30 ms·
Reddit Bans Nazi Groups and Others in Crackdown on Violent Content
- hberg 9y agoThere goes /r/The_Donald/
- oh_sigh 9y agoNo, they're still there, and no, everyone who disagrees with you isn't a Nazi. > we will take action against any content that encourages, glorifies, incites, or calls for violence or physical harm against an individual or a group of people This also means that people who encourage you to "punch a Nazi" or that there's nothing wrong with punching a Nazi/racist should also be banned.
- pknopf 9y agoThat place promotes violence and hate on a daily basis.
- tripplethrendo 9y agoIf by hate you mean people with dissenting opinions.
- _euac 9y agoThis has some examples: https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/53d5xb/what-is-rthedonald-donald-trump-subreddit https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/53d5xb/what-is-rt... Every time I've been to that subreddit, it only takes perusing the comments for 5 minutes to find way worse stuff. From people being openly racist, to people calling for Hillary Clinton to be raped, etc. Bunch of great people, really :\
- oh_sigh 9y agoI browse T_D frequently and I have not once seen someone calling for HRC to be raped. I'm not saying it never happened but I'm curious 1) how upvoted the commment was and 2) how you've glanced at the site for 5 minutes and saw something that I missed after having browsed the site since 2015
- _euac 9y agoThe post was on the front page of r/t_d, so I'm assuming it was fairly upvoted, and had plenty of comments from people supporting the spirit of the message. I remember linking it somewhere else on Reddit, to show just how vile the subreddit was (it was during one of the many discussions like this that try to portray r/t_d as a "high energy subreddit for fans only!")
- pknopf 9y agoNope. Not at all. /r/conservative is perfectly fine, as is /r/politics. /r/The_Donald is effectively 4chan.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- arkona 9y agoCare to give some evidence for your claims?
- pknopf 9y agoGo to the sub and click the first post you see. Evidence provided. edit: Here is the first non-stickied post I found. https://g.redditmedia.com/lWzOghJ9C76p2rMmU3CDWhHTtojbXJ9vlulE__NUm6s.gif?fm=mp4&mp4-fragmented=false&s=e27a80f2e8636072fb9889757af2e8d6 https://g.redditmedia.com/lWzOghJ9C76p2rMmU3CDWhHTtojbXJ9vlu... > Here is Hillary Clinton shitting herself on 9/11 > Did PETA publicly complain about the handling of that cattle? > THE SIDE OF BEEF MARRIED A RAPIST!!! > Hope she had her shitting pants on
- oh_sigh 9y agoFirst post seen at the top of the front T_D page is this: http://dailycaller.com/2017/10/26/the-last-time-hillary-had-a-birthday-she-thought-she-would-be-president-slideshow/ http://dailycaller.com/2017/10/26/the-last-time-hillary-had-... Which is making fun of a HRC tweet from last october which said "Happy Birthday to this future president". Doesn't seem very hateful to me. edit: Basd on your edit, I'm curious what you find hateful about this? HRC passed out on 9/11/16 and was dragged into a waiting van. There is a longstanding meme (in meme-years) about HRC being thrown into the van "like a side of beef", which explains some comments. Yes, the comments are crass, but is being crass the same thing as "promoting violence and hate"?
- pknopf 9y agoThe mod stickies are calmer. Here is the first non-stickied. https://g.redditmedia.com/lWzOghJ9C76p2rMmU3CDWhHTtojbXJ9vlulE__NUm6s.gif?fm=mp4&mp4-fragmented=false&s=e27a80f2e8636072fb9889757af2e8d6 https://g.redditmedia.com/lWzOghJ9C76p2rMmU3CDWhHTtojbXJ9vlu...
- pknopf 9y agoThere was a T_D user who faked a knife attack. He said it was a black person who did it because "he was white". He immediately posted his bloody hand on T_D and said "apparently I look like a NAZI". It was later found out that he made it up. He cut himself. He did it intentionally to stir up hate for black people. The entire sub is effectively 4chan. Crass jokes, fake news, subliminal degenerate brainwashing. It is a breeding ground for people to hate blacks and brown people.
- emmelaich 9y agoDo you have an example? Last time this was suggested on HN I held my nose and had a look. Didn't find any. In fact I found some healthy self-policing in among the muck.
