3 ms·
Dangerous compared to what? What is your standard of measure for danger? What are the alternatives to provide vital energy for human flourishing? What was the
by abtinf 9y ago
Dangerous compared to what? What is your standard of measure for danger? What are the alternatives to provide vital energy for human flourishing?
What was the death toll from Fukushima? Zero. Everything at Fukushima went wrong, and yet only 8 out of 2400 workers were exposed to out-of-tolerate levels of radiation. None of the plant's neighbors got sick, and no discernible increase in the rate of cancer deaths is expected. Radiation is everywhere in the real world, it is a natural part of life, yet we treat it like any amount is a lethal danger, when in low doses it is not a meaningful threat.
Fukushima was a non-event, and yet it caused a movement to shut down all nuclear power. Fear of nuclear is totally irrational. The more we embrace nuclear power, the greater its benefits to human well being.
Nuclear is safer than every other form of large scale energy generation ever devised. The only concern with nuclear plants is a large release of radiation, which is unlikely due to the layers of shielding and containment. The scaremonger's goto example of chernobyl lacked such safety measures because the Soviets didn't care about human life.
Also worth reading is The Health Hazards of NOT Going Nuclear: https://www.amazon.com/Health-Hazards-Not-Going-Nuclear/dp/0911762175 https://www.amazon.com/Health-Hazards-Not-Going-Nuclear/dp/0...
- jasonwatkinspdx 9y agoI am very familiar with the details of Fukushima, the prevalence of natural radiation, and the health risks of alternatives. I again believe it is entirely dishonest to call fear of nuclear power irrational. Was it a mistake for Germany and Japan to shift generation away from nuclear? Yes IMO. But it's absurd to call an event that required mass evacuation harmless.
- nickik 9y agoFear is not binary. Yes of course fear of nuclear power is rational, but so if fear of cows, cars and a lot of other stuff. The amount of fear that exists is competently out of proportion to the real problem.