesparza 9y agoIf you could post details of the events leading up to this it might be useful for other neighborhoods...
- SOLAR_FIELDS 9y agoSimilarly in Austin after Google Fiber was announced (even though it will be years before the far northern edges receive service) TWC (now Spectrum) was able to magically increase bandwidth/speeds for everyone at no cost to current plans. It was so simple and immediate that it was almost like they only had to flip a switch to upgrade the speeds.
- danesparza 9y agoWOW. The really revealing quote in this article is this: "But it remains easier and cheaper for companies like Comcast and AT&T, with the help of groups like ALEC, to instead convince clueless lawmakers to pass laws restricting your right to determine for yourself how your money gets spent, and what it gets spent on." I then googled "ALEC" (and looked past the Alec Baldwin twitter scandal of the day) and was amazed to discover a shadowy group that steers local legislation just about everywhere. Holy crap!
- nanodeath 9y ago13th has a bit on ALEC, or here's a clip: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=buO1KubTfQo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=buO1KubTfQo
- trumpownsyou420 9y agoomg, republicans! noooooo!
- s73ver_ 9y agoYeah, they've been around for a while. They rely on people not really knowing anything about them to operate. Kudos for you on finding out.
- cagenut 9y agojohn oliver did a full segment on ALEC: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aIMgfBZrrZ8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aIMgfBZrrZ8
- wavefunction 9y agoThey run trial balloons all over, especially in small venues they can then expand to larger levels. They promoted a law in a Montana town that would have allowed corporations to vote in the municipal elections.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- newshorts 9y agoWait... Aren’t monopolies illegal? I was under the impression they were, but maybe I’m wrong to assume that.
- s73ver_ 9y agoHaving a monopoly lands you generally have a lot of funding, with which to hire lawyers to challenge that. And bribe ALEC.
- davesque 9y agoThey're only illegal if politicians give a crap.
- deathanatos 9y agoI think we're still (politically) in the phase of convincing people that cable companies are both a monopoly, and an abusive one. E.g., here in the Bay Area, I have a choice in my area to go with AT&T[1] for Internet connectivity, but IIRC, they don't meet the FCC's definition of "broadband", so really, for broadband Internet access, my only choice is Comcast. (Now, the FCC was recently trying to re-write the definition of broadband s.t. mobile connectivity could count, but that's such an absurd stretch of the imagination when discussing the market of high-speed Internet access.) While there is also TWC, I've found that where TWC exists, typically they also enjoy a similar status. Chattanooga, TN, interestingly, offers ~50x the speed for the same price as Comcast here. As for having abused their status, http://www.tennessean.com/story/news/local/2016/10/25/comcast-sues-metro-over-google-fiber-backed-pole-otmr-ordinance/92748490/?from=global&sessionKey=&autologin= http://www.tennessean.com/story/news/local/2016/10/25/comcas... https://www.theverge.com/2015/5/1/8530403/chattanooga-comcast-fcc-high-speed-internet-gigabit https://www.theverge.com/2015/5/1/8530403/chattanooga-comcas... [1]: AT&T also has a history of disregarding consumer privacy (e.g., https://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/07/08/att-selling-data_n_3561263.html https://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/07/08/att-selling-data_n...), so I avoid them for that, too.
- innesinnes 9y agohttps://www.wired.com/story/san-francisco-municipal-fiber/ https://www.wired.com/story/san-francisco-municipal-fiber/
- visarga 9y agoThis is the corresponding 'FU Comcast Thread' from reddit. https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/792tq3/comcast_tries_to_derail_fort_collins_community/?utm_content=comments&utm_medium=front&utm_source=reddit&utm_name=technology https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/792tq3/comcast_...
- pascalxus 9y agoIt's understandable that Comcast wants to shut down the competition. They know how much customers hate them. If any competition shows up, Comcast is history.
- patrickg_zill 9y agoSo the info from people I know who live in Longmont, was that Comcast was as sleazy as their reputation in dealing with the city. Comcast executives said in statements to city council that it was physically impossible to deliver higher bandwidth over the existing cable. Edit to add: now over the existing cable they are offering higher speeds. YES, that same cable that pre competition, they stated could not handle higherspeeds. When Longmont decided to proceed with their own network, lots of FUD from Comcast both before it was successfully delivered and after, but everyone who has it, loves it. And it very rarely goes down. Comcast then tried to say that they had exclusive contracts with the landlords... but under CO law such restrictions placed on tenants are illegal. Etc. Etc.
- peterlk 9y agoYes, comcast threw tantrums in city hall on multiple occasions. Longmont's story is rather complicated and interesting. I don't know all the details, but knew a fair number of the key players. Essentially, Longmont allowed an upstart ISP to put cable in the ground. Part of the deal was that if they were going to sell it, Longmont got first right of refusal (or something similar), and when they went under, the city bought the fiber for cheap. They were sitting on dark fiber for a long time, and they leased it out to several companies who failed to make it work. Then, after enough people in the town and city government cared (I'll call out Jim Wall - the town CTO - for being awesome), the vote passed and with some creaking and groaning, the roll-out got started. Residents got 1 Gigabit symmetric for $50 per month (you're reading that correctly). Interestingly, nearly overnight, both Comcast and Charter were offering more than 1 Gb/s for $75ish.
- fludlight 9y ago> Comcast then tried to say that they had exclusive contracts with the landlords... but under CO law such restrictions placed on tenants are illegal. We could use such a law in California.
- youdontneedit 9y agoYou don't need one! Exclusive telecom provider agreements with multiple-dwelling units (MDUs) have been prohibited federally since 2009. Now, it's a fair bet that the current FCC leadership will flip on this - they published a "Notice of Inquiry" to "seek comment" on what they're now calling "multiple tenant environments" earlier this year: https://apps.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/DOC-345161A1.pdf https://apps.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/DOC-345161A1.p... But for now, exclusive provider agreements like this are not actually enforceable.
- jxramos 9y agoWow, I never even knew something like this was an option on the table! Makes me think of open source infrastructure. So what exactly does it take to get independent broadband?