9 ms·
The Unfortunate Fallout of Campus Postmodernism
- taylodl 9y agoThe more interesting question is what role did the recoil against postmodernism play in the election of Donald Trump? You can't reason with postmodernists since they eschew science and evidence-based reason as tools of oppression. They are quite literally unreasonable. This is not a trivial concern - since they can't be reasoned with I know of several people who took a "Fuck it. Burn it." approach to the election of Donald Trump (I don't agree with that strategy, but that's another matter). That's purely anecdotal, but it does make one wonder what role it played on sending Donald Trump to the White House and what role it might play on his staying there in 2021.
- hmschreck 9y agoIt seems like the article goes from talking about the reasonable parts of modern liberal belief (LGBT people have the right to exist, racism is still something that exists and happens to minorities, etc) to going dangerously close to the redpill minefield when they start using extreme examples ("cissexual heteropatriarchy" is a phrase I've literally never heard) and the idea that one instance where fighting against things I think we can all agree are bad (racism, sexism, etc) were taken too far means the entire idea of fighting those things is reprehensible. It seems like that's the real problem now - it's not whether or not these problems exist, or whether they're worth fighting, but rather to what extent they should be fought.
- creaghpatr 9y agoIf you haven't been to a college campus in awhile you would be shocked at the recent gap between 'general' liberal beliefs (legalize pot, gay marriage, increased welfare) and 'post-modern' liberal beliefs, which boil down to increasingly abstract accusations of structural racism/sexism/transism/other isms. That you don't recognize the phrase 'cissexual heteropatriarchy' seems to suggest this, because that's a term that many college administrations recognize, accept, and dole out punishments on, and even questioning that logic will put your education in jeopardy. Basically it's cultural extortion.
- QAPereo 9y agoHow about some concrete examples of all of that? If it’s that common you should be able to reference them like crazy. Show me evidence of this growing pattern. Edit: downvote away, but show me the evidence.
- jimmywanger 9y agoThe original argument has plenty of examples. Evergreen College wanted a "day of freedom" and forced a biology professor to resign. Just yesterday, a crazy SJW math professor said that math was inherently racist and cisgendered, and bemoaned that the social sciences didn't get as much funding as math. [1] Also, Berkeley and Stanford students complained so loudly and violently that Ben Shapiro and Ann Coulter did not speak (from the article) The search is trivial. [1] http://dailycaller.com/2017/10/23/professor-claims-math-algebra-and-geometry-promote-white-privilege/ http://dailycaller.com/2017/10/23/professor-claims-math-alge...
- QAPereo 9y agoA pattern within something as vast as our higher education system, and that’s it? Followed by the classic deflection of all those without a leg stand on, “find it yourself” to boot? This site has such incredible ups, but the downs are equally staggering and disheartening.
- imustbeevil 9y agoYou realize that your posturing, followed by denial of the evidence given to you that doesn't fit the narrative you entered the thread with, is exactly the problem that people are talking about here? I have experienced this first hand in New Jersey, Boston, and Colorado. It seems to me that the only people who don't see a pattern are the people creating the pattern.
- QAPereo 9y agoAsking for evidence commensurate to a claim is posturing? Edit: Claiming that you are right and someone else is wrong because they don't have evidence is posturing. Where did I claim to be right, rather than ask for evidence to support someone else's claim? You seem confused.
- rayiner 9y agoLook how much hate Bernie Sanders—a man who fought for equality his whole life—is getting from the left. He’s being called racist, sexist, etc., and not just by some straw man versions of liberals.
- praisewhitey 9y agoWhat hate is he getting from the left? I have seen center-left DNC members throw insults his way, but they would very much be on the right of his views (especially economically).
- rayiner 9y agohttp://www.npr.org/2015/11/01/453663625/is-it-fair-to-accuse-bernie-sanders-of-sexism http://www.npr.org/2015/11/01/453663625/is-it-fair-to-accuse...
- linkregister 9y agoAll that article established was that some undetermined amount of Clinton fanatics accused Sanders of using sexist language for political gain (to promote Clinton’s presidential candidacy). Your previous comment implies the criticism was more widespread and with more breadth.
- the_gastropod 9y agoThe term "Bernie Bro" is at least partially used to paint Bernie supporters as misogynistic "bros" as far as I can tell.
- dragonwriter 9y agoYes, but it's used by his opponents to his right within the Democratic Party as a guilt-by-association attack to make those in the electorate on the left uncomfortable with him, it's not actually an attack from the left.
- linkregister 9y ago
- WalterSear 9y agoI was inundated with that kind of language when I was last in school, a few years ago.