- _euac 9y agor/the_donald is not just about "disagreeing" it's literally the worst kind of ecochamber of conspiracy theories, veiled (and sometimes not-so-veiled) racism and constant calls to action against "the left". They are such an ecochamber that 90% of the time they speak on memes that nobody else understands (or cares to understand.)
- oh_sigh 9y agoCommunities developing their own language and shared understanding is nothing new. Yes, sometimes racist things are said, but are frequently downvoted or pushed back on. Unless, of course, if you considering being, say, anti-Islam as "racist". The most common thing I see is that T_D users accept all races and immigrants, but only if they conform to western ideals(say, by not killing gay people or stoning women) and american culture.
- _euac 9y agoWould you say being "anti-Jewish" is racist or bigoted?
- oh_sigh 9y agoI think either word could work
- _euac 9y agoBut somehow you don't consider being "anti-Islam" (read: anti-Muslim, because people with that set of prejudices is not going to be threading too thin) racist?
- hnbroseph 9y ago"jewish" has, at least historically, had both an ethnic and religious component; which is why anti-jewish could potentially be described as racist, depending on the time and circumstance. this is not really the case for islam or christianity; use of "racism" there is a typical "postmodernist race theorist" fallacy used to shut down discussion and avoid addressing arguments.
- Moral_ 9y agoThe Donald is probably part of the Russian probe. Reddit received an NSL earlier this year, I assume it was in regards to that subreddit. The NSL/Warrant probably had them keep it up and keep their mouths shut about it. That's probably why it's still around while still breaking tons of rules.
- tripplethrendo 9y agoAntifa subreddits will be removed?
- tripplethrendo 9y agoSo they banned Far_Right but https://www.reddit.com/r/farleft/ https://www.reddit.com/r/farleft/ is ok? What a cool place Reddit is! /s
- _euac 9y agoMaybe, just maybe, it's because the "far left" subreddit doesn't have content calling for ethnic cleansing? Just saying.
- jquery 9y agoNo, they want to cleanse the bourgeoisie, they're very multi-ethnic in their genocides. And not all of the far left is colorblind, we generally consider people who want to ethnically cleanse white people as far left.
- uoaei 9y agoThey specifically advocate for inclusion of races, and a destruction of a class system. Nowhere in this does "color" or "ethnicity" make its way into this.
- KGIII 9y agoIt's really, really not easy to stand up for the rights of Nazis. If you're a Nazi, you can use voat.co as they are very free speech oriented. You don't have to be a Nazi to participate, but it's a good idea to have a thick skin if you do go there. I go there and talk to the White Nationalists. They are pretty much Nazis. They know I'm not white and that I don't agree with them. They don't scare me. They are scared and powerless, looking for meaning in their empty lives, easily swayed, and not entirely unaware of some of the ironies. I've actually invited a few of them to my home, but no takers so far. Point is, I'm not sure banning does any good. Reddit can legally do so. I still think there's a better way to deal with the mentally ill and disenfranchised.
- mozumder 9y agoTechnically, you're supposed to actually kill Nazis, since the US government (and many others) literally declared war against them. Anything short of that is just a gratuity towards them. Honestly, Americans aren't horrified enough by the mere existence of these people, treating them as an academic concept. If you actually know Nazis, you already know they're an extremely violent group. It took only a few days of me being around Nazis before they literally tried to blow me up. They're not academic professors. They're violent and organized militants. Treat them as you would Al Queda or ISIS.
- DasIch 9y agoIndeed as a German the idea that some people think appeasement is the right strategy to combat nazis is astonishing. You don't talk to nazis, you destroy them.
- Wellshit 9y agoBan this one as well, boys.
- RightMillennial 9y ago> Technically, you're supposed to actually kill Nazis I'm shocked to actually see this sentiment on HN. You're technically supposed to kill Nazis? That war ended 70 years ago. While I have no sympathy for Nazis, advocating murdering them makes you no better than them. This is disgraceful.
