3 ms·
"It's very hard to see a discussion on this topic that does not miss the true point: This "conflict" is the fight between nationalist movements (Spanish and Cat
by hutzlibu 9y ago
"It's very hard to see a discussion on this topic that does not miss the true point: This "conflict" is the fight between nationalist movements (Spanish and Catalan) which re-enforce each other in every turn for the worse of the majority and of the European Union."
And I think it is very hard to discuss something, by starting with telling everybody else that they are wrong.
Now while it is true, that the conflict is also a clash of different nationalist, it is simply oversimplification and plainly wrong to reduce it to that. And also missleading. As the catalan nationalism is of a very different kind, than the spanish one.
From my experience, the spanish nationalism is classical chauvinism - or plain open fascism. Spain is superior. Period. Spain also never had a denazification since Franco. There simply are still many people in spain who still refer positiv to fascism. Also in positions of power.
And the catalans simply want to live their culture, free from spanish interference.
The catalan language was allmost forbidden for quite some time! And many died, were tortured or disappeared who did not bow their head low enough to the fascists. So one should not forget that long episode.
But yes, recently things were a lot different - thats why most catalans would have voted no - if spain would have granted them a referendum.
But since spain did not talked to them, but acted again like a empire to their peasants - it seems to many, that spain once again has dropped their masks and showed how they really are and think - so now they want to leave.
And yes, I think it is very sad for europe indeed, if this kind of empire-thinking and chauvinism gets the support of the EU. And the right of self-determination only gets taken seriously if it is some geopolitical interest, like in Kosovo.
- alexandrerond 9y ago> And many died, were tortured or disappeared who did not bow their head low enough to the fascists. So one should not forget that long episode. Note that this happened all over Spain, it was not just Catalonia suffering this. > Spain also never had a denazification since Franco Spain has had a low-speed consolidation of its democratic system. It is important to realize that, even though slow, it is miraculous that Spain got out of such regime without bloodshed and successful coups (though one was attempted). The slow process is the price Spain paid for that. Believe me when I say Catalonia is not helping to get the fascists away from power. > The catalan language was allmost forbidden for quite some time! Resentment may fuel nationalist feelings, but makes a bad argument in the current setting. There are so many things to be resentful about in totalitarian regimes from 40 years ago...
- hutzlibu 9y ago"Note that this happened all over Spain, it was not just Catalonia suffering this." But they probably suffered much more than others. Definitely more than spanish thinking people. "Resentment may fuel nationalist feelings, but makes a bad argument in the current setting." It is not about resentment, but about the fear that those who suppressed the catalans still would do it, if they can. Openly or behind doors. And it seems that there is some truth to it, with police bashing unarmed people who just want to vote.
- pvaldes 9y ago> they probably suffered much more than others You must be joking... :-(
- hutzlibu 9y agoDo you know the history of spain and the civil war? Even if not, don't you think it makes a difference for an area under spanish fascist rule, if most of the residents are pro spanish or if they are against it??
- tirant 9y agoI know the history of Spain really well, being Catalan and with part of my ancestors assessinated by Franco's regime. Being pro-Spanish did not mean shit for Franco and the fascist regime. The rebelled against a perfectly pro-Spanish republican government. The assassinated millions of socialist, communist, anarchist who were pro Spanish. Big majority of catalans were also pro Spanish and suffered prosecution. But they supported a different Spain than the fascist/catholic nationalist Spain than Franco's side. They supported a plural, multinational Spain, where all national and regional feelings were respected and supported.
- hutzlibu 9y ago"They supported a plural, multinational Spain, where all national and regional feelings were respected and supported." With pro-spanish I did not meant the "multinational Spain" variant. More pro spanish nation. (And I also think that "anarchist who were pro Spanish" ... were a pretty rare type of anarchists. Unless you only meant pro spanish language. But that is pobably nitpicking, which I feel is a bit inappropriate in this topic) So I still would think, that in general a spanish fascist would treat a spanish republican a bit better, than a catalan anarchist - but I don't think I should try to teach you your history. So I just stop and say, that I am very sorry for your family, as well.