- coffee9 9y agoStrange how it's always Communism, seems like a random thing for campuses to pump out so consistently.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- alexryan 9y agoIf you've spent your entire life wiring your brain to fight "oppression", what do you do after the war has been won decisively? It's not easy to rewire your brain. This is especially true when your job depends upon the existence of "oppression" and you have no other marketable skills.
- forapurpose 9y ago> reasonable parts of modern liberal belief [vs.] the redpill minefield when they start using extreme examples The things you call "reasonable" were "redpill minefield" to prior generations. Even women working was radical. Segregation was widely accepted. Homosexuality was illegal - nobody was talking about marriage, except probably some college campus radicals. It's a regular pattern: In college, we are open to new ideas and form their beliefs; we challenge the existing orthodoxies and wonder how the older generation can possibly support obvious evils, not understanding they were radical at the time. Then we move on and retain those beliefs: we aren't challenged on our ideas and aren't exposed to new ones, at least not nearly as much and as radically as in college. The new generation goes to college, challenges our settled ideas, and we suddenly are in the position we criticized before: Now, we say, they are going too far. And so change often only happens as fast as generations come and go. Marijuana legalization took waiting for the old generation to die out. Old white people - i.e., the old generation - make up much of the Tea Party (if that's still a thing) and the reactionary GOP. I think the language is off-putting, but that has nothing to do with the value of the ideas (if I read it correctly the meaning of "cissexual heteropatriarchy", which is new to me too, is that politics is dominated by heterosexuals who fit their gender stereotypes (i.e., aren't transsexual, etc.) - really not such a radical thought). I agree the ideas are challenging, but that certainly is not a signal of their value - other than possibly being a positive signal. If we want society to move forward faster than the generational pace, then we can't play the role of the comfortable, older generation - we're going to have to step way outside our comfort zones and into the redpill minefield.
- Chaebixi 9y ago> start using extreme examples ("cissexual heteropatriarchy" is a phrase I've literally never heard) Count yourself lucky. Seriously. These people totally exist. For instance: I have an white 20-something acquaintance who posted a photo of a decoration [1] he either made or received that was all full stuff like "In this house we fight cisgendered heteropatriarchy." They are very dogmatic and enthralled by a pseudo-religious ideology complete with devils (e.g. whiteness), saints (e.g. feminism), forms of penitent flagellation, etc. > It seems like that's the real problem now - it's not whether or not these problems exist, or whether they're worth fighting, but rather to what extent they should be fought. Or whether the battle should be led by monomaniacal ideologues. If you can't tell, I'm not one of these people, but I spent a lot of time around them (and am pretty exhausted from it). [1] the decoration was basically a parody of this: https://www.aliexpress.com/store/product/House-Rules-Family-Quote-In-This-House-We-Do-Real-We-Forgive-We-Love-Wall-Decal/1424253_32269911205.html https://www.aliexpress.com/store/product/House-Rules-Family-...
- danharaj 9y ago> You can't reason with postmodernists since they eschew science and evidence-based reason as tools of oppression. Which postmodern authors eschew science and evidence-based reasoning?
- _rpd 9y ago> Sara Giordano argues that "traditional science" relies on "a colonial and racialized form of power," and must be replaced with an "anti-science, antiracist, feminist approach to knowledge production.” https://www.campusreform.org/?ID=10021 https://www.campusreform.org/?ID=10021
- oconnore 9y agoThis website is ridiculous, featured article: "Trump Jr. says universities teach students to hate America"
- Zee2 9y agoThe professor's words still stand independent from whatever website decided to feature them.
- danharaj 9y agoPaper: http://catalystjournal.org/ojs/index.php/catalyst/article/view/122/pdf_3 http://catalystjournal.org/ojs/index.php/catalyst/article/vi... Abstract: In this paper, I argue that those of us who have left the Sciences proper and moved to feminist studies spaces have continued to do science through our teaching. In a moment when the impulse to do real science is palpitating in our feminist hearts, I suggest that we critically examine the political stakes of our affective attachments and detachments from s/Science(s). I consider what it means to be attached to a Science that earned its epistemic authority through its co-constitution with colonization and slavery. I argue that passion for science may act to strengthen the relationship between Science and Truth and conversely, willful refusal and failure may be used to break the bond. I offer critical science literacy as a practice that can directly challenge the epistemic authority of Science and be read as "doing science" or more broadly as "rewriting knowledge." Honestly, sounds nothing like the original link which is a poorly written polemic that is obviously done in bad faith (at least to me). I think the abstract is interesting enough that I'll read the paper myself and come to my own conclusions once I have spare time.
