4 ms·
You come in and hack with the team for a couple hours. You know, the activity that you'll be paid to do. How is this that hard?
by adamnemecek 9y ago
You come in and hack with the team for a couple hours. You know, the activity that you'll be paid to do. How is this that hard?
- reikonomusha 9y agoHow often can that really be productive?
- adamnemecek 9y agoYou are right, we should do white board interviews mixed with "how many golf balls can you fit into a school bus". Now that's what I programming skill assessment.
- rglullis 9y agoYou are saying that an engineer from my already resource-constrained team should be allocated to: - make a quick onboarding of the candidate - explain the general architecture of the system - find an issue/story that is "superficial" enough to be taken by someone with zero-experience at that job, but "deep" enough that you can test their experience and knowledge (oh, and that story better not involve anything that might be related to core company IP.) - do a pair-programming session with the candidate, and be the main driver ALL OF THE TIME (because the candidate does not have any git access, so their development environment is useless) - evaluate the candidate You really think that is something for "a couple hours"? Even if it were, do you think it is a good use of the time of the engineer that is going to be allocated to the task?
- adamnemecek 9y agoNever said it needs to be the current system. Make a simplified version if you want. Or something completely different that uses the similar languages/paradigms? > Even if it were, do you think it is a good use of the time of the engineer that is going to be allocated to the task? So what exactly is the alternative? Look, if you can't prioritize hiring, don't be surprised that you aren't able to hire. Yes, the engineers should be able to do this.
- fapjacks 9y agoAs an engineer that's been tasked to interview in this style, I have to say that it's possible to do with a few candidates without too much interruption to my regular duties, and it's actually my favorite method of interviewing. Having an inbound candidate build some simplified version of the thing we're making is extremely helpful and doesn't cost too much. You can easily define the simplified work sample project once and reuse it many times without spending too much time on it. The parent's criticisms are valid because there almost certainly won't be some work sample that fit all of the criteria mentioned and is actually a part of the product. But a work sample of a simplified version of the product they'll be working on is absolutely easy to do and insightful for both you and the candidate. Maybe they just really don't like the kind of thing you're working on. Well, this gives them a chance to dip their toe in the pool.
- rglullis 9y agoHow many "systems" do you think your run-of-the-mill startup has? What is the alternative? As most of things in life, the answer is "it depends". It depends on the size of the company, the type of candidate they are looking, the industry, and so on. But let's assume we are talking about the average startup that is neither looking for superstar candidates nor only looking for fresh graduates from Stanford. For those cases, I believe that one simple programming task, that exercises some of the technology required can be used as a screening filter. The task should not take more than 2 hours to reach a working state. If the solution presented by the candidate is satisfactory, then you go to the interview to discuss the solution and how they got to the solution, the things that were easy/hard, and so on. Then you ask about the things that are missing, and the candidate's evaluation on how they would like to tackle. Is that a satisfactory alternative?
- adamnemecek 9y agoI feel like we are talking past each other. > How many "systems" do you think your run-of-the-mill startup has? These dont need to be production systems, they can in fact be simple systems used just for interviewing. So in your alternative, how long does an engineer really spend on interviewing the candidate?
- s73ver_ 9y agoWhat if I already have a job?