14 ms·
Twitter’s multi-million dollar US election pitch to RT
- grabcocque 9y agoThe Kremlin is nothing if not reliably vindictive to those that it believes has crossed it. Twitter better hope it has its story straight (and the paper shredders working overtime) because this looks to me like Putin's minions have been ordered to go right for Twitter's jugular. I do hate to say this too, but maybe the Kremlin mouthpiece has a point here: many media organisations use ad spending to try to crowbar themselves into election narratives. The difference in the US is the sheer scale of it compared to most western nations that have strict limits on election spending, both domestic and especially foreign. The US has limits of a sort but they're so huge and so porous this sort of thing was practically inevitable.
- mavdi 9y agoI can see Vladislav Surkov's fingerprints all over this.
- aldous 9y agoI was pondering this too. In a general sense, the ol’ Kremlins digital savvy, often attributed to Mr Surkov, seems very impressive, horribly insidious as it is. Troll army operations: https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2014/08/the-kremlins-troll-army/375932/ https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2014/08/th... Initiatives around cryptocurrencies, https://www.thedailybeast.com/why-is-the-kremlin-suddenly-obsessed-with-cryptocurrencies https://www.thedailybeast.com/why-is-the-kremlin-suddenly-ob... Reappropriating and leveraging web vernacular https://www.thedailybeast.com/the-kremlin-crafted-takeaknee-memes-for-more-than-a-year https://www.thedailybeast.com/the-kremlin-crafted-takeaknee-... How does the West counter it? How do we, humble internet users sucked into the melee, keep our heads and distinguish fact from fiction? It’s a profoundly deflating landscape out there at times but equally utterly fascinating.
- cat199 9y ago> How does the West counter it? How do we, humble internet users sucked into the melee, keep our heads and distinguish fact from fiction? It’s a profoundly deflating landscape out there at times but equally utterly fascinating. How does the west counter a massive media campaign designed to discredit foreign news sources by making broad sweeping accusations and slanted reporting to mobilize large scale media and popular reaction in the online space? Hmm, let me read the several articles from your media campaign designed to discredit foreign news sources by making broad sweeping accusations and slanted reporting to mobilize large scale media and popular reaction in the online space to find out... perhaps by not thinking in us-vs-them terms but viewing all such organizations as somewhat suspect and determining a personal ethical/philosophical position and developing the ability to discern lies from truth based on the net-sum of available facts and historical understanding of reporting bias and self-interest of the various news sources involved, and using this discernment to evaluate such situations against the aforementioned ethical/philosophical position..
- aldous 9y agoI’m not sure I completely follow the implications in your reply tbh, it seems a little reductionist. Are you disputing that RT is a propaganda arm of the Kremlin? As stated above the Kremlin are quite explicit that this is indeed the case. Your point about us vs them… yes, indeed, thinking like this is indeed unhelpful and perilous, and one would be prudent to avoid it. However, the framing of geopolitics as ‘us vs them’ is concept that people like Mr Putin and his ilk fully leverage, propagate and exploit, it’s a core part of his strategy for the retention of power; Putin very much thinks in terms of “us and them”. The ‘West’ is far far far from a perfect entity/system whatever you want to call it, but the autocratic systems in place in countries like Russia are really incomparable with the freedoms enjoyed in the west. I don’t quite follow your last sentence, can you elaborate? How could this approach be practically adopted? What check and balances for example? “perhaps by not thinking in us-vs-them terms but viewing all such organizations as somewhat suspect and determining a personal ethical/philosophical position and developing the ability to discern lies from truth based on the net-sum of available facts and historical understanding of reporting bias and self-interest of the various news sources involved, and using this discernment to evaluate such situations against the aforementioned ethical/philosophical position..”
- kogepathic 9y ago> Twitter better hope it has its story straight (and the paper shredders working overtime) because this looks to me like Putin's minions have been ordered to go right for Twitter's jugular. But for what purpose/to what end? Bringing Twitter down would remove Trump's favourite method of communication. Or is this retribution for Trump not being the Manchurian candidate/lap dog Putin wanted? If that were the case, I would expect Russia to expose whatever they're holding over Trump (peepee tape?) to get him ousted. Trump already won the election, so taking out Twitter would only serve to reduce their ability to influence future elections. I'm not denying this looks fantastically bad for Twitter, but the aim of taking down Twitter isn't clear to me. There has to be a net positive to taking down Twitter, but what is it?