- twblalock 9y agoI don't think very many Trump voters spend time thinking about academic postmodernism.
- remarkEon 9y agoPerhaps you’re right. But, even if they don’t spend time reading and debating Derrida it sounds plausible to me that they’d react negatively to the consequences of Postmodernism - whether they know that’s what it is doesn’t matter.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- taylodl 9y agoSpeaking anecdotally, the majority of the people I know for which this applies are college students and majoring in mathematics or the hard sciences. It appears the Two Cultures (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Two_Cultures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Two_Cultures) are becoming further estranged from one another.
- WalterSear 9y agoOf course not. But they demonstrably spend time hating other people in order to make themselves feel better. And if the people in question are huffing their own farts, it's just more grist for the mill.
- gjjrfcbugxbhf 9y agoDo you mean the Trump voters or the academic postmodernists?
- WalterSear 9y agoThe Trump voters are laughing at the academics who are huffing their own farts.
- dragonwriter 9y ago
- qntty 9y agoMembers of labor unions, and unorganized unskilled workers, will sooner or later realize that their government is not even trying to prevent wages from sinking or to prevent jobs from being exported. Around the same time, they will realize that suburban white-collar workers — themselves desperately afraid of being downsized — are not going to let themselves be taxed to provide social benefits for anyone else. At that point, something will crack. The nonsuburban electorate will decide that the system has failed and start looking around for a strongman to vote for — someone willing to assure them that, once he is elected, the smug bureaucrats, tricky lawyers, overpaid bond salesmen, and postmodernist professors will no longer be calling the shots. One thing that is very likely to happen is that the gains made in the past 40 years by black and brown Americans, and by homosexuals, will be wiped out. Jocular contempt for women will come back into fashion. … All the resentment which badly educated Americans feel about having their manners dictated to them by college graduates will find an outlet. -Richard Rorty, 1998
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoI can assure you that if 'postmodernist professors' were calling the shots, the world would look far different than it does. For better or for worse I can't say. But very different.
- mccoyspace 9y agoThat is a fantastic quote from a truly great American thinker. You could add to it the quote from Ron Suskind's article from an unnamed Bush administration official: "The aide said that guys like me were 'in what we call the reality-based community,' which he defined as people who 'believe that solutions emerge from your judicious study of discernible reality.' [...] 'That's not the way the world really works anymore,' he continued. 'We're an empire now, and when we act, we create our own reality. And while you're studying that reality—judiciously, as you will—we'll act again, creating other new realities, which you can study too, and that's how things will sort out. We're history's actors…and you, all of you, will be left to just study what we do'" [1] This is a very 'postmodern' statement, but coming from the Right and from a government official able to wield the power of the State rather than a poor undergraduate or marginalized assistant professor of humanities. Arguably postmodernist thought has been so effective in describing contemporary social reality that it has been fully absorbed by the cultural/political Right. Claims of "fake news" alt-right social media memes, totalizing institutional critique -- these all are 'weaponized' forms and tactics from the postmodern Left, but now as mainstream tool of right-wing political action. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2004/10/17/magazine/faith-certainty-and-the-presidency-of-george-w-bush.html http://www.nytimes.com/2004/10/17/magazine/faith-certainty-a...
- Overtonwindow 9y agoThrowing in two cents from the world of politics, a lot of people voted in opposition to what they saw was a culture out of control. I think this is evident by the areas that votes for Trump, and the demographics. Trump pulled broadly from many segments of society.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> The more interesting question is what role did the recoil against postmodernism play in the election of Donald Trump? While it figures in the propaganda a lot, I don't think it's all that important; for broad (such as it is) base of Trump support, reaction against modernism is probably more germane than that against postmodernism. And the forces behind the movement seem very strongly influenced by postmodern dialectical approaches, though obviously the key conflict they arrange analysis around are different than those of the more widely acknowledged leftist post-modernists. Reaction against post-modernism seems likely to influence a fairly narrow intellectual (or pseudo-intellectual) slice of the movement.
- dcre 9y agoThere is no content here, only moral panic of precisely the kind the author is claiming to denounce: "Students are being taught by these postmodern professors that there is no truth, that science and empirical facts are tools of oppression by the white patriarchy, and that nearly everyone in America is racist and bigoted, including their own professors, most of whom are liberals or progressives devoted to fighting these social ills." The college students and professors who are supposedly descending into frenzied irrationality are actually spending their days talking, writing, and thinking about these issues in sophisticated ways. The moral panic about such people is just political maneuvering.
