3 ms·
> He's somehow implying that marketing FOSS is not a useful contribution. Whether or not it's useful, the FOSS community does have some holy ground that shall
by sliverstorm 16y ago
> He's somehow implying that marketing FOSS is not a useful contribution.
Whether or not it's useful, the FOSS community does have some holy ground that shall not be trod upon. The extent of that holy ground varies, but one of the basic tenants of open source is Credit Where Credit Is Due. Generally speaking, the community is very flexible, but don't be surprised if this is where the gloves come off.
- yungchin 16y agoThanks, that's a good point (I should read Homesteading the Noosphere again :)). I guess I've not been aware of (or sensitive enough to pick up) any clear offences by Canonical in this respect. Maybe that's because I only subscribe to their security notices, not the general news :)
- jberryman 16y agoI'm not a Ubuntu hater, but wrt to "Credit Where Credit Is Due", I was recently at the Ubuntu homepage: http://www.ubuntu.com/ http://www.ubuntu.com/ NO mention of "linux" or "GNU" anywhere on the page. Click on the "How Can It Be Free?" link, and no mention of GNU or the GPL. In fact the reasons they give are "1. It's Open Source" and "2. It's Managed and Funded by Canonical". Open Source is a side-effect of Free as in Freedom, a concept that Canonical is agnostic about. And I'm not sure what point 2 means. I can understand not wanting to turn people off with scary-sounding words, but even Mac like to tout the "rock solid unix foundation" on which OSX is built.
- nkassis 16y agoI think they view GNU and GPL explanations as not very friendly to their perceived audience which is the common computer user. Branding it Ubuntu in their view makes it simpler to understand. I think they want to be like OS X and relegate discussions of BSD and Mach Kernel to some really hard to find page. At least that's how i'm interpreting their pr stuff.
- jberryman 16y agoYeah, I agree. But I think the branding of Ubuntu as this "immaculately-conceived" OS is what annoys a lot of folks who know a bit about linux. I think a simple mention on their front page would be enough.
- troels 16y agoIn all respect, then perhaps the FOSS community should change perspective. Ubuntu has been one of the best PR-moves that Linux ever had. If the goal is to get people to use the software, then they contributed a great deal to the project.
- kelnos 16y agoThe problem with that semi-assertion is that the goal is differs greatly amongst OSS developers, from "I did something useful for me and am sharing it in case it's useful to anyone else," to "I'm going to take over the world by getting OSS into everyone's hands." ... and everywhere in between. Canonical clearly tends toward the latter end of the spectrum, where I imagine a company like Red Hat is somewhere in the middle.