- pavlov 9y agoBut for what purpose/to what end? Putin primarily wants to sow chaos in the American political class. It's not that he necessarily expected Trump to do his bidding -- the embarrassment and distraction created in Washington by a Trump presidency has been reward enough. China and Russia have been telling their citizens for a decade that democracy is fickle and easily manipulated. With Trump, they have a textbook case in favor of their argument. Exposing Twitter fits in that narrative.
- BerislavLopac 9y agoThey don't want to take it out -- they just want to show it that they can. Just like piggate.
- cat199 9y ago> Or is this retribution for Trump not being the Manchurian candidate/lap dog Putin wanted? If that were the case, I would expect Russia to expose whatever they're holding over Trump (peepee tape?) to get him ousted seriously? if anyone is taking that level of master/puppet game seriously they probably need to watch as many non-us media sources as they can.. news flash: not everyone agrees with US global neoliberal policy! you don't necissarily need to have some shadowy organization behind those people deciding for themselves to express themselves, organize, etc.
- thisisit 9y ago"In marketing, there is war for attention. It's the only thing that matters. Attention, not impression" - @Garyvee This should be expanded to - And the only way to grab attention is push the most atrocious stories. People are nothing if not curious about stuff. Specially the ones which align to their world view.
- matt4077 9y agoAhh, bullshit. People also love fatty, salty, and sweet food. Yet there's still market for kale and cod. Similarly, there has been tabloid journalism since the printing press was invented. But there has always been, and still is, plenty of high-quality journalism.
- djmips 9y agoAmericans are fatter than ever right now.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jochung 9y agoSure, but it's been amazing how quickly some outlets have gone downhill, chasing the buzzfeeds and gawkers into clickbait and moral outrage land. The Guardian comes to mind... Not too long ago they had Greenwald releasing the Snowden leaks. Now they're mainly good for pushing an orthodox progressive viewpoint, with a staff of vapid columnists like Valenti and Penny.
- lawlessone 9y agoDoes this not make Twitter AND RT look bad? They've just proven something they and Trump have been denying.
- commenter1 9y agoI don't get it, please explain what do you mean.
- lawlessone 9y agoAll the Trump supporters etc have been screaming for months that there is nothing to see here. Russia has been claiming there was nothing to see. Yet here is Russia's state owned propaganda station a admitting twitter pitched the idea of them targeting the the US elections with their adverts.
- nathankunicki 9y agoThe presentation specifically promotes unbiased political reporting. In addition, many media organisations promote themselves as the go-to place for political reporting. They proposed a partnership with an organisation they hoped would buy ads promoting political reporting. I don't see why this casts Twitter in a negative light.
- wavefunction 9y agoIt shows a Twitter desperate for profitability willing to work with known hostile foreign propagandists to target the US elections. That kind of sounds like traitorous behavior to me, but I'm also a bit judgmental.
- supergreg 9y agoIt sounds like Twitter is unbiased about who to work with to me.
- heartbreak 9y ago
- lancewiggs 9y agoThose discounts feel really light for adland. Did RT get a lousy deal or a good one?
- tryingagainbro 9y agoI think USA got a horrible deal, RT is a nation state, a million is nothing to them. Their GDP (Googled it) is 1.283 trillion USD (2016). https://www.google.com/search?q=russia+gdp https://www.google.com/search?q=russia+gdp Kudos to them for exposing twitter though.
- chrisseaton 9y agoSorry to be a bit pedantic, but ‘nation state’ is not just a technical sounding alternative for ‘major country’. It has a specific definition around national homogeneity, and in most people’s opinions Russia is not a nation-state.
- tryingagainbro 9y agowhatever. Is the GDP of the "Russian Federation" still $1+ Trillion? Do people's opinions on what Russia is, change the fact that they spend billions upon billions to achieve their FP goals? Nope.
- hidenotslide 9y agoThanks, this is a pretty interesting distinction I never realized. Now I want to go find a good modern political science book and learn more.
