6 ms·
So what's your point? Do you want to eliminate rent? Should people who either can't afford to purchase a house, or who simply don't want to, be forced into hom
by mindcrime 9y ago
So what's your point? Do you want to eliminate rent? Should people who either can't afford to purchase a house, or who simply don't want to, be forced into homelessness?
Personally I've paid over $115,000 in rent over the past 12 years, but I don't begrudge my landlord their money. I attained utility in exchange for the rent I paid, and have no problem with the arrangement. Not, of course, to say that I'm happy when rent goes up. But it's a conscious choice I make to live this way, not some sort of exploitation.
He renders no service to the community, he contributes nothing to the general welfare
Housing isn't a service that contributes to the general welfare? I call bollocks.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoNo, no one is advocating for eliminating rent. I (EDIT: removed "We") am advocating for tilting the scales back towards labor though. * No depreciation allowance on rental property that is almost always going to appreciate [1] * No 1031 exchanges, deferring capital gains forever [2] * No mortgage interest deduction, which encourages the wealthy to bid up real estate since their leverage is tax advantaged. [3] * Co-Ops acquiring property for renting to citizens when possible [4] [1] https://www.biggerpockets.com/blogs/2728/41560-understanding-rental-property-depreciation-and-recapture-tax https://www.biggerpockets.com/blogs/2728/41560-understanding... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internal_Revenue_Code_section_1031#Summary https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internal_Revenue_Code_section_... [3] https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2017/05/shame-mortgage-interest-deduction/526635/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2017/05/shame-m... [4] http://www.yesmagazine.org/people-power/in-berlin-a-model-for-creative-and-affordable-housing-20170412 http://www.yesmagazine.org/people-power/in-berlin-a-model-fo... EDIT: @ mcbruiser3: When I say "we" (which I removed above), people who share my progressive political view that people/humans/"labor" should be treated with priority over capital and rentseeking.
- mindcrime 9y agoFair enough! Coops acquiring property for renting to citizens when possible Yes, this sounds like a good idea. As a Libertarian, I like this model because it is compatible with private property rights, and doesn't demand some sort of government intervention.
- newlyretired 9y agoYou don't think property coops are at a high risk of acting like current HOAs?
- mindcrime 9y agoPerhaps, but as long as participation is voluntary, I can live with that. That said, if I ever buy a house, it will very pointedly be in an area with no HOA. :-)
- gowld 9y agoHow is an HOA worse for the resident than a landlord?
- b4lancesh33t 9y agoThey already do, at least in NYC. That's just part of the deal you sign when you join. If you don't like it, there are a lot of other options, each with their own tradeoffs.
- bhauer 9y agoAs a landowner, I would happily discard the mortgage interest deduction. And 1031s and depreciation allowances. Oh and toss California's Proposition 13 as well. In exchange, I would request a dramatically simplified tax code that avoids mechanisms such as these across the board. And reduced zoning regulations to allow more housing supply.
- mcbruiser3 9y agoonly fair if you reduce the tax burden dramatically as well. this would not just impact "evil landlords" but most of middle class as well. and who is "we" exactly?
- gowld 9y agoImprovements don't appreciate. Land appreciates.
- eli_gottlieb 9y ago>Do you want to eliminate rent? Yes. Land should be held by housing cooperatives or by private owner-occupiers. Rentiers can go find a line of business that contributes to society.
- WallWextra 9y agoWhen you live in a coop, you usually pay rent.
- gowld 9y agoWhere? Not in NY or SF, where co-ops are popular.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mcbruiser3 9y agoplease feel free to start up a coop then. nothing is stopping you and your friends from doing that. have at it, and good luck. edit: apparently some people don't like this comment because it means you have to help yourself instead of the gov't giving you other people's money. get a life.
- dang 9y agoWe've banned this account for using HN primarily for political and ideological battle and ignoring our request not to do this. Would you please not create accounts to break HN's rules with? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- aoeusnth1 9y agoSo what should exactly should those of us without the capital to buy or build our own houses do? Hit the road?
- natrius 9y agoDon't eliminate all rent, just tax away the rents derived from the land itself. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism
- jpao79 9y agoIn California at least, the property tax bill is already split into two components: 1.) Tax on land value 2.) Tax on improvements (building, landscaping) so Georgism already exists somewhat. An land value tax increase would need to be phased over decades to account for the building lifetimes which can span 50 or more years. Developers use multi-decode economic models for their developments based on assumptions including worst case property tax scenarios. But if that can change at moment's notice. It also would need to account for zoning restrictions. If some parcels get re-developed as ultra high density housing but NIMBY's block similar developments in neighboring parcels, that could lead to lawsuits against the county.