- biggestlou 9y agoWhat these articles invariably fail to do is name even one single "postmodern professor."
- dogruck 9y agoMakes me think of the recent headline where a Professor of Math Education supposedly claimed that basic math concepts perpetuate "white privilege." https://www.campusreform.org/?ID=10005 https://www.campusreform.org/?ID=10005
- jdpigeon 9y agoThis website really seems to have an agenda and isn't a source I would qualify as good journalism. For anyone who's interested in the story, here's an interview with the professor. Admittedly, from an interviewer who's pretty on board with her ideas. https://theeducatorsroom.com/mathematics-political-post-session-rochelle-gutierrez/ https://theeducatorsroom.com/mathematics-political-post-sess...
- oconnore 9y ago> "seems to have an agenda" Understatement of the year... the featured article is "Trump Jr. says universities teach students to hate America".
- dogruck 9y agoThanks for the link -- I had not seen that before. Still, it does not look like she backs away from her statements. For example, she says: > So, just like, there’s not a lot of incentive for Whites to interrogate Whiteness as the norm and as the right way to have society set up, there’s not a lot of incentive for mathematicians and math teachers to interrogate this unearned status that mathematics has in society. Do you disagree? Do you think the original article that I linked mischaracterized the Professor's statements and opinions?
- jdpigeon 9y agoNo, I was actually pretty surprised by how ridiculous some of her statements sounded. Still, encouraging traffic to a site like campusreform.com makes me feel queasy.
- 9y ago
- elipsey 9y agoIt’s weird how much this is not my experience with academia. I spent _way_ too long getting my BS at a state school, then I worked for Cornell as a programmer in an engineering grad school for several years, and now all my friends are grad students, instructors, and post-docs. Like there was literally no one else at my last barbecue, but I don’t know anyone who talks like this, and I have never seen protests or commotion on campus. I guess it might be because I mostly know engineering students, but I’m having trouble locating this epidemic of societal breakdown everyone seems to be talking about...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bbctol 9y agoIt's because this is a moral panic from people who think they're immune to moral panics.
- praisewhitey 9y agoI did my undergrad 10 years ago in a very large US college. Now I'm back doing grad in a different very large US college. The people the author is talking about do exist, but I would estimate there's about 100 of them in my college of ~39,000. And even then, how many of them will still be that way 5 years out of college?
- eximius 9y ago100 people showing up en masse at relevant events can cause quite a stir and wield an absurd amount of influence if they are loud.
- posterboy 9y agowhats the unit you are counting in, milliagressions per cubicstudent? /s but I mean not everyone weighs in the same nor is it a sharp cutoff.
- jdpigeon 9y agoI volunteered at a few food co-ops and student-run cafes during both undergrad and graduate school. It got me out of my bubble of science/technology classmates and exposed me to a lot of this world. There was never any bad behaviour, just plenty of students getting as serious about post-modern and feminist theory as I was about my science.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- vowelless 9y agoJust FYI, the author is Michael Shermer, founder and Editor in Chief of Sceptic Magazine, which also includes Richard Dawkins on its editorial board (along with some other intellectual heavyweights ).
- DonbunEf7 9y agoI'm ashamed to be a postmodernist because of these assholes. Postmodernists supposedly say "there is no truth." But that sounds an awful lot like a truth! Anybody who thinks only Sith deal in absolutes is going to have a bad time. Postmodernism still works once logic and critical thought are applied, but it stops being an excuse for bullshit.
- creaghpatr 9y agoPostmodernism is still a useful philosophical concept-the idea of fluidity is important when debating abstract ideas. it's when hard maths and science are literally changed as a result of perceived injustices that society becomes destabilized
- forapurpose 9y agoI think we should be careful about getting caught up in empty rants against the boogieman du jour, even if many people here feel like the author. It would be great to read a serious critique and defense of postmodernism, and if someone wants to allege that it has a widespread following on campuses, and that the sort of anecdotes in the editorial are widespread and that they are connected to postmodernism, they should present serious evidence of it. If we want to read about postmodernism, let's exercise our intellectual curiosity and learn about it, good and bad. I'm disappointed in Scientific American for publishing a piece so lacking in any serious basis or reasoning. It's a rant of anecdotes; I'm not sure the author knows what postmodernism is - they seem to attribute to it 'everything liberal that I don't understand'. Such low-quality outbursts reinforce among people in the sciences ignorance of the humanities. Someone famous once said: 'Dogs bark at those whom they do now know.'
