7 ms·
Old Battlefield games re-killed after EA’s legal warning
- rm_-rf_slash 9y agoWe need to re-think intellectual property. If a creator (or worse, buyer) of an IP loses interest in supporting it, then why should they retain a legal monopoly to do so?
- wickedlogic 9y agoWe should start by not calling it intellectual property (IP). Clearly this is not servicemark, trademark, etc. Is copyright actually preventing this?
- rm_-rf_slash 9y agoIANAL but as I understand it video games are IP. What I'm suggesting is that if an IP is abandoned in a meaningful way (such as server support for a multiplayer game) then the IP owner should not be allowed to prevent others from replicating that functionality. A few details still have to be hashed out though: can people charge for the use of their third party servers? Are new players required to purchase the game from the owner? What rights, if any, does the owner have regarding online configuration and interaction for a game they no longer support? If the owner stops distributing the game do they lose the right to demand payment for each copy distributed by a third party, either for pay or for free? I don't know these answers, but it's a better alternative to our outdated IP system. "Use It Or Lose It" should be the IP motto in the Information Age.
- craigsmansion 9y ago> as I understand it video games are IP What I think wickedlogic means is that the term "IP" is often used as a catch-all term for legal frameworks that are very dissimilar, and the various sides of "IP" should be treated very differently. As a catch-all term it might seem useful because it's short, but it's often used to confuse and divide. As an example: for Free Software, -software patents are just a terrible idea -copyright is broken, but usable -trademarks are important Three different branches of "IP," with widely varying consequences and implications. If someone talks to you about "IP," ask them to be specific, even if just to make sure you're talking about the same thing.
- PeachPlum 9y agoExcept it is exactly Trademark related. They weren't ask to turn off the server, they were asked to stop distributing EA assets: Dear [REDACTED], I write on behalf of Electronic Arts Inc. and its development studio DICE or, in other words, "those guys that make Battlefield." We've noticed that Revive Network has several projects and websites devoted to being a Medic by reviving older Battlefield games, including Battlefield Heroes, Battlefield 2, and Battlefield 2142. It's great to see your enthusiasm for these titles. Not to brag, but we too get the nostalgia chills when booting up these classic entries in the Battlefield franchise. We need a favor though: we must ask that you stop throwing down Ammo Crates. In other, more legal-styled terms, please stop distributing copies of our game clients and using our trademarks, logos, and artwork on your sites. Thing is, your websites may easily mislead visitors to believe that you are associated or affiliated with EA we're the only ones that get to wear the Official EA dog tag. Since you're Battlefield community members, we know that you are smart and helpful, and will respect that we must protect our intellectual property rights in the franchise. Please drop us a line to let us know you're on board with this. Should you have any questions regarding all this, please do not hesitate to contact me via e-mail at [REDACTED]@ea.com. Thanks, [REDACTED] IP Counsel Electronic Arts Inc.
- wickedlogic 9y agoMy comment still stands. Likely? they could have fixed their infringing acts. Trademark infringement is not what took down this service (or so motivated these people to take down the service). I have yet to read an "IP" compliance request that was accurate, truthful, or aligned with achieving a correct legal understanding between parties. This is not an accident. The use of that term creates an artificial whole, which is then used to imply greater authority over the sum of the parts. My comment is on the prior comment, which is about the concept... not this specific instance, even though it is still applicable.
- JasonFruit 9y agoThat sounds like a rationalization of "But I want it!" If someone owns useful land, but prefers to leave it fallow, they don't lose ownership of it; why shouldn't they have the right to leave their intellectual property idle? Part of ownership is the right to use your property as you please.
- fnord123 9y agoIt's more like renting out apartments and then tearing down the building while people are still living in it. There are laws against that.
- JasonFruit 9y agoThere's a big difference between people's residences and a video game.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- waqf 9y agoYou begged the question here. The question is whether and to what extent the creator of software should have "ownership".
- rm_-rf_slash 9y agoPrecisely. That's the difference between land and IP. IP is made. Land is bought, maybe worked on, developed, but as Mark Twain said about land, "they're not making it anymore." >Inb4 South China Sea.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lstyls 9y agoPutting aside the peril of comparing intellectual property to physical property, this is not true, even in the United States where property rights are quite strong. For instance, there are squatters rights laws on the books in many states.
- ajmurmann 9y agoWhat bothers me about this is that people bought the game, but they can't play it because EA doesn't want to run servers for it and prohibits everyone else from doing so. I very much preferred the old days when players had to run their own servers. It was less convenient, but made for great community and avoided situations like this.
- slezyr 9y agoWell it's not about server, but about MASTER servers. Those used to discover "players own servers" in the internet.
- masklinn 9y agoIsn't that even worse? That would require even less resources on EA's part, and is even less consequential to the actual game.
- Thaxll 9y agoYeah right ... showing homemade server by official EA servers. It's a recipe for disaster.