- mschuster91 9y agoHmm. This is going to be interesting. I mean, nearly everyone should be fine with banning Nazis. After all, they're vile and in my opinion don't deserve any place on the world except the inside of a jail cell... The problem is: where will the line be drawn? What about Black Lives Matter? The more, uh, militant parts of the Antifa movement? Militant animal rights groups (which actually are treated as domestic terrorist groups in some countries!)? All advocate, tolerate or embrace violence in some degree, and as there has been the precedent case of Nazis getting banned, it's going to be difficult. Of course one can say "we simply don't like Nazis, so we're stricter on them", and I'm fine with that, but I'm not sure if a new (or, for what it's worth, also current government) can't more or less force providers like Reddit (but also Cloudflare and the others who booted Daily Stormer off the net) to revive the "good old Red Scare"... edit: to clarify, for BLM I don't mean that BLM promotes violence - but there are certainly supporters who believe violence or, in one case, murdering cops, being legitimate (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_shooting_of_Dallas_police_officers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_shooting_of_Dallas_police...). I don't like it myself that the right wing was able to frame BLM as "taking part in the murder", but that image is not going to be corrected soon.
- intopieces 9y agoWhen those groups draw enough ire to affect ad revenue, they will be banned. There are no philosophical debates in the boardrooms of corporations, so let's stop pretending like these moves represent some kind of moral stance.
- hsod 9y agoCan you go into some more detail on how BLM "advocates, tolerates, or embraces" violence?
- mschuster91 9y agoI'm talking about stuff like this here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_shooting_of_Dallas_police_officers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_shooting_of_Dallas_police... While I do not see this as being "symptomatic" or representative for BLM, by far not everyone does so, and therein lies the danger in my opinion. People from the right wing, but also so-called "centrists", both already are using this as an excuse to denounce BLM in general...
- stronglikedan 9y agoI'm sure these bans will be totally fair and unbiased.
- KozmoNau7 9y agoReddit can ban whoever they way from their site, and people will simply either have to accept it or move to another site.
- stronglikedan 9y agoWell of course they can.
- blfr 9y agoWhy has free speech fallen out of favour with SV? Ironically, it happened rather silently. It's not just an Eternal September-like phenomenon. The very same people who used to support it not only don't any more but pretend they never did in the first place. Speaking of the founding fathers, I ask him what he thinks they would have thought of Reddit. "A bastion of free speech on the World Wide Web? I bet they would like it," he replies. It's the digital form of political pamplets. https://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2012/02/02/reddit-co-founder-alexis-ohanians-rosy-outlook-on-the-future-of-politics/3/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2012/02/02/reddit-c...
- hfourm 9y agoSame reason I would ban someone from my personal forum for spamming racial slurs, violent threats, and all around stupid commentary.
- KozmoNau7 9y agoExactly, because they're being a net negative influence on the quality of discussion on your forum, as decided by you, the proprietor of said forum. I'm still not sure why people find this so difficult to understand.
- lobf 9y agoThere's no shade of gray here? Either you host nazi propaganda, or you're "anti-free speech?"
- blfr 9y agoReddit, Twitter and others have banned a much wider selection of posters and communities than nazis. Of course they lead with NAZIS! but then it's anything from r/coontown to voting in the wrong thread. To answer your question, you're not running a bastion of free speech if you ban people for their political opinions.
- lobf 9y ago
- alexanderstears 9y agoIt's going to be interesting to see how the rights of free association evolve as platforms kick more and more people off of them. On one hand, most people agree that platform owners get to make the rules for their platforms. On the other hand, some bans might amount to discrimination based on protected classes. The most interesting thing imo is that political activities and affiliations are protected classes in California, theoretically political bans are violations just like bans on religion / race. We'll see how it pans out.
- keepper 9y agoAmazing ( well, more like sad ) that the first comments I see are "well, we can agree that nazis are bad, but this is a slippery slope, what about BLM, and antifa" Nazism - The belief ( on pseudoscience i may add )that other races ( a term that has no scientific basis ) are only worthy of extermination ( death, MDK ) BLM - The belief ( on experiences of some in society ), that Black people are not treated the same in their interactions with the government. Main vehicle, in your face protests. Antifa - an aggressive anti-hate group ( whose tactics, in the view of some, seem to make them a violent group ). The anti-nazis if you will. Really? Do these things seem REMOTELY equal? cue in the nitpicking about my definitions... PS: to be perfectly clear/blunt, since it seems as I suspected people started nitpicking... One group calls for the extermination of HUMAN BEINGS.. the other calls for the extermination of IDEOLOGY... now see the difference? free speech DOES NOT and HAS NEVER given you the right to call for the extermination of others... that is as clear cut case of "not protected by free speech" as there is. and yes.. if you take on the name of "nazi" or "national socialism", well, you don't get to redefine those terms in a "wink wink" manner.