- forapurpose 9y agoTalking to a few professional academics I know, my impression has been that postmodernism is out of fashion in academia. I was disappointed because it seems like exactly what we are missing now (and in fact I thought the abandonment of postmodernism might be a cause of our problems): A fundamental rejection of the supremacy of ideologies and absolute truths, and recognizing that at all their foundations are flawed human perceptions and self-serving assumptions. And the acceptance that yes, that includes the person in the mirror and their cherished beliefs.
- linkregister 9y agoI upvoted this article because it describes a problem on college campuses that I have only become aware of recently. That said, it misrepresents the Berkeley riots in a deceptive way. The rioters were not students; they were masked, black-clad members of Antifa and a movement called Black Bloc. I sympathize with journalists’ struggle to provide a coherent narrative, but rewriting history only serves to weaken the author’s point by anyone with first or secondhand knowledge of the events described in the article.
- maldusiecle 9y agoArticles like this seem to deliberately blur categories so as to describe large portions of academia as uncharitably as possible. "Postmodernism" has never been a term with a consistent definition, but even given that, certain claims in this article are contradictory or outright nonsensical. "Postmodernists have tried to hijack biology, have taken over large parts of political science, almost all of anthropology, history and English," Maitra concludes, "and have proliferated self-referential journals, citation circles, non-replicable research ..." What would it even mean for English research to be "non-replicable"? In fact, the replication crisis has struck social psychology harder than any of the fields mentioned. The implication throughout is that students are passive here: activism is something that their professors talk them into. This was not at all my experience at university, and it doesn't match what I've read about many contemporary protests. I'd be curious whether it matches the experience of anyone here on HN. I'd argue that most of these students who supposedly think there is "no truth" have very specific views of what is and is not true, and that their views are violently opposed to those of the author. The last time there was intense campus protest, the issues were civil rights and the Vietnam war. No doubt, in today's climate protesters engaging on those issues would be likewise condemned as postmodernists believing in "no truth."
- Floegipoky 9y ago>> 12 of the 13 academics at U.C. Berkeley who signed a letter to the chancellor protesting Yiannopoulos were from “Critical theory, Gender studies and Post-Colonial/Postmodernist/Marxist background.” This is a shift in Marxist theory from class conflict to identity politics conflict; instead of judging people by the content of their character, they are now to be judged by the color of their skin (or their ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, et cetera). So Yiannopoulos' critics object to his identity as a white gay man, rather than the hate speech he proliferates? Nice try
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hypersoar 9y agoThis article makes its case very poorly and misrepresents a few things. It's not at all clear who the "postmodernists" are; it appears to be any professor not in a STEM field. It goes through a bunch of unconnected anecdotes that, yes, illustrate a pattern and then says "this is bad, and it's due to postmodernism". In the parts where it attempts to make an argument, it misrepresents: >> This is a shift in Marxist theory from class conflict to identity politics conflict; instead of judging people by the content of their character, they are now to be judged by the color of their skin (or their ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, et cetera). I hear this talking point a lot, but that argument is a straw-man. The argument is not that people should be "judged by the color of their skin". The point is that they already are, frequently in subtle ways. You therefore have to address these things explicitly if you're to have any hope of counteracting them. If you don't, you're perpetuating the status quo without addressing how we got to it or what its problems might be.[1] >> Students are being taught by these postmodern professors that there is no truth, that science and empirical facts are tools of oppression by the white patriarchy, and that nearly everyone in America is racist and bigoted Are they actually being taught that "there is no truth"? I suspect that it's more like "The way we frame and talk about 'truth' is itself the result of political and social forces, and that framework of conservation is worth examining critically." I haven't read enough postmodernist philosophy to be sure. Neither, I suspect, has the author of the OP. As for the "everyone is racist" thing, this is, again, frequently misrepresented. It conjures up images of professors telling their students that everybody is throwing around racial slurs behind their backs. The actual point is that our society suffers from systemic racism, and everybody living in it plays a part, and it's important to be conscious of that part. Listen, maybe you disagree with all of this. You're allowed. But if you want to argue, you should argue against the strongest points being made, rather than the points drawn from articles written by people whose goal is to point and laugh. Recognize that, if you've never opened up a book on gender theory or literary criticism, then you are maybe not qualified to reject the entire fields out of hand. [1](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=36FbHXsEuzM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=36FbHXsEuzM), a clip from the noted philosophical work Adventure Time.
- creaghpatr 9y ago>Listen, maybe you disagree with all of this. You're allowed. On some campuses, you are absolutely not allowed. Consider the fallout from Mizzou in 2015.