- chrisseaton 9y agoOther examples of things that aren't nation states (it's a matter of opinion but most agree) include the United Kingdom, and possibly the United States.
- legitster 9y agoIt looks like this is just a standard deck from a sales team, with a standard bulk pricing deal.
- celticninja 9y agoGuess this helped Twitter get into the black for the first time.
- matt4077 9y agoThe story about Twitter's black bottom line is about Q3 2017, so I doubt that it's connected to the 2016 election.
- celticninja 9y agoit all helps though, and I imagine that if they (RT) spent large for the election and got their chosen candidate elected they would keep on spending to support him, see the numerous russian bot accounts following Trump or those that are being used to comment on BLM/flag protestors etc http://dashboard.securingdemocracy.org/ http://dashboard.securingdemocracy.org/
- mcintyre1994 9y agoTwitter have said they're going to donate all the RT ad money to external research on use of Twitter for things like this. They said it's $1.9m. Also the profit report seems to be based on a claim for next quarter, and presumably they've either costed that donation in Q3 or factored it into their Q4 prediction.
- celticninja 9y agoRT and Sputnik are not the only way that Russian money is getting into Twitter, either way my point stands that they received income from this source, courted money from this source and have now become profitable in part as a result of the money they have received from russian organisations.
- nathankunicki 9y agoI'm not sure I see what RT is attempting to say about Twitter here. That they offered them promoted content, ad-buy discounts, custom emojis, etc, in exchange for an ad-buy of a certain amount. This doesn't seem like anything other than a partnership of some kind. It doesn't say anything that RT should favour one candidate over another, in fact the presentation specifically promotes unbiased content and news.
- txmjs 9y agoThe presentation may promote unbiased content, but it would be naïve to suggest that Twitter had no idea who RT would support.
- emodendroket 9y agoEven if that's true, so what? It was pretty clear who Fox News or MSNBC would support but I doubt anyone would be up in arms if Twitter took advertising money from them.
- saas_co_de 9y agothat they are lying hypocrites seems to be the general drift :) complaining that RT was influencing the election after attempting to sell them a platform to influence the election does seem to fit the bill.
- matt4077 9y agoBut that's the point: There's nothing in this presentation suggesting they were even implying that it's a way to change the outcome of the election. In fact, I'd be quite surprised if it were: If you're doing marketing at Twitter in summer 2016, you'd be a genius if you though of RT's motives as anything else than getting clicks for their content.
- blfr 9y agoThere is nothing anywhere suggesting that RT did or could change the outcome of the elections because it has always been far beyond their reach. Clinton's campaign outspent Trump's so badly that a few million this or that way did not matter. It may have been illegal or unethical for US outlets to take the money but it did not make a lick of difference in the outcome.
- ShabbosGoy 9y agoBarring the political implications, this is an interesting window into how much one can charge for advertising. That's some serious market power.
- pornel 9y agoI was surprised when Jack said they'd be returning ad money from RT/Sputnik, because that's not really the election influence problem they have. Political discussions on Twitter are flooded by obvious bot/content farm accounts like "BaldEagleFreedom983428" shitposting memes how Hillary bought CNN to take away your gunflags. Ban this crap.
- emodendroket 9y agoWe really don't need more interference from Twitter, Facebook, et al to moderate political discussions. Time and time again they blunder it.
- ShabbosGoy 9y agoI'm of the view that we need more powerful users, not moderation. Would be hard to enforce I suppose, given voting rings and whatnot, but I'd like to see a community like that one day.
- emodendroket 9y agoI'm not sure what you are imagining but isn't a hive mind effect a challenge?
- imustbeevil 9y agoAt least hive mind is real people being stupid. Bots exactly misrepresent the will of the public.
- r721 9y agoI think algorithmic detection of agenda pushing is where the gold lies. I mean let's add to profiles "detected agendas: Russian state policy/US state policy/Vote for Democrats/Vote for Republicans/Buy bitcoin/whatever". There are probably some (a lot of?) caveats, but still.
