2 ms·
Not everyone is an aerospace investment banker so don’t be a dick. Trying to learn here, not be belittled.
by samstave 9y ago
Not everyone is an aerospace investment banker so don’t be a dick.
Trying to learn here, not be belittled.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoThere were a lot of questions your comment could imply. I couldn’t think of a simpler way to request clarification. Didn’t mean to offend. On Earth we’re used to power scaling with maximum speed because of drag. In space, there is no drag. The weakest engine can propel something to close to the speed of light given the time and energy. There is a measure called specific impulse. It asks how long an engine would hover if fuelled with a take-off weight ratio of one in Earth’s gravity (ignoring the mass of structure, tanks, et cetera). I don’t have an answer for this engine, but ion thrusters clock in around 30,000 seconds while most rockets are between 250 and 500. Terminal velocity relates to the interaction between drag and an object in free fall.
- samstave 9y agoMy apologies, Appreciate the response.
- samstave 9y agoYes, ok I understand your confusion to my comment as I had forgotten that terminal velocity applies to atmospheric based objects? But I haven’t thought about specific impulse much, so I am very naïve (but curious) So, what, if any, does the mass of the object being pushed by an engine with the 5.4 Newton’s of energy have of the ability of the engine to push it? If you push a 1-ton thing with 5.4, and a 100-ton thing with 5.4 Newtons will they reach mars at the same time? And what will be the fuel consumption diff?
- zamalek 9y ago> ability of the engine to push it Acceleration. For equal mass a more powerful engine would make the object go faster, faster. > If you push a 1-ton thing with 5.4, and a 100-ton thing with 5.4 Newtons will they reach mars at the same time? Force = Mass * Acceleration Acceleration = Force / Mass a: 5.4 / 1000 = 0.0054m/ss b: 5.4 / 100 000 = 0.000054m/ss As the space-crow flies, the 100 ton thing would take longer - it's accelerating 100 times slower. You also have to factor in the mass of the fuel, both starting weight and consumption. As the engine depletes the fuel reserves it gets lighter and therefore accelerates faster (increased Jerk[1]). So if the 100 ton engine was a chemical engine the situation might be different. The following would be the same time: "assuming reactionless drives, if you push a 1-ton thing with 5.4N, and a 100-ton thing with 540N." [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jerk_(physics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jerk_(physics)
- samstave 9y agoI dont know why - but I was under some weird impression that mass is less affected in space due to lack of drag.... Stupid thing to think. I guess that this is why the slingshot method is so important.
- zamalek 9y ago> Stupid thing to think. There's a difference between stupid and unaware. We live in an environment that is vastly different to space. You have to know quite a bit of Newtonian mechanics before it really starts making intuitive sense. Asking questions is how you get there.
- samstave 9y agoLiving in the small town of Newton NC, my car broke down and I took it into the exclusive dealership and shop I got it from - the only place I know - but It wouldn’t budge after I got there. Completely motionless. I asked the guy to fix it and he exclaimed “oh, sorry can’t help you there - all of these cars are dead. We can’t work on any of these! It will tend to just stay!” Just then, another car of the exact same model and color drove out of the lot, right by us! I said “what! That’s the same freaking car! Same color and body style and everything!” And he said, well you can find another person to try to work on it, but that body tends to stay in motion, this one... not so much... Clearly I don’t know enough Newtonian mechanics!
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> mass is less affected in space due to lack of drag Your intuition is closer to correct than many might think. It's harder to move massive things than non-massive things in space. This is because of inertia. Inertia may be more fundamental to physics than mass [1], and could be thought of as matter "dragging" against the gluon (and possibly other) fields [2]. [1] https://www.princeton.edu/~pear/pdfs/2001-inertial-mass-quantum-vacuum-fields.pdf https://www.princeton.edu/~pear/pdfs/2001-inertial-mass-quan... [2] http://web.mit.edu/physics/news/physicsatmit/physicsatmit_03_wilczek_originofmass.pdf http://web.mit.edu/physics/news/physicsatmit/physicsatmit_03...
- natosaichek 9y agoThat's not what specific impulse is... Or at least, I've never heard it explained that way. Certainly no chemical thruster has a specific impulse in the thousands. The SSME was the most efficient chemical rocket for a long time, with an Isp of ~450 seconds. Specific impulse is directly proportional to exhaust velocity, and the units of "seconds" come dividing the velocity (m/s) by the acceleration of gravity (m/s^2) leaving 'seconds'.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoPre-coffee brain fart. Should be 250 to 500. The physical analogy is, within approximation, an accurate way to think about isp.