- scopecreep 9y agoThis is how it was for many years. Decades even. It was fine. They weren't exactly "homemade" servers either. There was an entire industry of game server rentals and these were datacenter rack servers connected to fat pipes. It wasn't unusual at all to find third-party servers with way better pings (and higher player caps) than the official servers. I don't remember the official bf1942 servers ever having 32v32 player matches but that was fairly common for thirdparty servers for example.
- ajmurmann 9y agoCan I still type in a IP address directly?
- 9y ago
- Thaxll 9y agoWhat most people don't understand is EA can't legally release server code because they probably use libraries that forbid public distribution, physics engine ect ...
- Illniyar 9y agoI fail to see how is that relevant, people are saying either keep the server up or let other people run their own, reversed engineered server.
- syril 9y agoPretty upsetting, my buddies and me would get together on weekends and play Battlefield 2. Hopefully they find a way to get setup again (torrent client downloads)
- brango 9y agoAnyone play Battlefield 2 on the PS2 I think it was? You could look at any allied character on the battlefield and hit a button and you'd take over control of the character. So you could be a soldier on the ground being pinned down by a machine gun nest, look up to an allied helicopter, hit the button, become the pilot, launch missiles at the nest, then look down to a tank, become the driver, then back to the soldier, etc,... So much fun! I think they called it 'hotswap' or something. Any game devs: This was the single most fun mechanic I've played in years. Please please please make an FPS where you can hotswap between characters like that. For some reason apparently this awesome feature didn't even make it into the PC version of the game. I'd love to play a game with that mechanic again.
- gambiting 9y agoDriver: San Francisco had exactly this. But yeah, it sounds like fun in an FPS.
- pdelbarba 9y agoAll of the ARMA games have had this feature if you bother to enable it. It's not usually seen in the popular online "maps" though
- Darkenetor 9y agoOne of my favorite games, MercurySteam's Jericho, is based on that mechanic. We definitely need more games to experiment with that.
- djsumdog 9y agoThis reminds me of the old Blizzard vs open battlenet (bnetd) crap that happened in the early 2000s. I think it really hit a full head when people were using modified bnetd servers so they could play leaked beats of WarCraft 3. It's sad because bnetd lost their case, even though it was a total open source re-implementation and was an amazing work for what it was. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bnetd https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bnetd
- jannes 9y agoIn my opinion the question is how do we treat hybrid software products: A part of it runs locally and another part runs on a server. If you sell/advertise those two pieces of software as a single integrated product but you only give away the client executable, how long after the sale should you be required to keep the server running? It's a bit like a web app: The user downloads some HTML+JS which makes XmlHttpRequests to a server backend. In theory the user could download the HTML+JS only once and keep working with that initial copy, but after a few weeks the server endpoint might change and break that copy. I think the expectation for a web app is to keep working for a day or so and the expectation for a console game is at least 20 years?
- wbl 9y agoIn games traditionally people hosted their own servers.
- tomohawk 9y agoIt's too bad there isn't a yearly tax on the value of 'intellectual property', just like on real property. If a company doesn't pay the tax, someone else could pick it up. It would provide a legal path to handle abandoned things.
- ben_jones 9y agoOn the other hand its common for people to inherit property they can't maintain, forcing them to sell it with much regret. If a poor person patented tremendously valuable intellectual property it might be lost to an unscrupulous buyer.
- pjc50 9y ago> If a poor person patented tremendously valuable intellectual property Challenge for HN: find the most recent three patents which (a) were filed by individuals not an employer (b) those individuals could reasonably be described as poor (c) aren't subject to widespread infringement by a big company. (and (d) is for something actually useful not a perpetual motion machine etc) I think it might be quite a hard thing to find.
- Someone 9y agoa) is (technically) easily satisfied. In the USA, only persons can apply for a patent. See https://www.uspto.gov/patents-getting-started/general-information-concerning-patents#heading-10 https://www.uspto.gov/patents-getting-started/general-inform...: ”According to the law, the inventor, or a person to whom the inventor has assigned or is under an obligation to assign the invention, may apply for a patent, with certain exceptions.” and, more explicitly, http://www.iusmentis.com/patents/crashcourse/applicant/ http://www.iusmentis.com/patents/crashcourse/applicant/: ”When someone makes an invention, and does so as an employee of a company, usually the company owns the right to apply for a patent. The exception once again is the United States, where only natural persons may apply for a patent. In the USA, the employee will typically have a clause in his employment contract stating that he assigns all his patent rights to the company. The filing is then done on behalf of the employee, but the rights immediately go to the company.”
- charlesdm 9y agoAPIs and protocols generally can't be copyrighted in Europe. Not sure where they're based, but what stops them from running this in Europe?
- try_sincerely 9y agoI found Squad and Planetside 2 to be great heirs to the Battlefield 2 and Battlefield 2142 legacy. Amazing how Planetside 2 being a free game manages to outclass pretty much any combined arms FPS and is still looking really good visually for 2012 release.
- DaggerDagger 9y agoOh man I forgot about Planetside 2! Super underrated, it came out in a huge FPS glut in the market. I dig huge combined arms stuff but man I used to die to snipers in that game so much haha.