- 9y ago
- itronitron 9y agoTL/DR from one of the slides >> U.S. ELECTIONS PROPOSAL Limited offer for @RT_com. * Innovation: exclusive closed betas pending availability with Periscope, TweetDeck, and Moments. * Brand awareness and engagement: customized emoji, video, bespoke customized solutions (e.g. AutoResponse, ScratchReel, Conversational Video Ad). * Content strategy: strategic support with content management and best practices, vision and concept, tailor-made execution. * Dedicated team: Twitter experts to focus on LIVE (editorial and publishing), curate content and provide strategic and tactical support during the U.S. Elections. * Efficiency and measurement: customized research solutions (Nielsen // Milward Brown).
- dowrow 9y agoRT is just Putin's propaganda machine and will act accordingly.
- r721 9y agoTwitter's response (kind of): >Asked to respond, a Twitter spokesperson said via email that the company would not comment “on our private conversations with any advertiser, even a former advertiser.” A source familiar with the company’s dealings with RT said: “These kinds of conversations are industry standard pitching for any potential advertiser. It’s the job of any ad sales team to aggressively recruit and retain clients, and sometimes they use strong language in order to do so.” The spokesperson also noted that only “a very small slice” of Twitter’s communications with RT was being shown, adding that the Russian network’s “motivations may not be full transparency of our advertising relationship.” https://www.yahoo.com/news/twitter-cracks-ads-russian-news-sites-rt-sputnik-193434032.html https://www.yahoo.com/news/twitter-cracks-ads-russian-news-s...
- icu 9y agoRT == Roasting Twitter Jokes aside, it seems to me that Twitter has gone from bastion of free speech to global censor. This RT article is just another nail in the coffin of Twitter's credibility. I think that if Twitter's leaders don't articulate a corporate morality and initiate a culture change at some point Twitter's investors are going to realise that they are betting against freedom. This will obviously impact share price and quite frankly a reason why I don't own any shares.
- thriftwy 9y agoI wonder why all the slides from this keynote show to be consisting of a single (or is it the first) page? It's in window title, (1 страница) File name is same, there's one page to be displayed, but content is different. Is it some feature of keynote where you have more than one screen's worth in one page, or is it shopped?
- heartbreak 9y agoI’d take anything from RT with a grain of salt, considering the context. I’m not saying Twitter is in the clear, but it’s in RT’s best interest to make themselves look better.
- learningram 9y agoI notice some bot/troll activity in the discussions. Mostly new accounts
- dmix 9y ago[citation needed] I see this claim constantly on Reddit. I'd love to see examples of these 'bots' and paid trolls that everyone is so privy to...
- cat199 9y agoit's pretty simple - if you agree with my position (which agrees with what I see on the TV), then you are a legitimate user- if you do not, then you must be a bot, and should be discredited
- wu-ikkyu 9y ago> I'd love to see examples of these 'bots' and paid trolls that everyone is so privy to... Here is a study with some examples: https://www.reddit.com/r/netsec/comments/38wl43/we_used_sock_puppets_in_rnetsec_last_year_and_are/ https://www.reddit.com/r/netsec/comments/38wl43/we_used_sock...
- djhworld 9y agoRT know how to troll. Anyone who's visited, or is a resident of London recently might have noticed these ads on the tube or in the stations http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/rt-adverts-london-mouthpiece-tom-watson_uk_59e8615de4b0d0e4fe6d4ba6 http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/rt-adverts-london-mout...
- uhhhhhhh 9y agoPropaganda has got a lot more interesting with the growth of the private sector.
- rsynnott 9y agoRT isn't really private; it's a non-profit funded by the Russian state: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RT_(TV_network)#Foundation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RT_(TV_network)#Foundation
- Consultant32452 9y agoAm I mistaken in understanding that BBC is similarly tied to the UK government?
- rsynnott 9y agoThe BBC is funded by a government-mandated tax, but has editorial independence. RT is explicitly a propaganda organ; its editor in chief has said as much. It's also aimed at foreign markets. It's more similar to VOA than the BBC.
- makomk 9y agoIndeed, the BBC are of course totally editorially independent of the people who decide whether they continue to exist and at what scale. Also, I have a bridge in Westminster to sell you. (It's fairly well known here that they tend to be a mouthpiece of the Establishment and whichever party's currently in power.)