- arkona 9y agoI don’t want to nitpick your definitions, but nazism usually refers to the ideology of the NSDAP, a party that was disbanded at the end of WW2. You probably meant to say “violent racism”, in which case the comparison to antifa, and to a lesser extent blm, seems justified (they are linked by violence).
- celticninja 9y agoNazism calls for the death and extermination of other people, antifa and BLM don't.
- arkona2 9y agoSure nazism is 1000x worse than blm or antifa, the only problem is that nazism doesn’t exist anymore. The NSDAP was disbanded in 1945. Antifa and blm are still active today > see a “nazi”, punch a “nazi” > pigs in a blanked, fry them like bacon
- glenstein 9y agoWhat tends to happen when toxic subreddits get banned is people who liked them and supported them start whatabouting about edge cases and claim the ban wasn't done "consistently," eagerly pointing out instances of mistaken bans. It reminds me of the fable, though I forget exactly what it was (edit: Loki's Wager), where someone sought to avoid being beheaded not by claiming innocence but by endlessly disputing where their neck ended and head began.
- LARGEGALAXY 9y agoStop with this "Nazi" nonsense. This is not 1930's Germany, there are no Nazi's. People can dress as them sure, but if I dress as an elephant from the costume store this does not make me an elephant. Also, where are the articles of the Islamic-group crackdowns? I do not see any, even though the Islamic invasion is happening ever so slowly and the Islamists are extremely violent. That's the real threat, not this pretend "Nazi" rubbish.
- kevinmchugh 9y agoTwitter has banned over 350,000 ISIS accounts in the last year or two, and that's happened without Hacker News noticing, as far as I can tell. There's not any stories about it that come up in HN search with as many points as this has now. How is this situation different?
- rodgerd 9y agoA loud group of HN users are, apparently, very very sympathetic to the wellbeing of violent racists.
- jquery 9y agoI haven't seen any sympathy for Antifa on HN.
- kstrauser 9y agoIn your opinion, are Antifa racists?
- jquery 9y agoIt depends on whether you believe racism is power + prejudice or just prejudice. Since I subscribe to the latter, yes.
- kstrauser 9y agoWho is Antifa prejudiced against? I'm white but I've never felt like they were any danger to me whatsoever.
- heeen2 9y agoOne could argue that if you have nice things (e.g. nice car, upscale shop windows) certain groups that are assumed under the antifa umbrella would not hesitate to set fire to your car as a protest against capitalism and the power gradients it strengthens. Examplary incidents are G20 protests in Germany.
- rljy 9y agoAnd yet this is still online: https://www.reddit.com/r/sjwhate/comments/73h7mx/i_fuck_sjws_for_fun/ https://www.reddit.com/r/sjwhate/comments/73h7mx/i_fuck_sjws...
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoWhile shitty and mean, they aren't advocating for violence in that post. Do you think mean posts should be outlawed?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ifhd 9y ago47 points, 122 comments. flagged. Yup, sounds like HN.
- KGIII 9y agoI know it is flagged but I want to thank the mods for not truly killing it. It was mostly civil. The mods were pretty decent, and deserve our thanks. For the most part, the comments were pretty good too. I read them all. ;-)
- kakarot 9y agoClearly the solution is to corralle all fascists onto one big fenced-in echo chamber. What could go wrong?
- KozmoNau7 9y agoPossibly, hopefully a very impressive implosion.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- coffee9 9y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/modnews/comments/78p7bz/update_on_sitewide_rules_regarding_violent_content/dovlpdb/ https://www.reddit.com/r/modnews/comments/78p7bz/update_on_s... Though Nazis have taken over the conversation, they did ban a bunch of fetish subreddits too.