- njarboe 9y agoMy property tax bill in California does have the breakdown of the land value and improvements, but they are just added together and a single rate is applied to the total (~%1.3 in my case). So one could implement Georgism pretty easily, by just taxing the land value, but that is not how it works at the moment.
- gowld 9y agoIt's not the state's job to protect the landlords' business models.
- moultano 9y agoLand Value Tax. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax This is distinct from a property tax in that it only measures the value of the soil it sits on, so doesn't punish the landlord for improvements. The value of the land itself is almost entirely outside of the landlord's control, it's determined by the community around it. As a result, this is one of the least distortive taxes.
- to3m 9y agoBlog rebutting many common arguments against a land value tax: http://kaalvtn.blogspot.co.uk/p/index.html http://kaalvtn.blogspot.co.uk/p/index.html
- chimeracoder 9y ago> This is distinct from a property tax in that it only measures the value of the soil it sits on, so doesn't punish the landlord for improvements. The value of the land itself is almost entirely outside of the landlord's control, it's determined by the community around it. As a result, this is one of the least distortive taxes. When land value is taxed at a higher rate than property value, it creates a perverse incentive for landlords - especially those who don't live in the area in which they own property - to encourage blighting and sabotage the value of the land, while instead reinvesting this money into improvements on the property itself. That concentrates wealth even further in the hands of people who can afford to own these insular properties in otherwise "undesirable" areas. Actively blighting a neighborhood to depress values and make it easier to purchase land for new properties (either on the market or via eminent domain) is already a problem, and one that significantly skews power towards the extremely wealthy and massively-capitalized institutions. Taxing the value of the land separately from the property that sits on it (and at a higher rate) would exacerbate this unbelievably.
- gowld 9y agoHow have all the economists missed this obvious point? Murder also hurts property values. Fortunately, we have the ability to create laws to punish destructive behavior. Why would a landlord destroy the value of their own property, harming their own ability to draw rent?
- logfromblammo 9y agoAllow people to deduct rents paid from their income taxes if they report the location of the property and the identity of the party receiving the payments (in addition to the standard deduction). Tax income from rents at a higher rate than wage and salary incomes. The landlords will obviously just raise rents to pay the tax, but this allows you to gather data on who owns/manages all the rental properties, which are the sort of data you need to determine if rents or absentee-landlordism is even a problem anywhere. In response to the parent, the landlord is not providing housing. The people who live in the housing provide the demand for housing. The home construction industry provide new supply, and owners of existing housing stocks may be enticed to sell once their price point is reached. A landlord that buys a house with the intention to rent to someone else is acting as a middleman. If they did not bid up the price of that particular house, the price might have remained low enough for someone who intended to live in it to buy it. So what the landlord actually provides is the ability to buy a small interval of living in a home, rather than having to buy all the years of living there--from now until the fall of civilization--all at once. Mortgages are a different sort of middleman. They provide the ability to spread out that payment for all the remaining years over a fixed number of years. But the interest on a home mortgage is mostly just another form of rent-seeking. Without the availability of the mortgages, the houses would have to sell at lower prices, to those who could afford to pay for them. The problem, if there is one, is not that rent-seekers take rents, but that they do not spend those rents close enough to the people who give them for them to easily earn them back. If you rent out the loft above your garage to a single student, you're likely to spend some of that money at the restaurant where they bus tables part-time. That money circulates back through the local community. If you live in St. Louis and own a 3/2 in Tulsa, maybe the customer support line of the juice press you bought runs its call center out of there. That money leaves faster than it comes back. And if your retirement plan owns part of a REIT that owns rental property all over, and also has a bit invested in Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, that's basically a diffuse sucking of money out of the entire rest of the country to feed a diffuse scattering of investors that don't necessarily live anywhere near the sources. The circulation loop is totally broken. People stand at the nexus ("Wall Street") and skim off the top, then don't spend that money back into the communities where the rents come from. This is how an Appalachian ex-miner family can rent a drafty barn with no furniture for $300 a month, and not see any local jobs available to recirculate that money back to them. The owner doesn't live there, or spend money there, or even spare a single thought when their plane flies overhead. The only reason they own the barn is to extract the Social Security Disability money that flies in from Washington, DC, briefly touches earth, and then immediately flies away to a community where people own things for their living. Something like a Georgist land-value tax does not meaningfully distinguish between a landlord that lives next door and spends all their rent locally and one that lives 12 time zones away and spends it all to people much more distant on the money-circulation graph. Perhaps it would be more appropriate to tax rents based on the distance between the beneficial owner's legal domicile and the property? Composite entities like corporations and partnerships would then have to report their domicile and distance calculations for distributions and dividends though. Seems like a mess for reporting.