3 ms·
Please don't parrot Trump's lies and Russian sponsored propaganda intended to distract from the Russia investigation. This is not the place for that. You're onl
by DonHopkins 9y ago
Please don't parrot Trump's lies and Russian sponsored propaganda intended to distract from the Russia investigation. This is not the place for that. You're only embarrassing and discrediting yourself, and fooling nobody, while insulting everyone's intelligence.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/fact-checker/wp/2016/12/13/the-pre-war-intelligence-on-iraq-wrong-or-hyped-by-the-bush-white-house/?utm_term=.2c5384af9241 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/fact-checker/wp/2016/12/...
“These are the same people that said Saddam Hussein had weapons of mass destruction.”
— statement from the Trump transition team on Washington Post report that the CIA concluded that Russia intervened in the election to help Trump
Donald Trump’s staff dismissed U.S. intelligence conclusions that Russia actively interfered in the presidential election by noting the flawed intelligence cited by the Bush administration in making the case for invading Iraq nearly 14 years ago.
An alternative perspective came from House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.), who pinned the blame on the Bush White House for misrepresenting the intelligence.
Nancy Pelosi @NancyPelosi:
The intel didn't state that Iraq had WMDs. The Bush-Cheney WH made that misrepresentation.
12:21 AM - Dec 11, 2016
Trump’s complaint about this semi-ancient history is a bit odd because a) the intelligence analysts who worked on Middle East WMDs are not going to be the same as analysts focused on Russian cyber-behavior; b) the intelligence collection for hacking in the United States by overseas powers would be different from assessing illicit weapons programs in the Middle East; and c) reforms were put in place after the Iraq War to make it harder for suspect intelligence to bubble up to the top ranks without careful scrutiny. (For instance, a new procedure required heads of intelligence agencies to vouch personally for the credibility of any of their own agency’s sources that are used in a major estimate.)
Moreover, the Bush administration appeared determined to attack Iraq for any number of reasons beyond suspicions of WMDs; officials simply seized on WMDs because they concluded that that represented the strongest case for an invasion. “For bureaucratic reasons we settled on one issue, weapons of mass destruction, because it was the one reason everyone could agree on,” then-Deputy Defense Secretary Paul Wolfowitz told Vanity Fair in 2003.
- RasputinsBro 9y agoIt's funny that you call it "semi-ancient" history, given that the US is still occupying Iraq to this day.
- DonHopkins 9y agoHow does that wording that I quote or the fact that we've been in Iraq for such a long time contradict the point that "The intel didn't state that Iraq had WMDs. The Bush-Cheney WH made that misrepresentation." Do you agree with the fact that it's the Bush-Cheney White House who perpetrated the fraud by cherry picking and hyping the evidence that supported their pre-conceived conclusions while ignoring evidence from the intelligence community that contradicted it (to the point of outing a CIA agent to end her career because they didn't like the evidence her husband presented them), but the only nit you have to pick is with the Washington Post's wording calling 16 years "ancient history"?
- RasputinsBro 9y ago> How does that wording that I quote or the fact that we've been in Iraq for such a long time contradict the point that "The intel didn't state that Iraq had WMDs. The Bush-Cheney WH made that misrepresentation." It doesn't, it's completely irrelevant. Just like your opinion that that history is ancient is completely irrelevant. > Do you agree with the fact that it's the Bush-Cheney White House who perpetrated the fraud by cherry picking and hyping the evidence, but the only nit you have to pick is with the Washington Post's wording calling 16 years "ancient history"? You're the one making the distinction between US intel and US gov. No one else is talking about that or cares. US gov/intel/whatever told a lie and US media amplified it. Just like the Russia gov and media did now.
- DonHopkins 9y agoSo your comment is completely irrelevant. You're just trying to distract from the point. And speak for yourself about not caring. You're just trying to get people to stop talking about it.
- RasputinsBro 9y agoSo is yours. This thread is about media and propaganda, and you're talking about intel.
- CapacitorSet 9y agoYou claim that I'm "parroting lies", but the article you linked confirms what I said: American intelligence claimed that there were WMDs in Iraq. Notably, it says that "Before the October 2002 NIE, some intelligence agencies assessed that the Iraqi government was reconstituting a nuclear weapons program", and that "The intelligence community consistently stated between the late 1990s and 2003 that Iraq retained biological warfare agents and the capability to produce more". It is reporting in greater detail what I briefly mentioned in my comment. It is true that parts of these reports were exaggerated and parts were not given attention, but the same can be said of intelligence reports about Russian influence in elections. About your three points, none disproves my implication that the reports mentioned by Twitter are fake - if anything, b and c may make it more difficult to produce false reports, but certainly not impossible
- DonHopkins 9y agoYour attempt to refute the fact that the U.S. intelligence community’s conclusion that both RT and Sputnik attempted to interfere with the election, by blaming the CIA for the Iraq War without mentioning the fact that Bush and Cheney cherry picked the evidence and railroaded the decision, is extremely disingenuous, and literally parrots Trump and Putin's propaganda.
- CapacitorSet 9y agoYou claimed that I lie, but you're lying before my very eyes. I neither blamed the CIA for the Iraq War, nor did I "not mention the fact that Bush and Cheney cherry picked the evidence", and most of all I didn't even "refute the fact that the US intelligence community's conclusion [is?] that both RT and Sputnik attempted to interfere with the election". * I didn't blame the CIA for the Iraq War, as you can verify by re-reading my comments. * I certainly mentioned that the evidence was cherry-picked: I highlighted the mention [here](https://i.imgur.com/sLtW1al.png https://i.imgur.com/sLtW1al.png). I did not mention who cherry-picked the evidence, but it doesn't seem relevant to my point or yours. * If I understand your first sentence correctly - it is incomplete, giving space to interpretation - you're claiming that I attempt to refute the fact that the US intelligence's conclusion is that RT and Sputnik attempted to interfere with the election; I never refuted that the intelligence's opinion is such, nor did I attempt to refute that. I genuinely believe that these reports represent the intelligence community's opinion. Rather, I'm doubtful of the reliability of these reports, in light of the Iraq reports of 2003.