6 ms·
So a security researcher who was angry about getting raided and hit with a CFAA accusation after an unauthorized access of private medical data started doxxing
by Spivak 9y ago
So a security researcher who was angry about getting raided and hit with a CFAA accusation after an unauthorized access of private medical data started doxxing the FBI agent responsible on Twitter. And in response the FBI is requesting information about the Twitter users that were part of the conversation.
Doesn't seem quite as sensational once you know the backstory. The author is right that the charges aren't the strongest but we can't be obtuse and pretend that posting the personal information of the officer and his family couldn't meet the bar for intimidation or harassment.
- slackingoff2017 9y ago"unauthorized access" is bs. It was a public ftp server and he notified the owners. It's like telling your neighbor his door is open.
- gist 9y ago> It's like telling your neighbor his door is open. I think it's more like your neighbors door being open and you going in side and seeing that the refrigerator is open. Therefore proving that you trespassed on private property. Not legal. Of course in most cases you wouldn't be prosecuted for that I would imagine unless you tramped around the house. Article says: "he'd come across an FTP server operated by another dental software company, Patterson Dental, which makes "Eaglesoft," a dental practice management software product. Shafer had discovered an openly available anonymous FTP server with patient data" In order to determine it had patient data he would have to see the patient data not just connect to the server at the root level and then exit. So at the very least (in theory) he would have cd'd a few directories and perhaps downloaded a few files or noted the directory structure and names. That is entering and looking around.
- DarronWyke 9y agoOccam's Razor would say he logged in, saw a patient_data directory or something similar, and logged out. We don't know anything really about how his perusal or lack thereof had him come to that conclusion. If it was running batch job processing that places like Epic and others do, it could have a recognizable directory structure that would give it a clear fingerprint.
- jtbayly 9y agoFirst, I don't believe it is against the law to simply connect to a public FTP server. And I'm certain that I wouldn't bother to notify somebody that their public FTP server was... public. However, if I saw something that clearly wasn't supposed to be public. It's more like looking across the street and seeing a private act through an open window, and going to the front door and knocking and telling them that the window is open. There are laws against leaving patient data in the public. There are laws against public indecency. There are also laws against unauthorized access and laws against being a peeping Tom. Which one is going on is not necessarily easy to determine.
- joemi 9y agoHasn't unauthorized access of a server with weak or no security measures been proven illegal many times in court already, though? Admittedly, I'm not a legal expert of any kind, but I could swear that's a common thing.
- theossuary 9y agoThat's like saying you looked at my open front door so you committed B&E
- joemi 9y agoSure, that's one way to look at it. But also, since you have to actually interact with the server in order to discover such vulnerabilities in it, it could also be viewed as similar to walking in through an unlocked door and looking around. That, at least, is trespassing, I believe.
- tertius 9y agoOr making an inventory list of everything inside. "Oh, here's a filing cabinet, I'll just pull the inventory. Just peeking in..."
- slackingoff2017 9y agoWhen you connect with ftp or HTTP you get a top level directory or a home page. Same thing as looking through an open door.
- theossuary 9y agoAlright if we want to get specific it's like being blind and touching a home's open front door. Incredulous that the door is open you feel around inside for a second and feel a set of keys on the hook. You leave at this point and a week later are arrested for B&E because your fingerprints are on the keys (or you were stupid enough to tell the owner their door was open)
- 9y ago
- heartbreak 9y agoNo one is pretending that it couldn't meet the bar. It doesn't in my opinion, but that's not the point. The point is that Ken et. al. were not harassing anyone.
- nl 9y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15552707 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15552707 Seems relevant. The allegations are that he was harassing the family on FB.
- stedaniels 9y agoDoxxing? Hardly. Looking at the Twitter thread, he did far less than a lazy casual fan of a TV star would do on an average Google/Facebook search. > Doesn't seem quite as sensational once you know the backstory. Though your summary was sensationalised by the addition of the term doxxing (usually negative connotations there), whether you meant it to be or not. It is all about how the spin is put on it. An innocuous situation can be played up, or down, by either side. P.S. @Spivak, it's your 1024 days anniversary on HN! :-)
- amichal 9y agoactually if you read the attachments at the end of the referenced complaint[1] the FBI is claiming he did a bit more then look up the agent and his family. He also sent various semi-threating messages to them on facebook. Still not sure why that gives them grounds to subpoena everyone on the thread. [1] https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/4116064/Shafer-Complaint.pdf https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/4116064/Shafer-Co...
- stedaniels 9y agoDarn it. Apologies for going off with my half baked facts ;-)
- mirimir 9y agoDOJ's insanely broad subpoena aside, this is the real lesson. If you're going to harass, even in a joking way, an FBI agent and their family, don't do it using your real name!
- joemi 9y agoFirst definition of "dox" that came up for me on google: > search for and publish private or identifying information about (a particular individual) on the Internet, typically with malicious intent. Sounds appropriate, doesn't it? If you still disagree, here's a thought experiment: If someone were searching and posting that info about you, or anyone else reading this very thread, wouldn't we call that doxxing?
- maxerickson 9y agoSo if you get @ed in a Twitter thread that meets the bar of irritating DOJ, it's totally reasonable for them to subpoena the times of day you use your Twitter account? I guess that fits with throwing legal charges at people that laugh at you.
- Bartweiss 9y agoThat's the creepiest part to me - it equates "being spoken to" with "speaking about". The subpoena against the comment poster is questionable, but targeting people who were named in the Tweet is ridiculous. In particular, Dissent Doe never engaged with the thread in any way, but was only named in the exchange. If you can spawn an invasive data request against someone just by including their handle in a tweet, that's a shocking overreach or a misunderstanding of the communication system.
- mmanfrin 9y agothe FBI is requesting information about the Twitter users that were part of the conversation. What an exceptionally flippant dismissal of what is clearly an overstep. "FBI is requesting information" i.e. the FBI is subpoenaing Twitter about "users that were part of the conversation" -- users who discussed a case on twitter. I feel like your use of the phrase "part of the conversation" -- a phrase often used as euphemism for actual involvement -- is a subtle deception to anyone reading your comment. The totality of their involvement is tweets discussing the case. You go even further by following up claiming it "doesn't seem quite as sensational once you know the backstory" and in the next sentence you mention the alleged crime that they were talking about, not that they were involved in. To me, it feels like your comment is either missing the point that these 5 were simply talking about the case; or you are being willfully deceptive.
- icebraining 9y agoNo. The users were not part of the conversation in which the researcher doxxed anyone. They were part of another conversation, in which his total involvement was a smiley in response to one of their tweets. As the article makes plain: "Then, to subpoena a ton of info on 5 totally unrelated Twitter users... just because Shafer tweeted a smiley face emoticon at them?"