- smpetrey 9y agoThis Twitter pitch deck looks suspiciously “off-brand Twitter.” Why not release the PDF of the deck?
- gressquel 9y agocan HN ban RT.com please? I just flagged this story
- giarc 9y agoWhy? This is an interesting part of the twitter/US election story. This is the source of this part of the story, linking to another site would be against the HN "rule" of linking the original source.
- FilterSweep 9y agoAgree - but there's middle ground here. I would prefer a "do not link" or archived post for certain domains to prevent clicks on their page.
- f055 9y agoI know RT is not very trustworthy, but let me get this straight - Twitter was inviting RT to spend advertising budget during the US elections, like any other ad sales team would do (Facebook, Google etc.). Twitter got the budget, and RT started making ads on Twitter. Probably controversial, since you want to maximise CTRs etc. Then Trump won. Then everyone started wondering. Then they pinpointed Russian media for making social media ads during the elections. And now Twitter banned RT ads to get the "problem" off their shoulders. Isn't this hysteria? Aren't we putting too much trust that social media ads can really sway the election that much? Because it seems, as other commenters here pointed out, ads weren't as big of a problem as bots and fake accounts spreading propaganda tweets. Even more, how much respondents say that their voting decision was made because of social media ads or social media posts?
- matt_wulfeck 9y ago> And now Twitter banned RT ads to get the "problem" off their shoulders. Isn't this hysteria? I can’t help but feel everyone in Silicon Valley is desperate to believe every narrative about the election except the version where Trump wins because he was the only one promising prosperity to people not located in major cities.
- Consultant32452 9y agoYour comment ties directly to the Democrat election strategy. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ClytGvP_Qe4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ClytGvP_Qe4 "For every blue collar democrat we will lose in Western PA, we will pick up two moderate Republicans in the suburbs of Philadelphia." ~Chuck Schumer
- hockeybias 9y agoand there was obviously room for those Western PAers in Trump's "deplorables basket".
- Akujin 9y agoPhiladelphia is quickly gentrifying and this has caused massive lines in voting districts in the recently gentrified neighborhoods. Where voting lines used to be 15 minutes long they are now 2+ hours. We've been trying to get them to split the voting district into two here in Northern Liberties for a while but apparently it's falling on deaf ears. These are by the way "well-to-do" young professionals so it's in the interest of both Republicans and Democrats to fix this. Meanwhile 10 minutes away at Temple University you have 2 hour lines at polling close. If the dems want to win PA they need to get their voting district shit together in the city. It would not have made much off a difference. The spread in the entire state was about 90k but when I saw the lines at the universities it made me wonder about the entire state. I used to live in the suburbs of Philadelphia in a new "rich" neighborhood and the lines there are usually 15-30 minutes. Granted the population there doesn't fluctuate much.
- averagewall 9y agoWhy does it matter if RT or Russia advertised for the US election? Doesn't the US notoriously have no restrictions on who and how much advertising can be done for elections? What's the difference between an American doing it vs a Russian?
- BeetleB 9y ago>Doesn't the US notoriously have no restrictions on who and how much advertising can be done for elections? I believe they have restrictions involving foreign ads for traditional media (newspapers, TV, etc). Just not for the Internet. Otherwise, to be frank, I totally agree with you. Instead of owning up to the fact that most of the populace is really, really, easy to con, we seek blame elsewhere. Banning foreign entities from advertising in elections will not prevent a similar outcome in a future election.
- ianamartin 9y agoI think the real takeaway here is that advertising on twitter doesn’t work for shit.
- marioflach 9y agoI've been using Twitter exclusively for IT and tech over the last two years. Never been following anything political there. Today, for the first time, a political ad from @diraalwatan (official account for Saudi ministry of defence) promoting war in Yemen sneaked into my feed: https://twitter.com/diraalwatan/status/924548374711463936 https://twitter.com/diraalwatan/status/924548374711463936 I do and did tolerate the way Twitter takes actions in political ways lately, blocking accounts they consider to be fake news, state propaganda, etc. although I find it somehow controversive and very subjective. But having ads promoting war in Yemen just shocked me badly! How it this ad even entering my feed?